Fighting teacher sorting with behavioral interventions
How to cite
Ajzenman, Nicolas; Elacqua, Gregory; Marotta, Luana; Montalva, Veronica; Olsen, Sofie. 2019. "Fighting teacher sorting with behavioral interventions." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005036. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5036-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In this paper, we implement behavioral interventions to reduce teacher sorting (e.g., good teachers choosing the best schools). We test, in the context of teachers' school choice, the effect of two behavioral theories/effects well-established in the literature of psychology: the name-order effect and cognitive dissonance. In a large-scale countrywide intervention put in place in Ecuador we use the online platform that teachers use to select the schools to which they would like to apply to teach to implement two low-cost experiments. In the first arm, we prime altruism by asking if they would like to work in a school in which they think they could have a bigger social impact. We then label those schools and let them choose. A positive response to the treatment question would be inconsistent with choosing a less-impactful school. In a second arm, we order the schools to show first the schools in which they could have a bigger social impact to test a name-order effect on their choices. Our main outcome is the likelihood of choosing disadvantaged schools.
Intervention
The RCT will be conducted through an online platform that teachers use countrywide to apply for teaching vacancies. Teachers can apply for up to 5 teaching vacancies within their specialty and must rank these vacancies according to their preference. The treatment arms are designed to encourage teachers to apply for jobs at disadvantaged schools. To determine schools as “disadvantaged”, it was created an index that combined information about a) student performance, b) student socioeconomic background, c) proxies indicating whether schools are hard-to-staff and/or have shortage of teachers.
The RCT has three arms:
1. Control
• Teachers see the list of vacancies available with an icon indicating whether the vacancy is from a disadvantaged school. The list of vacancies is organized in random order.
• Teachers also see an explanation of the icon that says: “Schools that need committed teachers like you and where your ability to generate social impact is greater.”
2. Treatment 1
• Teachers see the list of vacancies available with an icon indicating whether the vacancy is from a disadvantaged school. The list of vacancies is organized in random order.
• Teachers also see an explanation of the icon that says: “Schools that need committed teachers like you and where your ability to generate social impact is greater.”
• Before teachers see the list of vacancies, they are prompted with the following text and question: "Some schools need more committed teachers. In these schools, your work could generate greater social change. Would you be interested in working in these schools where you could have more social impact?"
3. Treatment 2
• Teachers see the list of vacancies available with an icon indicating whether the vacancy is from a disadvantaged school. The list of vacancies is organized in a way so that disadvantaged schools are placed first.
• Teachers also see an explanation of the icon that says: “Schools that need committed teachers like you and where your ability to generate social impact is greater.”
Experimental design
The RCT will be conducted through an online platform that teachers use countrywide to apply for teaching vacancies. Teachers can apply for up to 5 teaching vacancies within their specialty and must rank these vacancies according to their preference. The treatment arms are designed to encourage teachers to apply for jobs at disadvantaged schools. To determine schools as “disadvantaged”, it was created an index that combined information about a) student performance, b) student socioeconomic background, c) proxies indicating whether schools are hard-to-staff and/or have shortage of teachers.
The RCT has three arms:
1. Control
• Teachers see the list of vacancies available with an icon indicating whether the vacancy is from a disadvantaged school. The list of vacancies is organized in random order.
• Teachers also see an explanation of the icon that says: “Schools that need committed teachers like you and where your ability to generate social impact is greater.”
2. Treatment 1
• Teachers see the list of vacancies available with an icon indicating whether the vacancy is from a disadvantaged school. The list of vacancies is organized in random order.
• Teachers also see an explanation of the icon that says: “Schools that need committed teachers like you and where your ability to generate social impact is greater.”
• Before teachers see the list of vacancies, they are prompted with the following text and question: "Some schools need more committed teachers. In these schools, your work could generate greater social change. Would you be interested in working in these schools where you could have more social impact?"
3. Treatment 2
• Teachers see the list of vacancies available with an icon indicating whether the vacancy is from a disadvantaged school. The list of vacancies is organized in a way so that disadvantaged schools are placed first.
• Teachers also see an explanation of the icon that says: “Schools that need committed teachers like you and where your ability to generate social impact is greater.”
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.