Identity and Polarization: Evidence from an Online Experiment

How to cite

Wimmer, Johannes; Vollmer, Leonhard; Esguerra, Emilio. 2019. "Identity and Polarization: Evidence from an Online Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005046. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5046-1.2000000000000002

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Johannes Wimmer* , Leonhard Vollmer , Emilio Esguerra

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0005046
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5046-1.2000000000000002
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2019-12-05 – 2021-09-01
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5046

Abstract

We test a theoretical model by Gennaioli and Tabellini (2019) on identity and polarization: when a new political dimension becomes salient, individuals choose new identities along this dimension and, due to a postulated tendency to stereotype both in- and out-groups, individuals shift their beliefs and attitudes in the direction of new stereotypes. This mechanism yields a clear prediction for polarization: an increase in the salience of one political dimension should lead to more polarized beliefs and attitudes along this dimension, while at the same time leading to less identification and reduced polarization along non-collinear, now relatively less salient, political dimensions. To test this prediction, we conduct an incentivized online survey experiment in which we randomly split participants into three groups: 1) control (C), 2) redistribution (R), and 3) openness (O). To vary the salience of a particular policy dimension, we expose each group to a different simulated news feed based on recent real-world news items from online media outlets. As outcomes we measure stated as well as revealed attitudes and beliefs about redistribution and openness (immigration, globalization, and climate change) to capture ideological as well as affective polarization.

Intervention

We run an incentivized online survey experiment in Germany. We recruit participants through a professional survey company to ensure that our sample is representative of the voting-age population with respect to gender, income, and age. Our intervention is designed to shift the relative salience of four political dimensions: redistribution, globalization, immigration, and climate change.

Experimental design

In the online survey, we elicit participants’ views on four political dimensions: redistribution, globalization, immigration, and climate change. In addition, we collect detailed information on participants' demographics, such as age, gender, income, or educational and employment status as well as political outcomes such as voting behavior.

As part of the survey, we experimentally vary the relative salience of the aforementioned political dimensions. More specifically, we employ the following five-arm design: first, we randomly allocate participants to either the 1) control group (C), 2) the redistribution group (R), or the 3) openness group (O). Each group is then exposed to a different stimulus varying the salience of a particular political dimension. More specifically, group R receives an upward shift in the relative salience of the redistributive conflict dimension; group O an upward shift in the relative salience of the openness dimension; while the control group C receives a placebo. We further split the openness group into three subgroups which receive a stimulus either increasing the salience of immigration (O1), globalization (O2), or climate change (O3). This leaves us with a total of five different groups.

Our treatment shifts the relative salience of either of the two political dimensions, i.e. redistribution or openness. We implement these shifts in the relative salience of political dimensions by exposing participants to simulated news feeds based on recent real-world news items from German online media outlets.

For further details on the experimental design, please refer to our pre-analysis plan.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
Randomization takes place at the individual level.
Clusters
As randomization is conducted at the individual level, the number of clusters equals the number of individuals.
Observations
We expect ca. 5,150 individuals to complete the survey.
Arms
We randomly assign participants with the following probabilities to five different groups: 1) control (C): 1/3 2) redistribution (R): 1/3 3) openness (O): 1/3 3.1) immigration (O1): 1/9 3.2) globalization (O2): 1/9 3.3) climate change (O3): 1/9 For clarification, individuals have a probability of one third of being assigned to the openness group. Within the openness group, each participants is randomly assigned either to the globalization, immigration or climate change condition. Hence, participants effectively have a chance of 1/9 of being assigned to the globalization, immigration or climate change condition, respectively.
Primary outcomes
Our set of primary outcomes consists of participants' views on the following four political dimensions: redistribution, globalization, immigration, and climate change. Based on participants' views on these four dimensions, we construct measures of ideological polarization for each dimension.
Secondary outcomes
Our secondary outcomes fall into five categories: 1. Revealed attitudes 2. First-stage relationship 3. Mechanisms 4. Affective polarization 5. Further outcomes

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords