Social Networks and Productivity Spill-over within firms
How to cite
Menzel, Andreas. 2014. "Social Networks and Productivity Spill-over within firms." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000495. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.495-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
I study the effects of implementing a management routine at randomly chosen sewing lines within garment factories in Bangladesh, to obtain evidence on the sources of observed productivity spill-over within factories. Bangladeshi garment factories are organized into several sewing lines which produce independently from another for different orders and buyers. Sewing lines producing garments that have already been produced by other lines in the factory before, are significantly more productive in the first days producing the new garment. Initial analysis by the author shows that these `spill-over' effects are stronger when the supervisors on the first and later lines to produce the garment report social ties in surveys. This intervention is designed to obtain additional evidence on the sources of the observed spill-over. Several garment factories agreed to implement a new management routine among randomly selected sewing lines. If a selected line start producing a garment that has already been produced on another line in the factory, the line supervisor from the first line producing the garment is actively involved in setting up the new line for the garment. If this intervention magnifies observed productivity spill-over, this would be indicative for spill-over being caused by sharing of knowledge between supervisors from the lines, as opposed to superiors or other persons (engineers, planners) applying their knowledge obtained on earlier lines producing the garment to later lines producing it, or other possible confounding sources.
Intervention
We work together with the management and the head production engineers in several Bangladeshi garment factories to implement the intervention. Participation in the project is still advertised, therefore the exact number of factories in the project is not yet determined. The intervention is of the following nature: Whenever a sewing line in the factory starts producing a new garment that it had not produced before but that was already produced on another sewing line, than the supervisor of the line that already produced the garment is actively involved in setting up the new line for producing the same garment. Sewing lines in our Bangladeshi partner factories typically switch the garment they produce every 1-3 weeks, and it is very common to see garments being produced on more than one line, while usually starting on different days. Switching the garment typically requires both changes of the machines used and/or adjustments on the machines themselves, such as change of the needle type or yarn type. The workers on the lines also need to be explained the new operations they have to perform on the new garment. This process of the style change can take between 1 hour and 1 day (but is usually done in the `zero-feeding' process, that is, in the line, one machine after another machines is adjusted, and the machines not yet adjusted still produce for the old garment while those already adjusted already work on the new garment. Thus, on average, each machine is idle only 15-30 minutes).
In the randomly selected lines, whenever they switch to a garment that has already been produced on another line in the factory, the line supervisor from the earlier line should be actively involved in the described change process. He should brief the new line supervisor on the most important things he has learned while producing the garment on his line, and inspect the line changing process, either after the end of the line changing process or while the most important machines for the production of the new garment are set up.
To monitor the intervention, we left with the factories either a tablet or a book, in which they should fill out a short survey every time a style change on a treatment line was "treated". The survey asks about the line that starts the garment and the line that already produced it, involved line supervisors, the garment itself, and a few questions on how well the communication went as perceived by the superiors of the line supervisors that instructed the briefing. The tablets send each report directly to a server upon finishing, while the books are collected regularly. Thus, the extent of the implementation, and whether it was implemented in the correct lines, can be checked throughout the experiment is running.
Experimental design
The intervention is carried out by the upper factory management ("General Manager", "Head Production Engineer"), under our guidance. The implementation is tracked by the tablet or book system explained above. Lines are randomly selected to obtain the treatment. In the first three factories, to test several forms of randomization, In one part of the factory, the lines were selected together in terms of sewing floors, that is sewing floors (typically containing 5-10 lines) were randomly selected. In other floors, the randomization occurred on the line level. This was done to test whether it is feasible to directly randomize on the line level. As in the initial three factories, the randomization on the line level seems to have been understood and followed, from the forth factory starting the implementation, randomization will be solely on the line level, to avoid cluster sample size concerns.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.