The Impact of a Smartphone Marketing Application on Smallholder Livestock Producers in Nepal

How to cite

Mullally, Conner; Miller, Scott; Janzen, Sarah; Magnan, Nicholas. 2020. "The Impact of a Smartphone Marketing Application on Smallholder Livestock Producers in Nepal." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005545. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5545-4.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Conner Mullally* , Scott Miller , Sarah Janzen , Nicholas Magnan

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0005545
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5545-4.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2018-01-01 – 2020-12-31
Countries
Nepal ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5545

Abstract

Can smartphone applications be harnessed to raise the incomes of smallholder farmers? Although previous literature has shown that access to mobile phones and mobile phone-based interventions can positively affect smallholder farmers, little is known about the effects of introducing smartphone applications (apps) designed to solve market problems and increase economic activity. In this pre-analysis plan, we propose to evaluate the effects of a smartphone-based, information-sharing app for livestock producers known as the ``Virtual Collection Center''. Our population of interest consists of smallholder goat producers in rural Nepal, all of whom are women and are members of producer cooperatives. We will estimate average and heterogeneous treatment effects of the app in four domains: information sharing, animals sold, prices received and cooperative-level management outcomes. Our study will contribute to two areas of interest where little evidence currently exists: the potential of smartphone apps as a tool for agricultural development, and business development for agricultural cooperatives in developing countries.

Intervention

We propose to evaluate the effects of a smartphone-based information-sharing app for livestock producers known as the ``Virtual Collection Center'' (VCC). Our population of interest consists of smallholder goat producers in rural Nepal, all of whom are women and members of producer cooperatives. The VCC allows rank-and-file cooperative members to regularly update leadership on available goat inventory. Cooperative leaders use this inventory information to negotiate bulk sales with traders, and then invite cooperative members to sales events through the app.

Experimental design

The impact of the VCC platform will be evaluated using a cluster RCT spanning 92 cooperatives in Nepal. Treatment was assigned at the cooperative level through a stratified randomization design as described in detail below. Treatment effects will be estimated at both the household and cooperative levels. The cooperatives in our study cover a wide geographic area. Based on conversations with HPIN, we understand cooperatives largely sell to local markets and buyers, such that broader macroeconomic price impacts (extending beyond the geographic borders within which the cooperative operates) are not anticipated. Cooperatives are geographically based, and members of a cooperative are only able to sell through their cooperative. Because cooperative membership comes through SHG membership, and SHG membership is extremely local (tole, or neighborhood), nonmembers would only be able to join their local cooperative and not a cooperative in a different treatment group.

To form strata prior to randomization, we first used the baseline data from both the household and cooperative leader survey to identify what we expect to be strong predictors of our outcomes of interest, including region (Terai and Mid-Hills), household goat revenue over the past 12 months, number of cooperative members, and cooperative revenue. Household goat revenue was top coded, replacing obvious outliers with reported number of goats sold multiplied by the median revenue per goat sold. The strata were then created using the following steps:
1. Dropping a single cooperative that was used in a pilot of the VCC app, leaving 107 cooperatives in total.
2. Sorting cooperatives within each region by average household-level goat revenue.
3. Splitting each region at its 33rd and 66th percentiles of average household goat revenue, yielding six bins.
4. Sorting cooperatives in each of the six bins by number of cooperative members.
5. Splitting each bin at the median number of cooperative members, yielding a total of 12 bins.
6. Sorting each of the 12 bins by cooperative revenue.
7. Splitting each bin at the median of cooperative-level revenue (from any source), yielding a total of 24 bins ranging in size from four to six cooperatives.
Within each cooperative, we generated a uniform random variable and assigned the two (in the case of strata with four or five members) or three (in the case of strata with six members) cooperatives with the greatest value of the random variable to treatment. For strata with five members, the odd-numbered cooperative was assigned to treatment with 50% probability using a uniform random variable.
Two complications arose around the time of treatment assignment. First, HPIN informed the research team that cooperatives in a single district could not be part of the randomization because the cooperatives work together to market goats. At that point, the randomization was complete and cooperatives had already been contacted to coordinate VCC app training. Therefore it would have been problematic to perform the randomization again. Instead, we verified that balance for our chosen indicators was maintained after dropping the cooperatives from the aforementioned district.2 The final treatment assignment includes 92 cooperatives in total, with 45 assigned to treatment and 47 assigned to control.
Second, a coding error occurred during the randomization that resulted in 39 of 92 cooperatives being assigned to strata using the wrong value of total cooperative revenue. Fortunately, the damage caused by the error was minimal. Total cooperative revenue was used at the lowest level of stratification, and no household-level variables were affected. Total cooperative revenue is almost identical on average in treatment and control cooperatives.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization in office by computer (Stata).
Randomization unit
Cooperatives
Clusters
92
Observations
2800
Arms
27
Primary outcomes
Our outcomes of interest are organized around four research questions: •Question 1:Does access to the VCC application improve communication within coopera-tives? 1a) Household is aware of whether or not their cooperative organizes goat sales with traders(0/1) 1b) Household was contacted at least once about cooperative goat sale in past 12 months(0/1) 1c) Administrative transparency index (continuous) 1d) Economic services transparency index (continuous) Question 2:Does access to the VCC application increase goat sales? 2a) Number of goats sold by the household through the cooperative (count) 2b) Number of goats sold by the household (count) Question 3:Does the VCC application increase prices received for goats? 3a) Revenue per goat sold through the cooperative (USD) 3b) Revenue per goat sold (USD) Question 4:Does access to the VCC application improve the planning horizon and expectations of cooperative leaders? 4a) Planning time horizon (years) 4b) Number of goats expected to be sold through cooperative in next six months (count) 4c) Total revenue expected to be earned by cooperative in next six months (USD)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords