Local Authorities and Property tax collection: Experimental evidence from Tanzania
How to cite
Mwaijande, Francis; Ally, Salama; Sereri, Jasmin; Lyimo, Eva; Mmbaga, Miriam; Shirima, Diego; Kachwamba, Muhajir; Badala, Kija; Mwakalikamo, Joshua; Kawega, Mwanahamisi. 2021. "Local Authorities and Property tax collection: Experimental evidence from Tanzania." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004960. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4960-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study aims to analyze the extent to which local community leaders in local government authorities can be leveraged to increase property tax collection in a developing country context. The property tax collection system is one of the main sources of revenue for many countries. Unfortunately, in Tanzania, property tax collection is as low compared to other types of tax such as VAT and Pay as You Earn (PAYE) tax. The Property tax collection in Tanzania is as low as 30% of the total expected revenue from property tax. The government has been changing strategies on collecting property tax, these include both centralized and decentralized approaches, but with less significant impact on compliance.
The study design employs a randomized control trial to assess the effect of messaging strategies and the involvement of local leaders/authorities to increase tax collection in Tanzania. Participants were randomly allocated to three treatment arms and a control group. The first treatment arm involved SMS reminder with a threat of fine, which is standard in tax compliance literature. The second treatment arm combined treatment for the first arm with an additional threat of involvement of local leaders in the tax collection process. The third arm involved the treatment in the first arm with an actual request for help from local leaders to increase tax compliance. Therefore, the innovation and value addition of this study to the existing body of literature stems from two additional experimental treatments in the second and third treatment arms stated above. While we acknowledge that there are many studies using SMS reminders/threats of fine to influence tax compliance; we leverage this strategy to study the additional effect of the involvement of local authorities in tax compliance.
Intervention
The study involves four experimental arms. These include control group (T0) which involves list of participants who neither receive SMS reminder nor local leaders are involved. The second treatment arm involved SMS reminder with both a threat of fine and a threat of involvement of local leaders. The third arm involved SMS reminder with both a threat of fine and an actual request for local leaders’ involvement in the tax collection process. Here below are the SMS scripts used in the intervention.
T0: T0-Neither SMS reminder nor Mjumbe will be involved in tax collection
T1: BASIC SMS for TaxPayers in Treatment 1 and Treatment 3 (control group receives nothing). Here below is the SMS content for T1.
Dear [NAME], Pay property tax for your building No [BRN], located at [STREET NAME] before June 30, 2021 amount of TZS [AMOUNT].
NON-PAYMENT IMPLIES FINES AND SANCTIONS FROM TANZANIA REVENUE AUTHORITY
T2: SMS for TaxPayers in Treatment 2 (basic T1 SMS+threat of Mjumbe action). Here below is the SMS content for T2.
Dear [NAME], Pay property tax for your building No [BRN], located at [STREET NAME] before June 30, 2021 amount of TZS [AMOUNT].
NON-PAYMENT IMPLIES FINES AND SANCTIONS FROM TANZANIA REVENUE AUTHORITY.
YOUR AREA’S MJUMBE, [MJUMBE NAME], WILL HELP TRA IN COLLECTING THIS TAX
T3: SMS for Mjumbe (only Treatment 3 – mjumbes in control group and Treatments 1 and 2 receive nothing). Here below is the SMS content for T3
Dear X, please inform property owners in your area to pay property taxes before June 30 2021. NON-PAYMENT IMPLIES FINES AND SANCTIONS FROM TANZANIA REVENUE AUTHORITY.
Experimental design
The study consists of a randomized control trial that involved 670 Mjumbes (local leaders) and 21,327 taxpayers from 4 Local Government Authorities: Busega District. Kahama Town Council, Bariadi Town Council and Shinyanga Municipal. The experiment has been rolled out as follows:
1. Baseline data collection: Data was extracted from the database of property taxpayers from the Tanzania Revenue Authority (TRA) in the financial year 2018/19-2020/201 covering 4 LGAs: BARIADI Town Council, BUSEGA District, KAHAMA Town Council and SHINYANGA Municipal.
2. Randomizationand Intervention: cluster-level randomization was carried out to assign subjects to one of 4 groups described above (3 treatment groups and one control group). A Big stick rerandomization approach was used to allocate 670 local leaders (Mjumbes, under which property taxpayers are organized), with the goal of achieving a balanced sample among main covariates. 4 waves of SMS reminders will be sent to treated subjects (2 per month) and 2 waves of phone calls will be made to leaders (one at the end of each intervention month).
(3) Endline data collection: Endline data will be collected between May and the end of June 2021.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.