Changing norms and behaviors through entertainment TV: Impact Evaluation of the MTV series Shuga
How to cite
Ferrara, Eliana La; Banerjee, Abhijit; Orozco, Victor. 2014. "Changing norms and behaviors through entertainment TV: Impact Evaluation of the MTV series Shuga." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000509. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.509-4.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
TV plays an important role in introducing ideas in societies where literacy is relatively low and social norms discourage novel ideas, especially related to stigmatized behaviors. Educational entertainment (“edutainment”) is a communication strategy that works through mass entertainment media with the aim of promoting a better context for behavior change than the delivery of information alone.
This evaluation uses an experimental design to study the impact of MTV series Shuga, a TV drama targeted at youth that aims to change social norms and behavior related to high-risk sexual behavior and gender-based violence. The impact evaluation will be among the first to experimentally estimate the impact of a product similar to commercial TV series (as opposed to an educational movie). It will be the first time that two crucial aspects of edutainment programs are evaluated: i) their “spillover” effect on people who did not watch the drama but may have heard about it from friends and ii) their effect through viewers’ perceptions of the beliefs and values of their peers after watching the drama. For instance, young men may only be willing to treat their partners with respect when they think that this will not make them look weak in the eyes of other men.
The evaluation will employ a clustered randomized trial design where communities will be randomly assigned to treatment 1 (Shuga screenings only), treatment 2 (Shuga screenings plus information about attitudes of peers) and control groups. The Friends treatment is cross-cutting across the treatment arms and will be randomized at the individual level.
Intervention
MTV International has produced and distributed the edutainment show Shuga, a TV drama started in 2009, designed to raise awareness and change attitudes and behavior related to HIV/AIDS and reproductive health among young people. Shuga presents young Africans from various socioeconomic strata balancing bright futures with the negative consequences of high-risk behaviors. The TV drama has been broadcasted in over 70 countries, mainly in SSA. In the summer of 2013, MTV filmed the third season in Nigeria. This third season introduces messages about gender based violence and attitudes towards women. The third season has eight 22-minute episodes.
Experimental design
The intervention will take place in screening centers, e.g.. schools or community centers. Using GPS coordinates of screening centers, we define communities around each of these centres as households located within a 2 mile radius, ensuring that there are buffer zones between communities to minimize the risk of contamination across study groups. These communities will constitute our unit of randomization.
Treatment communities will constitute 2/3 of the sample, control communities 1/3 of the sample. In treatment communities individuals will be shown the Shuga TV drama in two screenings of four 20 minutes episodes each. Control communities will be shown a placebo movie that will lack messages of sexual risky behavior and last for a similar amount of time.
Treatment communities will be randomly divided into two arms: one arm will only show Shuga (Treatment 1); the second arm will show Shuga plus some reinforcing messages on other people's attitudes (Treatment 2).
To half of the treated individuals (both in Treatments 1 and 2) randomly selected, we will offer the option to bring up to two people to the screening. This treatment is randomized at the individual level and is cross-cutting across the other two treatments. We denote this as the “Friends treatment”.
In all locations (treatment and control) survey participants who are NOT in the “Friends” treatment will be asked to list up to 3 friends whom they regularly talk to and who live in the community . Let us denote the people they mention as “Network Members”. A random sample of 15 of these Network Members will be administered the baseline and follow-up survey in each location.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.