Matching of charitable contributions is a commonly used tactic in non-profits. However, estimating the causal effect of these matches is difficult if the matching is not randomly assigned. We propose an experiment where matching is (partially) randomly assigned for a subset of loans on a microfinance website, allowing for a direct estimate of the effect of the match on loan fundraising velocity. Then, we propose using non-choice data to estimate the same effect. These estimates will be compared to the experimentally derived average causal effect.
Experimental design
N/A
Design details
Randomization method
Randomization of loans done using the ID numbers of each loan: loans with an identifier ending in zero (e.g., 10, 20, 30) will be assigned to be matched; loans with other identifiers will be assigned to be unmatched.
Participants on Mechanical Turk will be shown a random set of loans selected by computer from the set of loans in previously run experiment.
Randomization unit
A loan posted on our partner microfinance website.
Clusters
1
Observations
Depends on depletion of matching funds and amount of other matching activity. We are aiming for 2000 loans total, and 500 in the complier subset.
500 Mechanical Turk Participants
Arms
Depends on depletion of matching funds and amount of other matching activity. We are aiming for 250 loans in matched and unmatched treatment.
Primary outcomes
The key object of prediction is the rate at which loans are funded during an initial period after posting. Our primary measure of this rate will be the inverse hyperbolic sine of the funding velocity over the first day.
We will assess how well we measure treatment effects using a variety of metrics (such as bias, mean-squared prediction error, and calibration, as in the working paper (Bernheim, Bjorkegren, Naecker, & Rangel, 2013)).
Secondary outcomes
We may also assess performance across these measures:
Inverse hyperbolic sine of funding velocity, first three days
Square root of funding velocity, first day
Square root of funding velocity, first three days
Funding velocity, first day
Funding velocity, first three days
Fraction of all funds raised on the site received by this loan, during the first day
Fraction of all funds raised on the site received by this loan, during the first three days
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.