We examine the role of third-order beliefs in shaping potentially stigmatized public behavior. We hypothesize that information, in addition to its persuasive effects, potentially also affects behavior by providing an "excuse" for engaging in xenophobic actions, leading to changes in equilibrium expression even among people who do not necessarily believe the information. Guided by a theoretical framework, we design an experiment to disentangle the effects of third-order beliefs from those of first- and second-order beliefs in influencing respondents' decisions to donate to an anti-immigrant organization.
Experimental design
We recruit respondents through Lucid, a survey provider.
Design details
Randomization method
Qualtrics will randomize respondents into one of the three conditions. We use the "Evenly Presents Elements" option in the Qualtrics Randomizer to secure equal group sizes.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
3750
Observations
3750
Arms
1250 control condition, 1250 excuse condition, 1250 no excuse condition. To gain statistical precision, we also report some specifications in which we pool with pilot data (N=778, with 400 in the excuse condition and 378 in the no excuse condition). We also report the results from the replication experiment (N=701 in the excuse condition and 705 in the no excuse condition).
We ask our survey provider to restrict the survey to respondents who had not taken our pilot. To further ensure that our sample does not include repeat respondents, we also include a post-outcome question asking respondents whether they have taken a previous online survey that discussed the Lott study. We expect this number to be small and plan to exclude respondents who respond in the affirmative from our main specifications (though we will also report results with the entire sample).
Our survey uses Qualtrics' built-in feature to map respondents' IP to their city, which we then mention several times in the survey. This feature occasionally fails (typically when respondents are taking the survey from remote areas), resulting in no city being displayed. We will drop these respondents from all specifications.
Primary outcomes
Whether or not the respondent authorizes a donation to Fund the Wall, an anti immigrant organization (binary variable)
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.