Understanding Mechanisms Underlying the Relationship between Witchcraft and Prosocial Behavior

How to cite

Lowes, Sara; Nunn, Nathan; Rossignol, Etienne Le. 2019. "Understanding Mechanisms Underlying the Relationship between Witchcraft and Prosocial Behavior." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004878. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4878-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Sara Lowes* , Nathan Nunn , Etienne Le Rossignol

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004878
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4878-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2019-07-22 – 2021-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4878

Abstract

We describe the analysis plan for analysis of survey data, which is aimed at probing mechanisms as a followup to findings from a previous study that examines the relationship between prosocial behavior and others’ beliefs in witchcraft in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (Lowes and Nunn, 2018). As with the first study, participants will be individuals living in a city in Sud-Ubangi province which is in northern DRC. Participants will complete a series of incentivized questions asking about how socially appropriate most people in the city will view various actions in three experimental games that involve another player. For each hypothetical game, the other player is anonymous, but participants are given some information about them. They are informed of the other player’s age, sex, educational level, if from the same ethnic group, strength of belief in the Christian God, strength of belief in witchcraft, and whether the individual is from the city. The primary experimental treatment is that the other player is randomly assigned to have either a strong or weak belief in witchcraft. We outline the study design, the treatments, and the econometric strategy for the analysis.

We will also expand our sample to include 50 villages in rural areas. We will administer the activities described in Lowes and Nunn, 2018, and also implement the activities described above.

Experimental design

The norms measurement strategy follows Krupka and Weber (2013). Individuals will be given information on how three experimental tasks are played. These tasks are a dictator game (DG), a choose your dictator game (CYD), and a joy of destruction game (JOD). The details of these experiments will be discussed shortly. These are the same experiments that participants completed in 2018.
After reviewing each experimental task, the participant will be asked to imagine that there is a hypothetical decision maker who is completing the experimental task. They participant will be given information on the identity of the person that the decision maker in the task has been paired with. For each possible choice that the decision maker in the task could make, the participant will be asked: “Is this choice very socially inappropriate, somewhat socially inappropriate, somewhat socially appropriate, very socially appropriate?.” Individuals are not given the exact identity of the player that the decision maker is paired with in the experimental tasks. However, they are given the following information about the other player: age group, sex, education level, ethnicity, strength of belief in the Christian God, strength of belief in witchcraft, and whether they grew up in Gemena. The primary experimental manipulation is the reported belief in witchcraft of the other player. Participants complete two iterations of the set of questions about each experimental activity. The assignment of player characteristics is stratified so that in one of the two iterations (randomly chosen), the participant answers questions about a decision maker who is paired with someone with either a ‘strong’ or ‘very strong’ belief in witchcraft and in the other, the participant answers questions about a decision maker who is paired with someone with a ‘weak or very weak’ or ‘neither believe or disbelieve’ belief in witchcraft.

Design details

Randomization method
The primary experimental manipulation is whether an individual is answering questions about someone with a strong or weak belief in witchcraft. The survey will be implemented on a tablet. The tablet will randomly assign the characteristics of the individual about whom the respondent answers the question. An respondent answers the questions for two different individuals: one with a strong belief in witchcraft and one with a weak belief in witchcraft.
Randomization unit
Randomization is done at the individual level.
Clusters
We aim to follow up with our sample from 2018, which had 520 individuals. We will also expand our sample. We will visit 50 rural villages and select a random sample of 12 villagers from each village for a rural sample of 600 individuals.
Observations
We aim to follow up with our sample from 2018, which had 520 individuals. The rural sample will be 600 individuals from 50 randomly selected villages.
Arms
Each individual is treated in the sense that they answer questions about how appropriate actions are in each game two times: one time when the other player has a strong belief in witchcraft and one time when the other player has a weak belief in witchcraft. We aim to follow up with our sample from 2018, which had 520 individuals. We will also expand our sample to include 600 individuals from rural areas (12 villagers across 50 villages).
Primary outcomes
The key outcome variables are how appropriate the various possible actions are that a hypothetical decision maker can make in the dictator game, choose your dictator game, and joy of destruction game.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords