Local authorities and tax collection: Experimental evidence from Tanzania
How to cite
Mwaijande, Francis; Kachwamba, Muhajir; Sagini, Jumanne; Badala, Kija; Lyimo, Eva; Sereri, Jasmini; Ally, Salama; Kawega, Mwanahamisi; Shirima, Diego; Mwakalikamo, Joshua. 2021. "Local authorities and tax collection: Experimental evidence from Tanzania." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004875. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4875-1.2000000000000002
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Property tax is one of the potential revenue sources in developing countries, but has shown little contribution to the total tax revenue. The existing evidence indicates that property tax contributes on average less than 1% of GDP in developing countries and below 0.5% of GDP for African countries. The Tanzanian context of property tax is of no difference from other developing countries, where property tax is one of the potential tax base that has limited contribution to the total tax revenue. While we acknowledge that there are many studies using SMS reminders to influence tax compliance; we leverage this strategy to study the additional effect of involvement of local authorities in tax compliance. We employed RCT method to examine the effect of messaging strategies and involvement of local leaders to increase property tax payment compliance. Participants were randomly allocated to three treatment arms and a control group using big-stick randomization method which led to a final sample of 668 Mjumbes (local leaders) and 21,328 taxpayers. The first treatment arm involved SMS reminder with a threat of fine, and second arm combined treatment for the first arm with an additional threat of involving local leaders in the tax collection process. The third arm involved the treatment in the first arm with an actual request for help from local leaders to increase tax compliance. Results indicate that in all treatment arms, the regression coefficients show positive impact and are significant at 1%. Furthermore, when the coefficient of the first treatment (T1) in column 1 of table 5 are compared to the same column for third treatment (T3), the coefficient of the third treatment arm (T3) revealed a 2.2 percentage point increase in payment status for all tax payers. These results suggest that actual Mjumbe involvement triggered an additional effect in compliance relative to the standard reminder SMS alone.
Intervention
A Randomized Control Trial (RCT) will be set to experiment the Effect of Mobile Phone Reminder Text Messages on Property Tax Compliance in Tanzania. A list of registered tax payers from tax authority will be obtained and then validated for quality check of phone numbers and other demographic information. Participants will be owners of properties (residential or business). From the current Tanzanian tax laws, property tax is imposed to buildings with residential or business purposes, but exclusion is given to public buildings, e.g., schools, health centers, and religious buildings such as mosques and churches. Random assignment draw will be made to assign the participants into two groups; treatment groups (T) and control (C). Randomization will be at the street level but outcome will be measured at the individual level of property owner for both groups. Peer effect design will be tested in the identified clusters. The treatment group will consist of one treatment arm (deterrence message) with three (3) varying levels described in section B. Participants will be selected from urban and semi-urban in which there are eligible property tax payers according to the law.
Experimental design
Deterrence message contents with varied exposure messages will be sent to clusters so as to measure the peer effects (PEs).
To test the peer effect, groups of 20 registered households will be created within the same street randomly assigned in Treatment arms indicated as:
o Treatment 1a: message content a, exposure level 1 (2 households in 20 hh group)
o Treatment 1a: message content a, exposure level 2 (10 households in 20 hh group)
o Treatment 1a: message content a, exposure level 3 (18 households in 20 hh group)
A Control: create groups of 50 registered property owners within the street, but No message /placebo-reminder message will be sent.
This means, a deterrent reminder message will be sent to the treatment cluster and send none to the untreated cluster groups. Testing for the peer effect, sms messages will be sent to property owners in randomly selected treatment clusters, and send no any messages to all property owners in the control clusters.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.