Taxing the Poor Twice: Poverty, Bandwidth, and Utility from Consumption
How to cite
Schofield, Heather; Venkataramani, Atheendar. 2019. "Taxing the Poor Twice: Poverty, Bandwidth, and Utility from Consumption." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005157. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5157-1.3
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Poverty confers many costs on individuals. Being poor harms health, reduces education, and lowers productivity. More insidiously, the stress and deprivation of poverty also levies a cognitive tax, which has the potential to further reduce welfare via decrements in the value of what little the poor are able to consume. This potential tax on utility and societal welfare has broad implications for our understanding of the costs of poverty -- shedding light on a compounding effect of deprivation on human welfare and changing the calculus of appropriate policies to combat poverty.
The proposed randomized controlled trial will generate rigorous causal evidence linking elements of life in poverty to changes in bandwidth and corresponding changes in the value of consumption. Participants will be low-income adults from the city of Chennai, India. The research will experimentally alter bandwidth via methods ranging from standard laboratory approaches (i.e. memorizing numbers) to methods which address the stresses of poverty (e.g. high levels of thirst due to heat and lack of access to clean water). Participants will then undertake simple laboratory based tasks to measure bandwidth and complete experimental activities (e.g. watching a short comedy video) and rate their value of these activities via methodologies drawn from multiple disciplines.
Intervention
i. Control
The control group will listen to short, emotionally neutral stories for approximately 10-15 minutes. This control group allows for a comparison with a group with similar levels of interactions with study staff and similar total time, but no activities intended to change bandwidth.
ii. Memorizing a sequence of visual stimuli
Participants in this condition will be asked to memorize an ordered sequence of blocks in different locations on a page.
iii. Scarcity Priming
In this treatment, participants will be read a story about a typical person in the city who is from a disadvantaged background. The story narrates both positive and negative financial issues that a person from a background similar to that of the participants would face in their daily lives (e.g. a large number of high interest loans). The story would be followed by a conversation with participants about similar concerns that they may face. The participants will clearly be told that they are free to not answer questions that they would prefer not to.
iv. Thirst
Participants in this condition will be given dry salty crackers. They will be asked to consume the crackers, but may, of course, choose not to. As the intention of this arm is to generate thirst, participants randomized to this condition will not be provided with water until the end of the experimental activities unless they specifically request it.
Experimental design
Sample and Recruitment: Participants will be recruited in person on the street in communities in Chennai. After a potential participant is approached, they will be a brief description of the study and be asked if they are willing to take a short survey to determine if they are eligible. If eligible and interested in participating, the participant will be referred to the study office to complete a vision screening and complete the informed consent process. If the individual wishes to participate and completes the informed consent they will be enrolled in the study and will complete the activities described below.
Participation has three major components:
First Component
In the first portion of the experiment, participants will be randomly assigned to one of the following treatment arms. These interventions include:
a. Control: The Control condition is the “no change” comparison group – in which participants will listen to a series of short stories with little emotional content. Participants do this activity rather than nothing to keep constant interactions with surveyors and the duration of the study.
b. Memorizing a sequence of visual stimuli: This treatment group would be asked to remember a sequence of blocks arranged in a page in a given order (e.g. top right, bottom left, center right, center top, bottom right), a standard lab intervention to tax bandwidth. This treatment will also be administered at the beginning and between each outcome measurement to maintain a high cognitive burden. Given the lower literacy and numeracy in this study population, we will use a visual sequence rather than a string of numbers.
c. Scarcity priming: Priming on financial concerns similar to those undertaken in Mani et al. and other studies examining the impact of bandwidth (Shah et al. 2012; Bartos et al. 2018). In this treatment, participants will be read a story about a typical person in the city who is from a disadvantaged background. The story narrates daily financial concerns that a person from a background similar to that of the participants would face in their daily lives. The story will be followed by a conversation with participants about similar issues they may be facing. The participants will clearly be told that they are free to not answer questions that they prefer not to. At the end of the treatment condition, participants in this condition are asked a question on how exactly they would manage a huge expense in the near future.
d. Thirst: Generation of thirst via consumption of dry salty crackers. Participants in this condition will be asked to eat a few dry salty crackers (e.g. saltines) to increase thirst. We will ensure that the participant does not have any form of allergy towards the ingredients present in the food item. Participants are free to decline to eat the crackers.
Prior to implementing the interventions, a baseline survey is conducted to collect demographic data. Participants are also asked to express their willingness to: 1) play a board game while simultaneously listening to an unpleasant noise and then sit quietly for a few minutes, or 2) play the same board game and then listen to the unpleasant noise. The total duration of these activities and the time spent listening to the noise is the same across these two versions (simultaneous vs. sequential) of the activity. The purpose of this task is two-fold. First, it is used to determine whether people anticipate that bandwidth constraints (the unpleasant noise) reduce the value of consumption. Second, it serves as a test of the hypothesis that willingness to pay may be confounded by bandwidth constraints.
Second Component:
In the second portion of the experiment, participants engage in two short tasks, to measure cognitive bandwidth.
The cognitive tests used to measure bandwidth for the participants are:
a. Psychomotor vigilance task (PVT) (measures the ability to sustain attention)
b. Raven's progressive matrices (measuring fluid intelligence)
The order of the cognitive tasks is randomized at the individual level.
Third Component:
In the third portion of the experiment, participants engage in a set of positive experiences and answer questions about their enjoyment (or lack thereof) of the activities. The order of these activities is randomized across individuals.
a. Watching short videos (comedy video)
b. Listening to music (short local songs)
c. Completing puzzles or easy games (e.g. jigsaw puzzles)
d. Eating a small food item (e.g. a bite or two of chocolate)
The order of these experiences is randomized at the individual level.
Measurements of the value of consumption include: (1) self-reported enjoyment on a Likert scale (primary) and (2) willingness to pay to engage in a similar activity again (secondary). If the participant does not wish to do the activity, they simply report a willingness to pay of 0 Rs.
The study participants would stay in the study office for approximately 3 to 4 hours to complete these tasks.
Design details
Materials
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.