Can parental nudges improve early literacy in Sub-Saharan Africa? Experimental evidence from three contexts

How to cite

Rodriguez-Segura, Daniel; Castleman, Benjamin; Schueler, Beth. 2021. "Can parental nudges improve early literacy in Sub-Saharan Africa? Experimental evidence from three contexts." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005569. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5569-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Daniel Rodriguez-Segura* , Benjamin Castleman , Beth Schueler

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0005569
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5569-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2021-07-01 – 2022-02-28
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I21 Analysis of Educational, I25 Education and Economic Development, I28 Government Policy
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5569

Abstract

Education systems around the world have successfully leveraged additional family time and resources to further support children in the acquisition of their foundational literacy skills (e.g., Mayer et al, 2019; Teepe, et al, 2019 in the U.S., Knauer et al., 2019 in Kenya). However, these interventions tend to come with a relatively high price tag, and especially in low-income settings, can target parents with low educational attainment that may not be familiar with the best approaches to support their children’s education (Muralidharan et al., 2019; Portela and Atherton, 2020). In response to this, we evaluate an intervention that provides repeated low-cost reading materials, and low-touch behavioral encouragement to engage parents in their children’s literacy development process. We study the effectiveness of the repeated provision of properly leveled, low-cost, scaffolded materials (“postcards”) which guide parents through reading exercises they can perform with their children twice a week in an effort to improve early literacy outcomes. As such, we study this intervention through a randomized controlled trial of first graders during their first term across 112 private schools in Kenya, 42 private schools in Lagos (Nigeria), and 446 public schools in Lagos (Nigeria). Our experimental sample consists of over 23,000 students across these three settings.

Additionally, we investigate how the same educational intervention is implemented differently in three different settings. Contextual factors, implementation quality, and participant take-up are at the heart of the effectiveness of all development interventions. However, to date, much of the education literature in low- and middle-income countries has focused on the effectiveness, rather than on the rigorous documentation of the extent to which the local adoption and adaptation moderated their success. In this pre-registered analysis plan, we include a framework for how we will evaluate the implementation of the intervention in the three contexts based on our ex-ante theory of change. This framework will allow us to provide empirical evidence on the extent to which the same intervention was implemented differently in three contexts, and whether this moderated the effectiveness of the intervention.

Please see the attached document for further details on this study.

Intervention

The specific treatment consists of a “postcard” that students will receive every Monday throughout a full term (~15 weeks). This postcard contains two short reading passages, and one reading comprehension exercise on both sides and provides guidance for parents on how to engage on these passages and comprehension activities with their children. The content is largely the same across contexts, but the vocabulary and to a lesser degree the difficulty of the passages were adapted for each context. In an effort to maximize comparability across contexts, this intervention is set to start during the same school term (Term 1) across all three contexts.

The mechanics of the exercises are as follows: one side of the postcard is designed to be completed the same Monday the child brings the postcard home, and the other side is designed to be completed the following Thursday. Every Thursday afternoon, our partner will send parents an SMS text reminding them to complete the exercise. In an effort to increase perceived accountability of parents, each side of the postcard will have a designated space for parents to sign and acknowledge that they completed that day’s exercise. Furthermore, every Friday, students are encouraged to bring the signed postcards back to their teachers to check for completion.

Experimental design

To minimize potential spillovers of the treatment, we randomly allocate treatment at the school level. To increase power, we stratify within each context based on the wealth level of the community surrounding each school, and the relative baseline performance. Within each strata, we randomly select one school to be treated.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization performed using Stata 17 by researchers.
Randomization unit
Schools
Clusters
602 schools. Of these, 112 schools are in Kenya, 42 in Lagos (private), and 448 in Lagos (public). The appendix includes a table with descriptive statistics and sample balance across treatment and control schools for all three contexts. The appendix also provides visual representations of where these schools are geographically located.
Observations
Approximately 23,200 students across all three contexts.
Arms
56 treatment and 56 control schools in Kenya. 21 treatment and 21 control schools in Lagos (private). 140 treatment schools and 308 control schools in Lagos (public). In total, there are 217 total treatment schools, covering approximately 8360 treated students.
Primary outcomes
1. Oral reading fluency (measured in units of correct words per minute) 2. Standardized school grades for English and Kiswahili around the midterm (~6-7 weeks after the expected start of the intervention) and endterm (~13 weeks after the expected start) 3. Student dropout 4. Teacher survey on project implementation, and teacher beliefs and attitudes, also to be used to explore mechanisms 5. Parent survey on project take-up, and parent beliefs and attitudes, also to be used to explore mechanisms
Secondary outcomes
To explore potential heterogeneity of our results, we will use individual level data on gender, school, and baseline grades. Similarly, we also use regional data on community size (population), poverty levels, adult female literacy, and relative wealth within each country.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords