Market-level Effects of Competition: Prices, Quality, and Mechanisms

How to cite

Tjernstrom, Emilia; Schechter, Laura; Tjernström, Emilia; Njeru, Timothy; Deutschmann, Joshua. 2022. "Market-level Effects of Competition: Prices, Quality, and Mechanisms." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005226. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5226-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Emilia Tjernstrom* , Laura Schechter , Emilia Tjernström , Timothy Njeru , Joshua Deutschmann

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0005226
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5226-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2020-02-15 – 2022-12-31
Countries
Kenya ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5226

Abstract

Conventional wisdom has it that market competition drives down prices. The effect of competition on product quality, however, is more ambiguous. This project uses a market-level experiment to identify the causal effect of market entry on agricultural input markets. We randomize the rollout of new agricultural retail stores in Kenya, where agricultural input markets are served by small-scale retail shops with spatial monopoly power. We use this experimental variation in competitive pressure to estimate the effect on prices, product quality, and firm behavior including entry and exit decisions.

Intervention

The NGO is opening agro-input shops, in which they will sell high-quality hybrid seeds and fertilizers. Consumers will be able to obtain any quantity of inputs at any time during the year.

Experimental design

We partner with a large and established NGO that is opening agro-input stores in Kenya. The NGO provided us with a list of 100 locations where they wanted to open retail shops, and allowed us to randomize the roll-out. The randomized roll-out provides the key source of experimental variation for the study.

DEFINITIONS
- Market centers: defined as the 100 locations where the NGO planned to open retail shops
- Catchment areas: defined by all locations within 10 km of the market center
- Entrants: the NGO-run stores

DATA
Each round of data collection takes place as three separate activities:
1) We conduct market censuses in all catchment areas. Specifically, we list, geo-tag, and photograph each agro-input retailer within the 10-km catchment area (i.e., all stores that sell seeds or fertilizer).
2) We employ covert (mystery) shoppers, who purchase seed and DAP fertilizer from 10 randomly sampled stores within each catchment area listed in the census. We sample the mystery-shopped stores withour replacement (i.e., if catchment areas overlap, we exclude shops already selected to be surveyed based on also falling in another catchment area).
3) We conduct firm surveys with the same stores that we sent mystery shoppers to. This exercise is separated in time from the mystery shopping activity to ensure that the covert shoppers remain covert.

Design details

Randomization method
RANDOMIZATION We randomized market centers into early and late roll-out using pairwise randomization. We used the following variables to create the pairs: 1) An indicator of whether the entrant location is within 1 km of a main road 2) Altitude 3) Number of incumbent stores within 5 km of the entrant location 4) Population density within 10 km of the entrant location If the NGO faces difficulties opening stores in some of their planned treatment locations (for example if they can not find an appropriate piece of land), the pairwise randomization will enable us to drop that location and it’s matched control location. VARIABLES - Distance to main road: we label all roads classified as trunk or primary roads according to the Kenyan road system as "main roads" - Number of incumbents: we proxy the number of stores in an area using a 2015 census conducted by McKinsey of all agro-input stores in Kenya - Population density: we use population density estimates from WorldPop (2013) - Altitude of the market centers: from a Digital Elevation Model done by the USGS Shuttle Radar Topography Mission MATCHING Using the above variables, we constructed pairs of market centers following the procedure employed by King et al. (2007), i.e.: * Calculate the Mahalanobis distance for every possible pair of market centers within each region * Choose the pair with the smallest distance and remove it * Repeat these steps until all stores have been matched
Randomization unit
Market centers
Clusters
100 markets
Observations
2,000 fertilizer samples; 2,000 maize seed samples, 1000 firm surveys
Arms
50 markets control 50 markets treatment
Primary outcomes
- Input quality at incumbent stores - Input prices at incumbent stores
Secondary outcomes
- Incumbent firm demand - Entry and exit of agro-input stores in the study catchment areas - Firm behaviors, strategies, and beliefs
Sponsors
Name: National Science Foundation (NSF) Url: https://www.nsf.gov/ Name: Private Enterprise Development in Low-Income Countries (PEDL Url: https://pedl.cepr.org/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords