The ethical consumer: Do consumers care more about social or environmental sustainability?

How to cite

Sarin, Maivand; Eyberg, Alexandra; Irlenbusch, Bernd; Conrads, Julian. 2019. "The ethical consumer: Do consumers care more about social or environmental sustainability?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005066. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5066-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Maivand Sarin* , Alexandra Eyberg , Bernd Irlenbusch , Julian Conrads

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0005066
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5066-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2019-11-21 – 2020-02-29
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D12, D62, M14, M31
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5066

Abstract

In a previous study, we conducted a randomized experiment to test whether consumers’ willingness to accept, elicited in an incentivized auction (BDM), increases when they are informed that a product is produced in a socially and environmentally sustainable way. We find a significant increase. However, our design does not allow us to disentangle if the increase is driven by the social sustainability-related aspects of the environmental sustainability-related aspects of the production. In this project, we replicate the methodological approach of our previous study but alter the information consumers receive. To be able to answer the question if consumers care more about the social or environmental impact of the production of goods, we either inform them about social sustainability-related aspects or environmental sustainability-related aspects of the production, but not about both simultaneously.

Intervention

We create variation by handing out different informational sheets about the backpack. The sheets contain a picture of the backpack on the left. On the right, participants in the SCL treatment find the following text with three bullet points:
The backpack is characterized by
• high functionality (e.g. expandable from 26 to 33 liters, padded laptop compartment, 2 accesses to main compartment: rolltop system and circulating zipper),
• outstanding wearing comfort (e.g. ergonomic shoulder straps, padded back section, removable and adjustable chest strap),
• water-repellence.
• a socially compatible production, i.e. regular auditing of working conditions of the backpack production by the independent third party Fair Wear Foundation (including occupational safety reviews, employee training and no child labor), and long and transparent partnership with suppliers

In the ECO treatment, participants find the following text with three bullet points:
• high functionality (e.g. expandable from 26 to 33 liters, padded laptop compartment, 2 accesses to main compartment: rolltop system and circulating zipper),
• outstanding wearing comfort (e.g. ergonomic shoulder straps, padded back section, removable and adjustable chest strap),
• water-repellence.
• an ecologically compatible production (e.g. fabrics made from 100% recycled PET bottles, backpack free of PFCs harmful to the environment and health and continuous reduction of negative environmental impacts in production as certified by the independent third party bluesign)

Experimental design

We investigate if consumers value a socially or an environmentally sustainable production of goods more by measuring the increase in their willingness to accept (WTA) for backpacks when they are either only informed about the social sustainability-related aspects in the production or only about the environmental sustainability-related aspects. WTA are elicited by using an Becker-DeGroot-Marschak auction (BDM) (Becker, DeGroot, & Marschak, 1964). More precisely, participants are given a backpack that they can immediately sell back in two BDM auction rounds. After inspecting the backpack, participants state their minimum selling price in a first pre-intervention auction round. Then, they are given information about functionality and wearing comfort of the backpack, e.g., being water-repellent. In addition and depending on the treatment, participants either receive information about social (SCL) or about ecological (ECO) sustainability. In a second post-intervention auction round, they are then again asked to state their minimum selling price. Subsequently, a number is randomly drawn to be the price. If participants’ bid is higher than the price, they keep the backpack. If their bid is equal to or lower than the price, they must sell the backpack at the drawn price.

The experiment is conducted at university campuses in Cologne. The experimenter asks people that pass by the experimenter’s stand if they want to participate in a consumer survey that is conducted by the University of Cologne. They are told that, if they are drawn in a lottery, they can win a backpack or money. If they agree to participate, they are randomly allocated to either the control or the sustainability treatment. Then, participants are given detailed, written instructions that are read aloud to them by the experimenter. To test and enhance participants’ comprehension of the method, one training round with an apple is conducted. Then, participants make their pre-intervention bid. The backpack is available at the experimenter’s stand for participants to inspect. Afterward, depending on the treatment, participants receive one of two different informational sheets about the backpack, either with social sustainability-related information or with ecological sustainability-related information. Then, participants make their post-intervention bid. In the end, participants answer various questions: They are asked if they know the brand (yes/no) and its CSR activities (5 point Likert scale), if they like the design (5 point Likert scale), about their current need of a backpack (5 point Likert scale) and how well they know the backpack market (5 point Likert scale). Then, they are asked to answer demographical questions about gender, age, vocational situation, field of studies, and highest educational degree. Finally, they are asked if they usually buy socially and environmentally sustainable clothes and accessories (2 questions: 5 point Likert scale) and if they have paid more in the past for clothes and accessories that were produced socially and environmentally sustainably (2 questions: 5 point Likert scale). Participants that are allocated to the sustainability treatment are asked additionally if they know Fair Wear Foundation and bluesign (2 questions: yes/no).

Design details

Randomization method
After subjects agree to participate in the experiment, the experimenter randomly draws a card from an envelope that determines the treatment group.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
n.a.
Observations
Step 1: 128, Step 2: 308
Arms
Step 1: 64 each, Step 2: 154 each.
Primary outcomes
Difference in willingness to accept

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords