This paper investigates attitudes towards hiring decisions.
Experimental design
Nothing to report yet.
Design details
Randomization method
Randomization will be carried out in the Qualtrics Survey by a computer.
Randomization unit
Respondents.
Clusters
450 respondents
***Update July 29, 2020***
additional 1,300 respondents only for the survey experiment
Observations
For primary outcomes 1-2: 450 observations (1 observation per respondent)
For primary outcomes 3-6: 1,800 observations (1 per respondent-scenario combination - each respondent sees 4 scenarios)
***Update July 29, 2020***
For primary outcomes 3-6, we will collect an additional 5,200 observations (1 per respondent-scenario combination)
Arms
For primary outcomes 1 and 2:
Treatment arm 1: approx. 225 respondents (50%) will first see the scenario in which a woman is discriminated against
Treatment arm 2: approx. 225 respondents (50%) will first see the scenario in which a man is discriminated against
For primary outcomes 3-6:
• Control group: approx. 225 respondents (50%)
For ease of exposition, we will number the information treatments as same suffering (treatment 1), worked equally hard (2), no discrimination (3), same suffering, worked equally hard and no discrimination (4).
• Treatment group 1: order of information treatments (1,2,3,4), approx. 37.5 respondents (8.3%)
• Treatment group 2: order (1,3,2,4), approx. 37.5 respondents (8.3%)
• Treatment group 3: order (2,1,3,4), approx. 37.5 respondents (8.3%)
• Treatment group 4: order (2,3,1,4), approx. 37.5 respondents (8.3%)
• Treatment group 5: order (3,1,2,4), approx. 37.5 respondents (8.3%)
• Treatment group 6: order (3,2,1,4), approx. 37.5 respondents (8.3%)
***Update July 29, 2020***
For primary outcomes 3-6, the additional respondents will be assigned to treatment groups in the same proportions as stated above.
Primary outcomes
1. “pro-women attitude” in base scenario.
2. “pro-woman attitude” after reflection.
3. Effect of holding discrimination constant on pro-women attitudes (separately for “pro-women”, “neutral” and “pro-men” respondents)
4. Effect of holding effort constant on pro-women attitudes (separately for “pro-women”, “neutral” and “pro-men” respondents)
5. Effect of holding suffering constant on pro-women attitudes (separately for “pro-women”, “neutral” and “pro-men” respondents)
6. Effect of holding discrimination, effort and suffering constant on pro-women attitudes. (separately for “pro-women”, “neutral” and “pro-men” respondents)
Secondary outcomes
1. Average pro-women attitude (between sample)
2. Average pro-women attitude by gender
3. Average pro-women attitude by education
4. Average pro-women attitude by income
5. Average pro-women attitude by political leanings
6. Relationship between pro-women attitude in base and belief that women suffered more in hypothetical scenarios.
7. Relationship between pro-women attitude in base and belief that women worked harder in their career in hypothetical scenarios.
8. Relationship between pro-women attitude in base and belief that women worked harder in general in hypothetical scenarios.
9. Relationship between pro-women attitude in base and belief that women are more discriminated against in hypothetical scenarios.
Feess, Eberhard, Jan Feld, and Shakked Noy. "People Judge Discrimination Against Women More Harshly Than Discrimination Against Men–Does Statistical Fairness Discrimination Explain Why?." Frontiers in psychology 12 (2021): 675776.
https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.675776
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.