Peer Effects In Street Donations: A Field Experiment
How to cite
Vargas, Kristian López. 2020. "Peer Effects In Street Donations: A Field Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005116. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5116-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Is altruistic behavior in street donations affected by peers? We study how people's pro-social behavior is affected by watching others' donation behaviors. We implement a field experiment in the traffic lights on the streets of Lima (Peru), where it is common to see artists perform during the red light and then collect money from drivers before the light turns green.
We exogenously vary three elements: (1) whether a driver sees another driver making a donation; (2) the gender of the performer; (3) the income-background appearance of the performer. The unit of analysis in our experiment is the vehicle, and we are interested in studying the behavior of passing-by drivers and passengers in terms of how often they donate to a street performer and how much.
We accompany this study with two follow-up surveys of drivers to disentangle the possible mechanisms of peer effects.
Intervention
Treatment 1 -- Peers' visible donations with two levels: seeing someone donate and not seeing someone donate. In this treatment, we use natural variation of donations (whose car is near you in the light is random) as well as experimentally manipulated donations. More precisely, we record the donations made by regular drivers. However, since these donation events are rather infrequent, we also hire two drivers who position themselves in the front rows in the red light (so they can be seen) and make donations every other light
Treatment 2 -- Gender of actors with two levels: male vs. female
Treatment 3 -- Income background appearance of actors with two levels: low vs. high
Experimental design
The unit of analysis in our experiment is the vehicle. We study the behavior of passing-by drivers and passengers in terms of how often they donate to a street performer and how much.
We deploy a between-subject design in an experiment with two components. In the first component, called "peers' visible donations", we use a hybrid of experimental and observational approaches to assign units of analysis (vehicles) to treatments. The two treatments in this component are: seeing someone donate and not seeing someone donate.
We use natural variation of donations (whose car is near you in the light is random) as well as experimentally manipulated donations. More precisely, we record the donations made by regular drivers. However, since these donation events are rather infrequent, we also hire two drivers who position themselves in the first row in the red light (so they can be seen) and make donations every other light.
The second component of the design is purely experimental and it manipulates the income-background appearance and gender of the performers. We utilize a 2 by 2 full factorial design to test their individual and interaction effects on people's willingness to donate. More precisely, we will have four conditions: (1) male, low-income appearance; (2) male, high-income appearance; (3) female, low-income appearance; (4) female, high-income appearance. All actors perform the same act repeated times in each red light.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.