Beyond Bias: Reducing Provider Bias Towards Adolescents to Increase Contraception Take-Up in Tanzania, Burkina Faso, and Pakistan

How to cite

Wagner, Zachary; Moucheraud, Corrina; Wollum, Allie; Shah, Manisha; Dow, William; Friedman, Willa. 2020. "Beyond Bias: Reducing Provider Bias Towards Adolescents to Increase Contraception Take-Up in Tanzania, Burkina Faso, and Pakistan." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005354. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5354-2.3

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Zachary Wagner* , Corrina Moucheraud , Allie Wollum , Manisha Shah , William Dow , Willa Friedman

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0005354
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5354-2.3
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2019-09-01 – 2021-09-30
Countries
Burkina Faso (), Pakistan (), Tanzania, United Republic of ()
JEL codes
I1, I14, I12
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5354

Abstract

We evaluate the impact of an intervention designed to reduce family planning provider bias towards young, unmarried, and nulliparous women in Tanzania, Burkina Faso, and Pakistan. The intervention has three components: 1) a summit that highlight the consequences of provider bias and instructions on how not to be biased, 2) a forum for continued communication between providers and implementation staff that reinforces the information from the summit, and 3) a rewards program where facilities in which providers exhibit less biased client interactions or who have improved the most towards this end are rewarded with social recognition and a ceremony. We randomized half of the eligible clinics in each country to receive the intervention and the other half to be a control group. We evaluate the impact of the intervention on a range of outcomes using four types of quantitative data: 1) provider surveys, 2) mystery client visits, 3) client exit surveys, and 4) service provision data routinely collected by the clinics. We report the impact of the intervention on providers’ biased attitudes and beliefs, family planning counseling, family planning methods dispensed, and client perceptions of family planning care. We contextualize our quantitative results with qualitative interviews with key stakeholders, managers, providers, and clients. The document outlines our general analysis plan. This document is in a “rough draft” format but nonetheless pre-specifies our main approach. Some of the writing will be included verbatim in the final paper and thus is written in the past tense (even though most of the work has yet to be performed).

Intervention

The intervention has three components: 1) a summit that includes impactful stories told to and by family planning providers that highlight the consequences of provider bias, 2) a forum for continued communication between providers, and 3) a rewards program where clinics in which providers exhibit less biased client interactions or who have improved the most towards this end will be rewarded with social recognition and a ceremony.

Experimental design

Among the eligible facilities in each country, half of the facilities will be randomly assigned to receive implementation of the “Beyond Bias” intervention, while the other facilities will serve as a control group—standard adolescent and youth sexual and reproductive health or family planning program interventions—to establish a counterfactual. Provider-level assignment is infeasible due to the nature of the interventions: all providers within a given facility will have the same assignment as the facility.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office using Stata
Randomization unit
Clinic
Clusters
235 clinics (Tanzania: 75; Burkina Faso: 78; Pakistan: 80)
Observations
91,000 exit surveys (Tanzania: 39,000; Burkina Faso: 39,000; Pakistan: 13,000) 692 provider surveys (Tanzania: 300; Burkina Faso: 312; Pakistan: 80) 366 mystery client visits (Tanzania: 150; Burkina Faso: 156; Pakistan: 160) 612 direct observation (Tanzania: 300; Burkina Faso: 312) 210 interviews with clients (70 per country) 90 interviews with providers (30 per country) 65 interviews with clinic administrators (Tanzania: 25; Burkina Faso: 20; Pakistan: 20)
Arms
117 treatment clinics, 116 control clinics (Tanzania: 38 intervention, 37 control; Burkina Faso: 39 intervention, 39 control; Pakistan: 40 intervention, 40 control)
Primary outcomes
We will have different primary outcomes for each domain of interest. Provider Attitudes/Beliefs: Bias index (construction of index outlined in pre-analysis plan) Patient Centered FP Care: Optimal method counseling FP Method Received: Received modern method Perceived Quality of Care: perceived patient centered care index (construction of index outlined in pre-analysis plan)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords