From Workfare to Work and Economic Well-being: A Randomized Control Trial of Labor-Intensive Public Works for the Urban Poor in Eastern DRC

How to cite

Mvukiyehe, Eric; Verpoorten, Marijke; Windt, Peter Van der; Smets, Lodewijk; Brandily, Paul; Adjogon, Guigonan Serge. 2019. "From Workfare to Work and Economic Well-being: A Randomized Control Trial of Labor-Intensive Public Works for the Urban Poor in Eastern DRC." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004946. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4946-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Eric Mvukiyehe* , Marijke Verpoorten , Peter Van der Windt , Lodewijk Smets , Paul Brandily , Guigonan Serge Adjogon

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004946
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4946-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2015-09-15 – 2020-12-31
Countries
Congo (Democratic Republic of the) (Sub-Saharan Africa)
JEL codes
I3 Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty, O12 Microeconomic Analyses of Economic Development, J48 Particular Labor markets - Public Policy, D13 Household Production and Intrahousehold Allocation
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4946

Abstract

The World Bank supports efforts to end conflict and realize economic recovery in Eastern DRC through the Productive Opportunities for Stabilization and Recovery in the DRC (STEP, in its French acronym) program. STEP notably contains a labor-intensive public works (LIPW) component, sought to increase resilience and livelihoods in five major cities in Eastern DRC. This paper analyses the impact of the LIPW component by leveraging a randomized impact evaluation of key STEP components. The project, implemented by the Social Fund of DRC (FSRDC), offered short-term employment to the urban poor, along with additional benefits created in order to make a lasting impact (namely an incentivized-savings scheme and vocational training). This study seeks to produce rigorous evidence on the post-program labor market and economic welfare outcomes.

Intervention

The urban LIPW component created short-term employment opportunities in five major cities in Eastern DRC: Beni, Butembo, Goma, Bukavu and Bunia. Local NGOs – under the supervision of the FSRDC – offered temporary employment to implement activities such as road rehabilitation, street cleaning or garbage collection. In each of the cities, a sensitization campaign was launched to announce the program. The LIPW programs – implemented on a rolling basis – were designed to target the urban poor through two mechanisms: first, self-targeting based on the minimum wage and, second, geographic targeting of the most deprived neighborhoods in each of the five cities. Any resident from a targeted neighborhood was eligible to receive project benefits as long as he/she was willing to work for the set wage – the country’s minimum wage of 3USD a day – and apt for physical labor. As designed, the project offered all selected beneficiaries with a full-time work for around 4 months, paid at minimum wage (3USD/day) as well as soft-skills training (health at work, cooperation, etc.) aiming to prepare efficient teamwork.

In order to make the impact last, the project offered two additional activities: 1) an incentivized-savings scheme, and 2) a training program. The incentivized savings arm of the program contained the opening (if needed) of a savings account, at no cost to the beneficiary. Then, beneficiaries where incentivized to save US$ 1 a day (out of the 3$ pay) against a 1$ extra-pay, directly placed on the savings account and available only by the end of the LIPW. In other words, beneficiaries of the savings scheme chose between being paid 3$/day, every day, or 2$/day everyday plus 2$ per worked day (on an account) at the end of the contract. Beneficiaries of the training program arm, on the other hand, were trained by professional NGOs on specific skills right after the end of each LIPW project. The skills were chosen based on a market study of local economic conditions. Trainings mainly provided beneficiaries with new professional skills or business management techniques. Training days were paid as any workday (3USD) and so beneficiaries of this treatment arm theoretically also benefited from an extra-income.

Experimental design

This paper is concerned with four main research questions: 1) What is the impact of the LIPW program on economic outcomes (income, consumption, employment, investments, savings)? 2) What is the additional impact of the savings incentive? 3) What is the additional impact of the training program? 4) What is the impact of all three activities combined?

The impact evaluation was designed to produce rigorous evidence on the causal impact of the LIPW program on these four main aspects. In each of the 26 targeted neighborhoods, public lotteries were held to assign candidates into one of four groups. A first group of beneficiaries was offered short-term employment. A second group was offered a savings incentive in addition to the temporary works component. A third group was offered the employment component in addition to a training program while a fourth group was offered all three program activities. Remaining applicants for each lottery form the pool of potential controls, from which a stratified random sample of 3,205 was selected.

Design details

Randomization method
Public lottery.
Randomization unit
Unit of randomization is at the individual level.
Clusters
NA
Observations
5,980 individuals
Arms
Treatment A: 700 Individuals Treatment B: 695 Treatment C: 693 Treatment D: 687 Control: 3,205 Individuals Extra workers (replacements, not considered in this study): 1,678
Primary outcomes
1) Active labor market participation 2) Monthly hours worked 3) Total monthly earnings 4) Total net financial savings 5) Use of formal financial institutions 6) Hard skills 7) Employment from other members of the household 8) Earnings by other members of the household 9) Total expenditures aggregates 10) Assets accumulation 11) Children schooling and welfare 12) Coping strategies 13) Remittances
Secondary outcomes
• Has worked in a job (C1.1 & C1.36) • Has looked for a job in the last 30 days (C1.3a) • Hours worked in wage employment (C1.9 & C1.20) /week • Hours worked in self-employment (C1.9 & C1.20) /week • Total days you spend in wage-employment in a typical month (C1.10 & C1.21) • Total days you spend in self-employment in a typical month (C1.10 & C1.21) • Total income from wage employment (C1.13, C1.24) • Total profits from self-employment (C1.12, C1.23) • Total sell from agricultural activities (C1.5.12) • Plus total savings (C2.4) • Minus total debt (C2.2.1 and interest rates C2.2.2b) • Has opened a bank account (C2.4) following LIPW (C2.4.1) • Used a formal saving system after LIPW (C2.3.1) • Used a formal lending system after LIPW (C2.2.2) • Received training in a trade since LIPW started (C3.1) • Possesses unused skills (C3.3) • Labor market difficulties when exist (C3.4) are not due to lack of skills (C3.4.1=(1|3)) • Business difficulties when exist (C3.5) are not due to lack of skills (C3.5.1=1) • Other household members or head is working (C1.28, C1.31 & C1.32) • Type of works from other household members or head (C1.29, C1.32) • Earnings from employment by the head of the household (if different than respondent) (C1.30) • Earnings from employment by other household members (C1.33, C1.35) • Food expenditure: o Total spent on food (B3.1.1.a) • Non-food expenditure: o Total spent on medical (B3.1.1.b) o Total spent on leisure (B3.1.1.c) o Total spent on clothing (B3.1.1.d) o Total spent on transportation (B3.1.1.e) o Total spent on energy and water (B3.1.1.f) o Total spent on phone and internet (B3.1.1.g) o Total spent on cosmetics (B3.1.1.h) o Total spent on other services (B3.1.1.j) • Dwelling (B2.4-B2.6); • Furniture & electronic equipment (B2.1); • Livestock (B2.1); • Real estate (B2.2); • Agricultural land (C1.37, C1.39, C1.40 if C1.36=1) • Schooling (B1.2, B1.6); • Worked over last month (C5.4); • Domestic work over the last month (C5.8); • Suffered from a common disease (at least one “yes” from E2.7 to E2.17) • Suffered a negative income shock or more (B4.1) • Were able to use savings or went through with no need for asset/investment depletion (B4.1.1) • Has received assistance from an NGO or the government (B4.2) • Household net position regarding financial assistance with relatives (Money given, B3.8, minus money received B3.5, B3.6, B3.7) is null or positive.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords