Let me choose my incentives: A mindfulness intervention

How to cite

Romagnoli, GIORGIA; Lindemans, Jan Willem; Probst, Birgit; Cloughesy, Jonathan; Bartmann, Nina; Woerner, Andrej. 2019. "Let me choose my incentives: A mindfulness intervention." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004881. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4881-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

GIORGIA Romagnoli* , Jan Willem Lindemans , Birgit Probst , Jonathan Cloughesy , Nina Bartmann , Andrej Woerner

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004881
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4881-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2019-10-28 – 2020-04-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93, D0
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4881

Abstract

We implement a behavioral intervention intended to promote the take-up and maintenance of a mindfulness meditation habit. Over a period of 36 days, participants can complete daily online meditation sessions and receive monetary incentives to do so.
We compare a control group (where subjects receive access to the meditation sessions but no monetary incentives to complete them) to two incentive treatments where subjects receive monetary compensations. In one treatment, subjects are assigned one of two reward schemes: the first is based on a constant payment for each completed session; the second rewards subjects (comparatively more) for completing sessions in 3-days streaks. The second incentive treatment is identical to the first, except subjects are allowed to choose the scheme that they prefer between the two described above.
We explore the following questions: (1) Can mindfulness meditation habits be created and sustained by behavioral interventions similarly to other more commonly studied habits (such as gym attendance)?; (2) How does the dynamic incentive scheme compare to the constant incentive scheme?; (3) Does letting participants choose their own incentives increase engagement and completion rates?

Intervention

We test the effect of two monetary incentive schemes intended to support the take-up and maintenance of an online mindfulness meditation program. The program, inclusive of incentives, lasts for 36 days and is based on daily meditation sessions which last between 5 and 15 minutes. Subsequently, participants continue to have access to meditation sessions for two additional months but receive no additional payment.
Subjects have access to two types of incentive schemes: (i) Constant scheme, where they receive 2 euro for each complete meditation session; and (ii) Dynamic scheme, where subjects receive 8 euro for each sequence of three completed meditation sessions (3 days in a raw).
Subjects are randomized into 3 treatments: (1) control, (2) exogenous incentives, where one of the two incentive schemes is randomly assigned; and (3) endogenous incentives, where subjects can choose, between the two incentive schemes, the one that they prefer.

Experimental design

We test the effect of two monetary incentive schemes intended to support the take-up and retention of an online mindfulness meditation program. The program, inclusive of incentives, lasts for 5 weeks and is based on daily meditation sessions which last between 5 and 15 minutes. Subsequently, participants continue to have access to meditation sessions for two additional months but receive no additional payment.
Subjects have access to two types of incentive schemes: (i) Constant scheme, where they receive 2 euro for each complete meditation session; and (ii) Dynamic scheme, where subjects receive 8 euro for each sequence of three complete meditation sessions.
Subjects are randomized into 3 treatments: (1) control, (2) exogenous incentives, where one of the two incentive schemes is randomly assigned; and (3) endogenous incentives, where subjects can choose, between the two incentive schemes, the one that they prefer.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization by computer software (Qualtrics).
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
no clusters
Observations
about 480 participants
Arms
We will have about 160 participants per treatment. Subjects in the exogenous treatment are further randomized into the dynamic scheme (60%) and the static scheme (40%). The percentages are chosen to match the distribution of subjects in the endogenous treatment from pilot data collected prior to the intervention.
Primary outcomes
• Number of completed meditation sessions during the intervention period. • Indicator variables for assigned treatments (1: Control, 2: Exogenous incentives, 3: Endogenous incentives). • Indicator variables for incentive schemes (1: Static; 2: Dynamic).
Secondary outcomes
• Standardized self-reported mindfulness level. We will measure mindfulness level at baseline and end-line with the “Mindfulness attention awareness scale” (Brown, K.W. & Ryan, R.M., 2003); and in particular the Dutch version by Schroevers, M., Nykliček, I., & Topman, R., 2008]. • Standardized self-reported stress levels. We will measure stress levels at baseline and end-line with the Perceived Stress Scale (Cohen, S., Kamarck, T., & Mermelstein, R., 1983). • Standardized meditation motivation measure at baseline. Elicited with six questions extracted from the Intrinsic Motivation Inventory scale (Ryan, R. M., 1982). • Past meditation frequency at baseline. Self-reported typical number of meditation sessions per week, on a typical week prior to the study. • Meditation goals at baseline. Desired number of meditation sessions per week for the near future (before knowing about incentives). • Standardized desirability of control measure at baseline. Elicited with six questions extracted from the Desirability of Control Scale by Burger and Cooper (1979). • Risk aversion measure (Gneezy and Potters, 1997). • Beliefs at baseline about future completed meditation sessions, given assigned treatment. Participants in the endogenous treatment answer the belief questions both for the incentive scheme they choose and did not choose. Subjects are asked to guess how many meditation sessions they think they will complete during the study period. Incentivization: Subjects receive 1 euro if their guess is correct. • Standardized academic self-concept measured at baseline and endline. Elicited with six questions extracted from the Academic self-concept scale (REF) by Reynolds (1988). • Standardized self-esteem measured at baseline and endline with the “Self-Esteem Scale” by Rosenberg (1965), and in particular the Dutch version by Franck et al. (2008). • Time preferences measure elicited at endline. • Past meditation frequency and future meditation goals elicited at baseline. • Completed meditation sessions in the 2 months following the end of the intervention. • Demographic questions (age, gender, study program).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords