The Role of Hard and Soft Skills in Entrepreneurial Success: Experimental Evidence from Uganda
How to cite
Fiala, Nathan; Carney, Dana; Gertler, Paul. 2014. "The Role of Hard and Soft Skills in Entrepreneurial Success: Experimental Evidence from Uganda." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000550. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.550-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This project will investigate the relative importance of hard skills versus soft skills in business success and more broadly in the youth’s school-to-work transition. The project will strengthen, experimentally, the training of these skills among recently graduated Ugandan secondary school students. The goal of the current endeavor is to: (a) leverage insights from the economic and social sciences toward the goal of improving entrepreneurial success in developing countries, and (b) test whether “hard” versus “soft” skills better predict consequential entrepreneurial and business longevity outcomes, and a better performance in the labor market, particularly among young people and women.
Intervention
The role of the entrepreneur in business and development success has grown in interest among policy makers and researchers in both developed and developing economies. While often left out of formal theories, the entrepreneur plays a key role in the exchange of goods and development of innovation. The role of the entrepreneur in development is of especially important concern in regions where formal sector employment is scarce.
Uganda, like most low-income countries in the world, has a large share of youth who are either unemployed or underemployed. This is not only a concern of the welfare of these youth, but also a waste of valuable human capital available for economic growth. Youth living in these countries encounter numerous challenges entering into and succeeding in the labor market. Living in economies where employment opportunities are scarce and self-employment often the only option, youth need the right combination of human, financial, and social capital that will give them a chance to turn their energy and ideas into entrepreneurship opportunities that lead to the creation of more and better jobs.
Individuals often lack knowledge of the best practices of running of business, especially in developing countries, where education in general is often limited. An intervention growing in popularity is the introduction of business skills training. The goal is to increase the knowledge individual business owners have about doing business, and while doing so, also increase their returns and welfare.
A number of recent research projects have explored the impact of enterprise training and have found mixed results. Oosterbeek, van Praag and Ijsselstein (2010) find that business skills training has no effect on business outcomes. Bjorvatn and Tungodden (2010) find that business training in Tanzania has some effect on business knowledge, but no effect on business outcomes. Karlan and Valdivia (2006) include business training in a microfinance institute in Peru. The program lead to increased business knowledge, revenue and repayment rates, but had no effect on profits. Attanasio et al (2011) subsidized vocational training in Colombia and found income and employment increases for women, but none for men. Blattman, Fiala and Martinez (2011) find high returns to a grant program in Uganda for business training and capital for men and women, with large long-term effects for women. They find though that alleviating capital constraints were the major reason behind business success, with a small role for business training.
At best the current literature presents conflicting results of the usefulness of entrepreneurship training. At worst it suggests such programs are not sustainable. The questions being asked in the literature though are unsatisfactory when it comes to answering definitively the value of entrepreneurship training, in part because they are asking too broad of a question. Each of the evaluations described focus on a package of entrepreneurship training initiated by one or more NGOs or training facilities. It is not clear what exactly is in this package, whether it is comparable across programs or countries, or even whether it can be replicated in the same area. Rather than asking what makes a good entrepreneur, they are throwing a black box program at individuals and seeing if that particular program works in that particular place. It is not surprising then that the results are somewhat contradictory. Entrepreneurship training thus works for women only in some programs, or men only in others. Some increase revenues, other have no effect.
In order to determine if entrepreneurship can be taught, and if that teaching can then lead to real improved real world outcomes, a clear theory of the entrepreneur needs to be developed. The theory should then be tested through precise experiments that parse out the individual components of entrepreneurship to determine what, if anything, can be taught. This will lead to a clearer understanding of what enterprise training works, how it works, and if it can be replicated.
This pre-analysis plan is for an experiment to determine a major component of what type of training improves business development. We focus on the differential effect of what is commonly referred to as “hard” skills (e.g., financial decision making) and “soft” skills (e.g., negotiation and communication). This project will investigate the relative importance of hard skills versus soft skills in business success and more broadly in the youth’s school-to-work transition. The project will strengthen, experimentally, the training of these skills among recently graduated Ugandan secondary school students. The goal of the current endeavor is to: (a) leverage insights from the economic and social sciences toward the goal of improving entrepreneurial success in developing countries, and (b) test whether “hard” versus “soft” skills better predict consequential entrepreneurial and business longevity outcomes, and a better performance in the labor market, particularly among young people and women.
The hard skills training was built upon a currently existing hard skills-based curricula developed by the ILO called Know About Business (KAB), which has been run in over 40 countries worldwide. The newly developed curriculum will focus on financial literacy, the role of budgeting, calculating and keeping track of expenses, revenue and profits, the importance of re-investment for business growth, and a number of other topics.
The soft skills training was built upon existing soft skills-based curricula harvested from both the Young Entrepreneurs Program (YEP) and Educate!, a local NGO that mentors young people in starting businesses. These existing curricula will be refined through guidance from economic and social science research pointing to the critical importance of a few core social skills areas including: building and accessing social networks, how to influence and persuade, how to perceive and listen to others, and how to effectively and creatively negotiate. The full development of this component will build on the existing undergraduate business curriculum at major business school and will be adapted and rigorously piloted tested to match the Ugandan context.
As the target population of the evaluation is youth who have recently finished school, the research will first measure the effect of entrepreneurship training on attitudes and skills. The project will also measure the training on positive labor market outcomes and business success (such as self-employment, business creation, job creation through start-ups, and earnings). The project will then ultimately assess the importance of soft skills versus hard skills. The research will provide evidence on how these skills help to build better, sustainable and bankable businesses. To capture the chain of effects on young people’s decisions and outcomes and measure labor market outcomes, the first follow-up data collection will be conducted in the middle of 2015, two years after participants have finished the training.
Experimental design
Between November 2012 and April 2013, IPA sent 3 rounds of mass SMS reminders and did 2 rounds of intensive calling (i.e. called all individuals in the treatment group). The last round took place shortly before the program launch. Efforts to reach students or their close relatives on the phone included calling every phone number the student had provided at different times of day, and calling the school administrators and student leaders (whom IPA designated to help mobilize their peers).
Once the program had launched, teams in schools with low turnout also called students who didn't turn up. IPA offered a transport refund to each student as a part of efforts to encourage students to participate, a fact which was emphasized during initial recruitment, as many students had to travel long distances to attend the training.
To further reduce costs incurred by students, IPA organized mass transportation rather than expect students to find their own way to the training sites, some of which were relatively remote. The team asked students to meet at a well-known location in a nearby town, where IPA team members waited to greet students and load them onto buses to the training sites. About two-thirds of individuals in the treatment group eventually attended training.
To train SEED instructors, IPA partnered with Educate!, an NGO that delivers social entrepreneurship training and mentorship to Ugandan secondary-school students. Educate! periodically trains groups of potential teachers in general techniques for teaching entrepreneurship skills. Educate! recruited and trained the majority of the SEED teachers in two rounds in October 2012 and February 2013. After the pilot, the implementation team realized that it was necessary to increase the number of teachers at each training site in order to make their workload more manageable. Time constraints made it difficult for Educate! to train additional teachers, so IPA asked another education NGO called the Private Education Development Network (PEDN) to recruit and train a third group. After all teachers had undergone a general training in teaching methods, IPA trained them on the curriculum to which they had been assigned as well as the business plan curriculum.
The student trainings took place at secondary schools with which Innovations for Poverty Action partnered to implement the program. Students slept and boarded at the schools, attending training sessions during the day. Each student also wrote a business plan guided by daily instruction in the business plan curriculum; a cash grant of UGX 1,000,000 ($400) was awarded to the author of the highest quality business plan in each school (one out of every 100-120 students).
In addition to instructors, IPA trained two “camp directors” per training site to run the day-to-day operations, including handling finances, managing members of the school’s support staff that IPA retained, enforcing discipline, and organizing sports and social activities. The camp directors were supervised by a Field Officer, who was in turn supervised by a regional Field Manager. In January 2013, IPA carried out a pilot in a non-sample district to test the logistical arrangements and curriculum quality, making adjustments to the implementation plan accordingly.
A team of IPA-trained auditors observed teachers’ lessons on a rotating basis, using forms that recorded teachers’ adherence to lesson content, application of quality teaching methods, and details on the learning environment. In addition, students were asked to complete a variety of self-administered evaluations over the course of the training that asked about teaching quality, relevance of lessons, student characteristics, and their experience of SEED camp, among others. They also completed a knowledge assessment covering both hard and soft skills at the beginning and end of the camp. Auditors conducted focus groups at the end of the first and final weeks of the training that delved more deeply into student opinions on the lessons, teaching, and overall experience. Finally, teachers recorded student attendance at the start of each lesson.
A variety of problems arose over the course of the training. In some schools, students complained about the food provided, poor dormitory conditions, and particular camp rules. This was typically addressed by having one of the higher-level SEED supervisors step in, for instance to monitor the school support staff to improve food quality. Some students had been under the impression that SEED would be a relatively luxurious training given the involvement of foreign donors and the way it had been advertised (a free training with an opportunity to win cash grants) and were disappointed with the food quality and actual number of cash grants to be awarded, for instance. At one school, students briefly went on strike over such issues before higher-level SEED organizers were able to calm them down.
In one school the living conditions were very poor, which had demoralizing effects on the teachers and students. The implementation team worked quickly to shift all the students to a nearby SEED school that could accommodate them. In the same school shortly before the move, a student went to the nearby river to swim, despite warnings by school administrators, and drowned. The incident caused significant distress among teachers and students; lessons were canceled for two days and began again the following Monday.
One the final night of training in one of the rural schools, one of the auditors reportedly was out in the nearby town until very late at night with the school doctor and three female students. He was also observed on multiple occasions assisting one of the students with her business plan. This was the only reported case of inappropriate conduct between IPA staff and trainees.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.