We study the impacts of an agricultural microcredit product for smallholder farmers on farm investment, farm performance, broader measures of economic performance, and household welfare.
Intervention
The intervention is the provision of a seasonal agricultural microcredit loan.
Experimental design
Access to agricultural microcredit is provided to a randomly-selected treatment group and not to a control group, within a set of farmers who showed interest in the agricultural microcredit product.
Design details
Randomization method
The randomization component is done based on the last digit of farmers' National Registration Card (NRC) number, which is effectively random. Treatment-control was divided based on even-odd last NRC digits.
Randomization unit
Individual borrower (representing an agricultural household).
Clusters
21 villages.
Observations
453 potential borrowers (leaders of agricultural households).
Arms
There are 356 treatment and 97 control. The distribution of treatment-control varies by cluster (village) as randomization was done at individual rather than cluster level.
At the time of the baseline survey, 342/453 households were successfully surveyed, a 75% response rate. Due to Covid-19, the endline survey was implemented as a phone survey, as in-person surveying was not legal in Myanmar at the time. At the time of the endline survey, we resurveyed baseline respondents, and also attempted to survey as many respondents who were missed at baseline (from the 25%), successfully reaching 94, so another 20.7% of the original sample of 453. We implemented a modified survey instrument at endline with this group, which also asked about a subset of variables that would have been asked at baseline. This allowed us to partially reconstruct a baseline-endline panel.
Of the 342 baseline respondents, only 1 attritted in the endline phone survey, so we resurveyed 341 baseline respondents at endline. Added to the 94 who were missed in the original baseline, that gives us 435 total respondents (a 96% overall response rate), 341 who have full baseline-endline panel data, and 94 who have partial baseline-endline panel data.
We can also break down these figures by sample group, which we describe as group 1 (188 randomized treatment), group 2 (168 credit officer selected treatment), and group 3 (97 control).
-Group 1. 186 completed, 2 not completed = 188. Of the 186, 152 responded at baseline and endline, and 34 only at endline.
-Group 2. 162 completed, 6 not completed = 168. Of the 162, 124 responded at baseline and endline, and 38 only at endline.
-Group 3. 87 completed, 10 not completed = 97. Of the 87, 65 responded at baseline and endline, and 22 only at endline.
Primary outcomes
Our theory of change is that seasonal agricultural microcredit loans should primarily be invested in agricultural activity. Since the loans are provided very close to planting season, they should lead to a genuine increase in access to finance for the winter agricultural season, rather than providing a slightly lower-cost source of financing. Hence loan recipients should have greater capital to invest in agriculture, rather than substituting for other loans.
Given their timing and purpose, we expect loans to be used on variable inputs such as seeds, fertilizer, and labor inputs. Hence we should see impacts on these agricultural investments, both in the monetary value invested in inputs, and the likelihood of accessing key types of inputs. It is also possible that access to loans would lead to a change in cropping patterns, e.g., devoting more land or investment to a more input intensive crop. So we will study the crop mix, but we don't have strong priors here.
In principle, increases in agricultural investment should lead to increases in agricultural productivity and outcomes, in particular, total yield, which can be measured in quantity terms (e.g., kilograms or volume-based measures of yield). Increases in yields should lead to increases in agricultural revenue. While loan recipients might also increase expenditure through use of loan proceeds, on net they should have higher profits than non-recipients.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes concern off-farm outcomes: non-farm business and earnings activity, household labour market outcomes, and broader outcomes for the household.
With respect to other economic activity, we will focus on investments and returns from non-farm businesses, and labour earnings.
With respect to other household outcomes, we will construct the Probability of Poverty Index (based on the Myanmar PPI), and calculate other monetary measures of household outcomes including expenditure on health and education, transfer receipts, and food security. In particular, we will look at a measure of 4-weeks' consumption, and likelihood of households needing to ration meals.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.