The demand for and the impact of formal property rights in Dar es Salaam

How to cite

Collin, Matthew; Sandefur, Justin; Ali, Daniel Ayelew; Deininger, Klaus; Dercon, Stefan; Zeitlin, Andrew. 2020. "The demand for and the impact of formal property rights in Dar es Salaam." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005529. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5529-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Matthew Collin* , Justin Sandefur , Daniel Ayelew Ali , Klaus Deininger , Stefan Dercon , Andrew Zeitlin

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0005529
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5529-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2010-05-01 – 2016-02-29
Countries
Tanzania, United Republic of ()
JEL codes
H42 J16 K11 O18 Q15
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5529

Abstract

This study had two main goals. The first was to investigate the impact of formal property rights on a wide range of outcomes, including investment incentives, expropriation risk, credit access and property market outcomes. In addition to this, the study was designed specifically to increase the proportion of formal property owners who were female, and thus aimed to understand whether households were less likely to obtain a formal title when a woman would be registered as a co-owner. To these ends, the trial was run in two adjacent unplanned settlements in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. Blocks of informally-held land parcels were randomly-selected: treatment parcels received cadastral surveying and subsidized access to formal titles (CROs) as well as assistance with the relevant paperwork, where control parcels had to access CROs at their full price and obtain cadastral surveying on their own. In addition to this block level randomization, parcels within treatment blocks received vouchers, allocated in a public lottery, which reduced their subsidized price by a further 20-80%. A random subset of these vouchers had a condition: that at least one woman was included as a co-owner of the property upon registration. This design allowed the research team to identify the demand curve for CROs while also understanding if gender conditionality depressed demand.

Intervention

There were two levels to the intervention, a block-level intervention and a parce-level intervention.

In two communities, parcels were divided up into contiguous `blocks’ of 40-50 parcels each. Parcels in treatment blocks and their owners were:

Provided with a free cadastral survey, demarking the boundaries with cement beacons.
Invited to local meetings run by a local NGO (the Women’s Advancement Trust - WAT) to discuss their involvement in the project and the benefits of obtaining a land title.
Invited to apply for a Certificate of Right of Occupancy (CRO) for their land, with support from WAT, for a heavily-subsidized price of 100,000 Tanzanian Shillings (TSh), to be paid for over a period of 5-6 months.

Parcels in control blocks were still able to obtain a CRO, but did not receive a cadastral survey, any support or subsidization. In addition to this block level randomization, parcels within treatment blocks were allocated vouchers which further discounted the cost they would pay for a CRO. These vouchers could take on values of 20, 40, 60 or 80k TSh. There were two voucher types: one could be applied to the cost of a CRO without condition, the other could only be applied if, during the CRO application process, the household included at least one woman as a co-owner of the property. A parcel could be allocated both types of vouchers at the same time. Names of households that chose to apply a conditional voucher were checked at the time of application to ensure their compliance.

Following these two interventions, owners of parcels in treated blocks were allowed to sign up and begin repaying at will.

Note: due to several adverse circumstances, there was no actual distribution of CROs following the application process. The Tanzanian government decided to raise the price of CROs being charged to the project, drastically increasing the cost of providing them. Second, following the initial sign up phase, the Government of Tanzania declared a large proportion of the study area to be ineligible for land titling

Experimental design

The first level of the intervention was block-level randomization (within each of the two communities). Parcels were divided into contiguous blocks of 40-50 and randomly allocated to treatment and control groups. Re-randomization was used to achieve balance on several pre-intervention characteristics.

The second level of the intervention was, within treatment blocks, a parcel level randomization. Parcels were allocated vouchers which further discounted the cost they would pay for a CRO. These vouchers could take on values of 20, 40, 60 or 80k TSh and could either be unconditional or conditional (see above). The randomization method is described below.

Design details

Randomization method
First level: done in office by computer Second level: a combination of computer and public lottery using the following process: For each block, 100 draws of general/conditional voucher distributions were drawn We tested balance using several parcel-level pre-treatment characteristics (using average t-stat values) and kept the three most balanced draws. Draws were presented as three folders to attendees of block-level community meetings. One of the attendees was nominated by the community to choose one of the three folders (draws) and the result was the final allocation.
Randomization unit
First level: block Second level: parcel
Clusters
Planned Number of clusters Block level randomization: Community 1 - 20 blocks Community 2 - 30 blocks
Observations
Planned Number of Observations Block level randomization: Community 1: 919 Community 2: 1,362 Parcel level randomization: Community 1: 463 Community 2: 683
Arms
Sample Size (or number of clusters) by treatment arms Block level randomization: Community 1 - 10 treatment, 10 control Community 2 - 15 treatment, 15 control Parcel level randomization: * Community 1 * Unconditional | voucher | Conditional voucher value value | 0 20 40 60 80 | Total ------------------+-------------------------------------------------------+---------- 0 | 24 40 42 36 53 | 195 20 | 30 20 41 37 0 | 128 40 | 27 29 22 0 0 | 78 60 | 14 21 0 0 0 | 35 80 | 24 0 0 0 0 | 24 ------------------+---------------------------------------------------+---------- Total | 119 110 105 73 53 | 460 * Community 2* Unconditional | voucher | Conditional voucher value value | 0 20 40 60 80 | Total ------------------+-------------------------------------------------------+---------- 0 | 46 52 32 53 56 | 239 20 | 55 42 47 34 0 | 178 40 | 42 40 53 0 0 | 135 60 | 37 36 0 0 0 | 73 80 | 58 0 0 0 0 | 58 ------------------+-------------------------------------------------------+---------- Total | 238 170 132 87 56 | 683
Primary outcomes
Primary outcomes of interest for the block-level randomization include: Household investment in the parcel Perceptions of the parcel’s risk of expropriation, land disputes and actual expropriation events Access to credit Perceived sale price Household level economic outcomes (income, assets, employment, enterprise activity) These outcomes were measured at baseline, but no follow up was conducted due to the suspension of the block-level intervention (see above). Primary outcomes of interest for the voucher-level randomization included: Whether the owner of the parcel fully paid for a CRO through the program. Whether the household included at least one woman as an owner of the parcel. Several proxies for women’s empowerment (self-reported measures of control over money, assets and decision making; expenditure on children)
Sponsors
Name: World Bank Gender Action Plan Trust Fund Url: https://www.worldbank.org/ Name: Global Land Tool Network Url: https://gltn.net/ Name: World Bank Knowledge for Change Program Location: USA Url: https://www.worldbank.org/en/programs/knowledge-for-change Name: International Growth Centre Location: United Kingdom Url: https://www.theigc.org/
Partners
Name: WAT-Human Settlements Trust Partner_type: ngo Url: http://www.wat.or.tz/wathstaboutus.html

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords