Prosociality across Socio-Economic Disparities: Trust, Cooperation and Generosity in Argentina
How to cite
Ortega, Juan Diego Serrano. 2019. "Prosociality across Socio-Economic Disparities: Trust, Cooperation and Generosity in Argentina." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004971. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4971-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The aim of the study is to explore differences in prosocial behavior across socioeconomic classes. In order to do so, we did an experiment with 513 high school students in Argentina coming from an array of socio-economic backgrounds. We randomly assigned treatment of equal and unequal endowments at the classroom level and studied their behavior in a dictator and trust game. We further captured data related to their valuation of generosity, trust, and friendship.
Intervention
The study will be divided into 3 parts. Part 1 consists of a survey. In the first part of this survey, participants will be asked baseline information (age, gender, income level proxies, opinion on generosity in their communities). In the second part of this survey, participants will be asked for information on their opinions on each of their classmates. Attached to the survey there is a small plan of the class with numbered seats. They will be asked questions about friendship, trust, and privilege of each one of the students seating in the class. Part 2 consists of 3 games. They are first told that no matter what they are receiving a participation fee and that depending on their decisions in the games, they can earn more money. The games are a dictator game, a trust game, and a choice between lotteries. During the games they will not be using real money, they will be given the money after the experiment at some point of the day. Part 3 consists of a very short survey. In it, participants will be asked about their thoughts and behavior during the games. Specifically about how they think they behaved with respect to the other participants. At the end of the study, each student will be given their payments in an envelope. Some students will be receiving a higher payment than they should. Attached to each envelope their will be an email address they should contact if there is an issue with the payments. We are doing so to measure whether they have the incentive to receive what they have not earned.
The treatment effect will consist of giving different participation fees to different participants within a class (either 25ARS or 75ARS). For the control group, everyone will receive the same amount (50ARS). The way they will notice this difference is when they read the Payment Method section before playing the games. They will be informed about what their payment is. At the same time, in the treatment case, we will have two situations. One in which they are informed of this inequality by telling them they receive 25ARS and others receive 75ARS or vice-versa. Another in which they are unaware of this difference in payments, they are just told they receive 25ARS or 75ARS without knowing what others receive. For the control, they will be told everyone receives 50ARS. A class will be randomly selected to have the treatment or not. Ideally in each school, we should have enough classrooms to apply the treatments and the control. From the entire sample, 50% of the classes will receive the equality treatment, the other 50% of the classes will receive the inequality treatment. From the Inequality treatment, 50% of the classes will know of this inequality and 50% of the classes will not know of it.
Experimental design
The study will be divided into 3 parts. Part 1 consists of a survey. In the first part of this survey, participants will be asked baseline information (age, gender, income level proxies, opinion on generosity in their communities). In the second part of this survey, participants will be asked for information on their opinions on each of their classmates. Attached to the survey there is a small plan of the class with numbered seats. They will be asked questions about friendship, trust, and privilege of each one of the students seating in the class. Part 2 consists of 3 games. They are first told that no matter what they are receiving a participation fee and that depending on their decisions in the games, they can earn more money. The games are a dictator game, a trust game, and a choice between lotteries. During the games they will not be using real money, they will be given the money after the experiment at some point of the day. Part 3 consists of a very short survey. In it, participants will be asked about their thoughts and behavior during the games. Specifically about how they think they behaved with respect to the other participants. At the end of the study, each student will be given their payments in an envelope. Some students will be receiving a higher payment than they should. Attached to each envelope their will be an email address they should contact if there is an issue with the payments. We are doing so to measure whether they have the incentive to receive what they have not earned.
The treatment effect will consist of giving different participation fees to different participants within a class (either 25ARS or 75ARS). For the control group, everyone will receive the same amount (50ARS). The way they will notice this difference is when they read the Payment Method section before playing the games. They will be informed about what their payment is. At the same time, in the treatment case, we will have two situations. One in which they are informed of this inequality by telling them they receive 25ARS and others receive 75ARS or vice-versa. Another in which they are unaware of this difference in payments, they are just told they receive 25ARS or 75ARS without knowing what others receive. For the control, they will be told everyone receives 50ARS. A class will be randomly selected to have the treatment or not. Ideally in each school, we should have enough classrooms to apply the treatments and the control. From the entire sample, 50% of the classes will receive the equality treatment, the other 50% of the classes will receive the inequality treatment. From the Inequality treatment, 50% of the classes will know of this inequality and 50% of the classes will not know of it.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.