Guiding Managers to Increase Wage Equity: A Field Experiment in a Company

How to cite

Deversi, Marvin; Sliwka, Dirk. 2020. "Guiding Managers to Increase Wage Equity: A Field Experiment in a Company." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005389. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5389-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Marvin Deversi* , Dirk Sliwka

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0005389
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5389-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2020-02-05 – 2020-04-06
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93, D63, J31, M52
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5389

Abstract

Our project investigates whether a simple decision guidance can help managers to achieve more equitable reward decisions. We study this question in partnership with a large software company that wants to strengthen equity considerations in the annual salary planning process. We evaluate the decision guidance using a Randomized Controlled Trial. In the treatment groups, the guidance is implemented into the software tool used by managers when they determine the annual salary increases. It provides a proposed merit increase value for each of the managers' team members. Post-experimental surveys and operational data from the company records (including, e.g., other reward instruments or utilization rates of consultants) complement our experimental data on managers' decision-making about merit increases.

Intervention

We implement a decision guidance into the software tool used by managers when they determine the annual salary increases (the “merit increase”) for their direct subordinates. The guidance tool provides a proposed merit increase value for each employee. The guidance value is calculated based on this employee's position in wage range, which refers to a pre-specified salary band for each combination of career level and job function in the company. The higher the employee's position in wage range, the lower is the guidance value. If the managers follow the guidance this should lead to a more compressed wage distribution within the pre-specified salary bands. However, managers still have their full discretion and can deviate from the guidance as they wish and are made aware of this. To allow managers to follow the guidance, we also adjust the budgeting approach as compared to previous salary increase cycles such that the sum of guidance values equals the available team budget.

Experimental design

The intervention affects managers from different countries (US, India, and several European countries) in several units of the firm. We randomly assign managers into one of four treatment groups.

(1) STATUS QUO: No guidance value is provided. The merit process follows the same budgeting approach as in the previous year. No information on the average team budget is provided.

(2) CONTROL: No guidance value is provided. The merit process follows the new budgeting approach that is based on the guidance values (sum of guidance values equals team budget). Managers receive information on the average budget per team member.

(3) GUIDANCE VALUE: A guidance value is provided. The merit process follows the new budgeting approach that is based on the guidance values (sum of guidance values equals team budget). Managers receive information on the average budget per team member.

(4) GUIDANCE RANGE: A guidance range is provided ([-10% of guidance value, +10% of guidance value]). The merit process follows the new budgeting approach that is based on the guidance values (sum of guidance values equals team budget). Managers receive information on the average budget per team member.

Comparing (2) and (3) shows the causal effects of the guidance value.
Comparing (1) and (2) shows the causal effects of the new budgeting approach.
Comparing (3) and (4) shows the causal effects of using the guidance value versus using the guidance range allowing to study differences in manager’s accountability for the merit increase.

Design details

Randomization method
Stratified randomization (stratification by country and board area) done in office by a computer using stata.
Randomization unit
Randomization takes place on the manager level. Each manager makes several salary increase decisions such that we cluster on the manager level.
Clusters
624 managers
Observations
We observe merit increase decisions for 9,073 employees.
Arms
STATUS QUO: 72 managers CONTROL: 186 managers GUIDANCE VALUE: 185 managers GUIDANCE RANGE: 181 managers
Primary outcomes
Managers' merit increase decisions
Secondary outcomes
(a) survey measures; (b) utilization rate;

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords