Cultivating Altruism in Market Economy: The Case of “Gongyi Baobei” in Taobao

How to cite

Chen, Zeyang; Weng, Xi; Wang, Hui; Meng, Juanjuan. 2020. "Cultivating Altruism in Market Economy: The Case of “Gongyi Baobei” in Taobao." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005222. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5222-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Zeyang Chen* , Xi Weng , Hui Wang , Juanjuan Meng

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0005222
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5222-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2019-12-27 – 2020-02-16
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5222

Abstract

We often associate self-sufficient farming life with honesty and kindness and market economy with selfishness and ruthlessness. Is this true? Does market economy harm morality? Literature gives some different conclusions. Previous studies have found that people are willing to pay more to save a mouse’s life in a non-market environment than in a market environment (Falk and Szech, 2013) and people increase donations to vaccines in non-market economy (Kirchler et al., 2015); on the other hand, it has been found that the willingness to pay for products above the minimum wage is indifferent in a market environment or in a non-market environment (Pigors and Rockenbach, 2016) and people are even more willing to pay for reducing pollution in a market economy (Bartling et al., 2014). Most of the studies take the form of laboratory or questionnaire surveys of on willingness to pay for moral behavior. We plan to study whether the market economy can cultivate altruism through field experiments.
“Gongyi Baobei” is a donation project in Taobao. Taobao sellers can choose to label the products as “Gongyi Baobei” and can freely choose the amount of donations and donation projects. After the transaction is finished, the Taobao system will automatically donate a certain amount from the transaction amount to the charity organization. In 2017, there were 1.78 million selllers who donated from “Gongyi Baobei” on the Taobao platform, and the total amount of donations reached 246 million RMB (35 million US dollar). We plan to give buyers and sellers some random information about “Gongyi Baobei” and study the impact of this information on their altruistic tendencies.

Intervention

We designed two types of interventions.

1. Awareness of “Gongyi Baobei”
This experiment will be carried out through a questionnaire survey. We randomly introduce “Gongyi Baobei” (treatment group) and free shipping (control group) in the questionnaire, and track the changes in respondents' purchasing behavior and charity behavior in the later stage, and then analyze the respondents’ purchasing behavior and charity behavior in a DID design.

2. Awareness of one’s historical altruistic behavior
This experiment will be carried out through Taobao message. We plan to randomly offer some annual summary on “Gongyi Baobei” (treatment group) to some buyers or sellers and no such summary to others (control group). We will later use Taobao data to compare the changes in behavior.

Experimental design

We designed two experiments for two types of interventions, respectivley.

1. Awareness of “Gongyi Baobei”
[Step 1] Intervention: randomly increase the awareness of “Gongyi Baobei” by questionaire
- Treatment group: introduction of “Gongyi Baobei”
- Control group: introduction of free shipping (a basically well-known thing)
[Step 2] Tracking: collect respondents’ data.

2. Awareness of one’s historical altruistic behavior
[Step 1] Intervention: randomly send message on one’s past altruistic behavior to buyers and sellers.
- Treatment group: sending annual summary on “Gongyi Baobei”
- Control group: not sending annual summary on “Gongyi Baobei”
[Step 2] Tracking: collect sellers’ and buyers’ data.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is done by computer.
Randomization unit
The unit id randomization is individual seller or buyer.
Clusters
1. Awareness of “Gongyi Baobei” - Buyers side: 2000 observations (buyers) 2. Awareness of one’s historical altruistic behavior - Buyers side: 2,000,000 - Sellers side: 200,000
Observations
1. Awareness of “Gongyi Baobei” - Buyers side: 2000 observations (buyers) 2. Awareness of one’s historical altruistic behavior - Buyers side: 2,000,000 - Sellers side: 200,000
Arms
1. Awareness of “Gongyi Baobei” - Buyers side: 1000 in treatment group (learn about "Gongyi Baobei") and 1000 in control group (learn about free shipping) 2. Awareness of one’s historical altruistic behavior: - Buyers side : 1,000,000 in treatment group (receive normal message) and 1,000,000 in control group (blocked from the message) - Sellers side: 100,000 in treatment group (receive normal message) and 100,000 in control group (blocked from the message)
Primary outcomes
Overall consumption, "Gongyi Baobei" consumption and other charity behavior in Taobao

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords