When does tomorrow start? 401(k) Auto-escalation over future time horizons

How to cite

Bhargava, Saurabh; Benartzi, Shlomo; Mason, Richard. 2019. "When does tomorrow start? 401(k) Auto-escalation over future time horizons." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005136. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5136-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Saurabh Bhargava* , Shlomo Benartzi , Richard Mason

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0005136
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5136-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2018-10-01 – 2020-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5136

Abstract

While it is widely recognized that 401(k) enrollees are more willing to commit to increases in future, relative to present, savings, clarifying how enrollees conceptualize the “future” is an open question. Clarifying how individuals conceptualize the future, in the specific domain of savings, could help policy-makers and program designers encourage savings via optimized design of auto-enrollment interfaces and could help deepen our understanding of the mechanisms that drive individuals to exhibit present-focus in their intertemporal financial decisions. The proposed project would investigate these questions by testing how the willingness of US employees to enroll in 401(k) automatic escalation varies across the default escalation delay, default escalation increment, and the framing of the auto-escalation delay through a randomized field study administered across several hundred 401(k) plans sponsored by Voya Financial. The field study will be supplemented with experimental studies to investigate mechanisms.

Experimental design

The experimental interventions involve randomizing employees across approximately 500 hundred 401(k) plans, sponsored by our firm partner, to one of several variations of the automatic-escalation enrollment interface as they proceed through online plan enrollment (or adjustment). The randomization occurs by a computer algorithm and is administered at the individual level. The randomization will involve all plans for which data is available, and for which there are no commercial exclusions, that had at least 25 online active enrollments from October 2018 to September 2019 (526 plans prior to any data, commercial exclusions – currently unknown to us).

The interventions reflect systematic departures along three dimensions from a baseline condition (which itself reflects a slight simplification relative to the prevailing commercial design used by Voya): the length of default escalation delay (90 days, 180 days, 365 days), the default escalation increment (1% or 2%), and the framing of the delay (as mm/dd/yy, or in # days). We do not intend to test all possible combinations (3 x 2 x 2) due to technical and operational constraints. For increased statistical efficiency, we intend to double-sample the baseline condition.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done by algorithm - implemented by firm partner.
Randomization unit
Employee level (or as best inferred by IP address, cookie)
Clusters
As described in the power calculation section, we aspire towards 27,000 enrollments/employees prior to exclusions. Using administrative data on enrollment from October 2018 to September 2019, we estimate that our sample (of plans w/ at least 25 annual online active enrollments) will yield approximately 3,000 observations (prior to exclusions per month). To simplify logistics, we pre-specify a trial period that ends at the end of a calendar month rather than specifying an explicit sample threshold. Assuming approximately 3,000 non-excluded observations per month (Mason 2019), we anticipate a data collection period lasting approximately 9 months. Assuming a start date during the first week of December implies an end date of August 31st 2020.
Observations
As described in the power calculation section, we aspire towards 27,000 enrollments/employees prior to exclusions. Using administrative data on enrollment from October 2018 to September 2019, we estimate that our sample (of plans w/ at least 25 annual online active enrollments) will yield approximately 3,000 observations (prior to exclusions per month). To simplify logistics, we pre-specify a trial period that ends at the end of a calendar month rather than specifying an explicit sample threshold. Assuming approximately 3,000 non-excluded observations per month (Mason 2019), we anticipate a data collection period lasting approximately 9 months. Assuming a start date during the first week of December implies an end date of August 31st 2020.
Arms
We aspire towards approximately 2300 enrollments/employees per each of 11 conditions (or 10 w/ the control double-sampled) after exclusions or approximately 27k observations collectively prior to exclusions.
Primary outcomes
We intend to analyze two sets of behavioral outcomes to capture the immediate and longer-run effects of the interventions on enrollment decisions and savings. Note that we anticipate excluding 10% of data based on earlier research targeting the same market segment (Mason 2019, Bhargava et al. 2018; Beshears et al. 2019). The basis for exclusion includes observations with incomplete data, and at the plan level, extend to plans that use non-standard data tracking methods, offer after-tax Roth contributions, index contributions in dollar amounts rather than percentage terms, etc. Immediate Outcomes: Enrollment Decision, Escalation Decision (Delay, Increment, Cap) Long-Run Variables: Persistence of Enrollment, Escalation Decisions, Subsequent Plan Adjustments, Leakage/Loans, Asset Accumulation

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords