Democratization by Accident: Does Development Aid Change Local Hierarchies?

How to cite

Koos, Carlo; Hager, Anselm. 2020. "Democratization by Accident: Does Development Aid Change Local Hierarchies?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005525. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5525-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Carlo Koos* , Anselm Hager

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0005525
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5525-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2018-12-01 – 2022-10-30
Countries
Liberia ()
JEL codes
D6, D7, O120, O43
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5525

Abstract

Governments of low-income countries often rely on development agencies to implement programs aiming at improving health, education and economic outcomes. Apart from these \textit{intended} effects, development programs can have powerful \textit{unintended} side-effects. In this study, we explore one such side-effect: democratization. Specifically, we assess whether a standard development intervention unintentionally changes local hierarchies to become more democratic. We propose two primary channels how development interventions affect social hierarchies. First, new political roles and committees challenge existing elites. Second, economic specialization brings people closer together and results in new interest groups. Both channels should, in theory, lead to more democratic local-level decision-making. We assess these hypotheses in post-conflict Liberia using a cluster-randomized controlled trial. This pre-analysis plan lays out our empirical strategy to assess the program's effect on local democratization.

Intervention

The program includes three key components, to which communities are randomly assigned: i) gender empowerment; ii) water, sanitation and hygiene; and iii) agricultural innovation. The specific program components are described below:

Gender empowerment (RRP-Gender)
The first arm of the program implements a gender empowerment program. The program is implemented by Medica Liberia in 15 villages. The goal of the program is to address sexualized and gender based violence through prevention and advocacy. To this end, Medica will set up institutionalized women support groups in beneficiary villages. The groups support women in employment related issues and provide a support network in case women are subjected to violence.

Water, sanitation and hygiene (RRP-WASH)
The second arm of the program implements a behavior change program. The program is implemented by WHH in 112 villages. The purpose of the program is to change respondents' behavior toward water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH). Specific behaviors that are addressed in the program include nutrition during pregnancy, food handling, handwashing practices, cleanliness (to avoid rodents). Apart from behavioral change campaigns, this program arm also includes the rehabilitation of water pumps and the assignment of maintenance responsibilities to community members.

Agricultural innovation (RRP-Agri)
The third arm of the program provides agricultural training and tools to men and women. The agriculture program is implemented by Oxfam and WHH in 61 villages. The program provides high-value crops to farmers (e.g., rice, cassava, plantain, pineapple, beans) and also implements training workshops in order to improve production, processing, storage and marketing. The program also promotes the use of vegetables in lowlands and backyard gardening in the uplands.

Experimental design

The program across the three treatment arms is implemented after the baseline survey
has concluded. It will last for one year after which a midline survey will be conducted.
After the midline survey concludes, the former control villages will receive the program
for one year. Once the program has been implemented everywhere, an endline survey
will be conducted. The program thus follows a cross-over design.

Design details

Randomization method
Computerized randomization
Randomization unit
Unit of randomization is the village
Clusters
121 villages
Observations
ca. 10,000 households x 3 (base-, mid-, endline)
Arms
After collecting baseline data, all 121 program villages were randomly assigned to the different program arms or a pure control. Importantly, not every program could be implemented in every village. As stated, 61 villages could receive RRP-Agri; 15 villages could receive RRP-Gender; and 112 villages could receive RRP-WASH. The reason for the different sample sizes is owing to budget and logistical constraints. Since our interest is in determining the effect of the three independent treatments relative to the control (as well as potential interaction effects), we devised the following factorial randomization scheme. First, we randomly assigned the 15 RRP-Gender villages to treatment or con- trol, blocking on whether any given village could also be assigned to RRP-Agri or RRP-WASH, respectively. Second, we randomly assigned the 61 RRP-Agri villages to treatment or control, blocking on whether any given village could also be assigned to RRP-Gender or RRP-WASH as well as whether any given village had already been assigned to treatment in the RRP-Gender. Third, we randomly assigned the 112 RRP- WASH villages to treatment or control, blocking on whether any given village could also be assigned to RRP-Agri or RRP-Gender, respectively, as well as blocking on whether a village was assigned to treatment in the two respective programs. The final assignment is provided in Section A. Table 1 (see PAP pdf) shows excellent balance for nine typical baseline measures.
Primary outcomes
Outcome 1: Community-decision making (battery of three questions) Outcome 2: Democratic values

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords