Overcoming social disadvantages through reinforcement of babble in infants from low socioeconomic homes

How to cite

Keren-Portnoy, Tamar; Kanaan, Mona; DePaolis, Rory; Daffern, Helena. 2020. "Overcoming social disadvantages through reinforcement of babble in infants from low socioeconomic homes." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005552. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5552-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Tamar Keren-Portnoy* , Mona Kanaan , Rory DePaolis , Helena Daffern

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0005552
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5552-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2020-09-01 – 2022-11-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D19, J13, Z13
Secondary IDs
SRG19\190697 (Funder: British Academy)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5552

Abstract

Babble is the consonant-vowel syllabic vocalisations (e.g., ‘dadada’) produced by infants typically from 7 months of age and is the precursor to spoken language. Whilst early babbling and first word production are known to be related, a causal relationship has not yet been experimentally established. This project will address this through a new intervention aimed at infants from lower-SES families.
Such infants are at risk for slower-than-typical early word production. It is well established that children from such families have much less adult speech addressed to them than children from middle-SES families, and their language on entering nursery/reception is less advanced than that of children from middle-SES families. We suspect that the lower exposure to speech in those infants begins in their first year – low-SES-infants’ babble receives fewer adult responses contingent on their vocalisations at age 11 months than does that of middle-SES infants and they engage in fewer verbal interactions with adults and vocalise less than middle-SES infants, even though they begin babbling at a similar age.
The intervention will be delivered using an iPad game (BabblePlay) which we have designed, that rewards infants with moving shapes appearing on the screen when they vocalise.The app responds to voiced infant utterances in real time with colourful moving shapes, providing reinforcement to all vocalisations within an infant’s pitch range that are not too loud (so as not to encourage shouting and crying). It does not respond to environmental sounds such as bangs, rustling and traffic noise.
We predict that infants who have used BabblePlay will have larger vocabularies than those who have not, and that their parents’ attitudes towards talking to infants will become more favorable as a result.

Intervention

We will recruit 7-month-old infants from low SES families in the York area. Infants will be randomly divided into two groups: Infants in the experimental group (n = 42) will receive the BabblePlay app to use in the home for 3 weeks. The control group (n = 42) will receive an app that does not respond to voice, but only to touch (shapes will disappear when touched).
We will follow the two groups until the infants are 16 months old.

Experimental design

Apart from the difference between the apps, the procedures and measures taken will be identical for the two groups.
During the initial 3 weeks infants will use the apps twice a day (or as close as possible to that). The apps work for 5 minutes at a time and then turn themselves off.
Following those first 3 weeks, participation will involve filling in questionnaires periodically (about general development, reaching development and language development), until the child turns 16 months.

Design details

Randomization method
Block randomisation will be done by the PI in the office using the "rand()" command in Excel. The project administrator will not be blind to the group that participants are assigned to, since she will need to give each family an iPad with the correct app on it and to teach the family to use it.
Randomization unit
Individual.
Clusters
0
Observations
84 infants.
Arms
42 infants in Experimental group, 42 infants in Control group.
Primary outcomes
1) Productive lexicon size at 16 months, assessed based on the 'The UK Communicative Development Inventories' (Alcock, Meints & Rowland, 2020) - using short form
Secondary outcomes
2) Receptive lexicon size at 16 months, assessed based on the 'The UK Communicative Development Inventories' (Alcock, Meints & Rowland, 2020) - using short form 3) Productive lexicon trajectory between 7 to 16 months, assessed based on the 'The UK Communicative Development Inventories' sort form (Alcock, Meints & Rowland, 2020) 4) Receptive lexicon trajectory between 7 to 16 months, assessed based on the 'The UK Communicative Development Inventories' short form (Alcock, Meints & Rowland, 2020) 5) Change in parental attitudes between 7 and 16 months, based on the Kennison & Byrd-Craven 2015 parent belief questionnaire. 6) Average number of vocalisations (or maximal number of vocalisations) per session in the three final days of use (maximal number of 6 sessions, at 2 per day for 3 days), based on the vocalisation counts as recorded by the two apps. 7) Change in the number of vocalisations over time, based on the counts of the two apps, as recorded over the entire 3-week period in which each infant uses it. 8) Score at 16 months on the subtest of the motor skills section from the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale. 9) Trajectory of change from 7 to 16 months on the subtest of the motor skills section from the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords