We examine the role of third-order beliefs in shaping potentially stigmatized public behavior. We hypothesize that information, in addition to its persuasive effects, potentially also affects behavior by providing an "excuse" for engaging in xenophobic actions, leading to changes in equilibrium expression even among people who do not necessarily believe the information. The central implication of our theoretical framework is that people make different inferences about agents who engage in xenophobic actions when they know those agents have an "excuse" for doing so, relative to when they believe those agents do not have an "excuse". In particular, our framework predicts that when making inferences about agents with an excuse, respondents will believe these agents to be less biased than agents without an excuse. We test this prediction with an incentivized experiment eliciting respondents' beliefs about the characteristics of agents who chose to donate to an anti-immigrant organization with or without an excuse.
Experimental design
For the first experiment, we recruit respondents through Lucid, a survey provider. For the follow-up experiment, we recruit them through Prolific, another survey provider.
Design details
Randomization method
Qualtrics will randomize respondents into one of the four conditions. We use the "Evenly Presents Elements" option in the Qualtrics Randomizer to secure equal group sizes.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
In the first experiment, we target 3000 individuals (5163 individuals when pooling with pilot)
In the second experiment, we target 1000 individuals per topic (illegal immigration or defunding the police) for a total of 2000 individuals.
Observations
In the first experiment, we target 3000 individuals (5163 individuals when pooling with pilot)
In the second experiment, we target 1000 individuals per topic (illegal immigration or defunding the police) for a total of 2000 individuals.
Arms
In the first experiment, we target 750 individuals in excuse/gullibility, 750 individuals excuse/bias, 750 individuals no excuse/gullibility, 750 individuals no excuse/bias. To gain statistical precision, we also report some specifications in which we pool with additional pilot data (N=2163, with 517 excuse/gullibility, 510 excuse/bias, 502 no excuse/gullibility, and 511 no excuse/bias). In the second experiment, we target 500 individuals per treatment arm (excuse/no excuse) per topic (illegal immigration/defunding the police).
In the first experiment, we ask our survey provider to restrict the survey to respondents who had not taken our pilot. To further ensure that our sample does not include repeat respondents, we also include a post-outcome question asking respondents whether they have taken a previous online survey that discussed the Lott study. We expect this number to be small and plan to exclude respondents who respond in the affirmative from our main specifications (though we will also report results with the entire sample).
Primary outcomes
Respondent's guesses as to their matched respondent's score on the Foreign Culture Tolerance Scale and the Gullibility Scale (experiment 1)
Respondent's decision of whether or not to authorize a $1 bonus to their matched respondent and their guess of whether or not their matched respondent donated to the organization (follow-up)
Secondary outcomes
Open-ended text: "Why do you think your matched respondent chose to donate to Fund the Wall"?
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.