Elicitation of beliefs in light of dynamic new information: a laboratory experiment
How to cite
Proto, Eugenio; Becker, Christoph; Trautmann, Stefan; Sofianos, Andis; Melkonyan, Tigran. 2020. "Elicitation of beliefs in light of dynamic new information: a laboratory experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005499. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5499-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Bayesian Updating is the dominant theory of learning in economics and other disciplines. According to this theory, decision-makers have prior beliefs which they update according to Bayes rule after receiving new information. The theory is silent about how individuals react to receiving information that the subjects have not observed previously and, hence, which they may deem impossible. Recent theoretical literature has put forth a possible mechanism, called “reverse Bayesianism”, which decision-makers may use to react to unforeseen events. We started to explore experimentally testing reverse Bayesianism in a previous experiment (AEARCTR-0003815). Our experimental findings show that participants are consistent with the theory, while they do not show to have an expectation of the unknown.
Because of these findings, our goal in this project is to understand when individuals cease to expect something new. Additionally we aim to test reverse Bayesianism in a more dynamic context where more than one unforeseen event might occur. A summary description of our design follows. Participants will be asked to repeatedly draw coloured balls from a virtual urn. After every draw, participants are asked to declare their perceived proportion all colours that have been drawn until that point and for any other colour not yet drawn or observed. There will be a total of 30 draws and this will be repeated for 4 different virtual urns. The beliefs on the proportions of different colours will be incentivised using the Karni (2009) method.
We have two treatments. In the “2 - outcome” treatment, participants will first make draws out of a 2-outcome urn, while in the “4-outcome” treatment participants will first make draws out of 4-outcome urn. Following the first urn, the three following urns will be for both treatments: 3-outcome, 2-outcome and 4-outcome. In the supporting documents, we attach a diagram detailing this sequence for each treatment.
This design will allow us to explore if participants have an expectation of the unknown and additionally when does this expectation diminish. Contrasting our two treatments, will allow us to consider whether a difference between individuals that have experienced a broader environment or a narrower environment will exist. Specifically, how experience might cause an individual’s expectation of the unknown to diminish differently. Furthermore, we will be able to consider multiple instances of new events occurring and thus testing reverse Bayesianism in a more dynamic fashion. We will in particular address the following questions: Do individuals naturally expect events that were previously considered impossible? Does experience affect an individual’s expectation of unknown events? How do individuals update their beliefs about the urn composition after an unexpected event takes place?
Experimental design
We design an experiment where subjects are asked to report subjective probabilities of prizes after observing multiple draws from virtual urns. These elicitations are incentivised by using methods similar to Becker-DeGroot-Marschak (BDM) to report the subjective probability of prizes (see the enclosed documents for more details).
There are two treatments:
(1)
2-outcome treatment:
Participants make 30 draws out of a virtual urn. They are faced with 4 different urns in sequence. After every draw made they are asked to report their subjective probabilities for the each of the coloured balls they have observed until that point and additionally any other colour not observed yet. These inputs are forced to always sum up to 100, that is, participants are prompted to update their inputs if the subjective probabilities do not sum up to exactly 100. The first virtual urn participants in this treatment will contain two outcomes, the second will contain three outcomes, the third will contain two outcomes and the fourth will contain four outcomes. One randomly chosen subjective probability reported out of every of the four urns will be paid according to the Karni (2009) method. Details on this method are offered in the attached document.
(2)
4-outcome treatment:
The only difference to the 2-outcome treatment is that the first virtual urn will contain four outcomes. Otherwise, the two treatments are identical
Each session ends with a short incentivised Raven test and some general demographic questions.
Our specific hypotheses to be tested are included in the attached document.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.