The Effect of Cash Transfers and Market Access on Households in Rural Liberia and Malawi

How to cite

Robinson, Jonathan; Spearot, Alan; Park, David Sungho; Kumar, Naresh; Jeong, Dahyeon; Aker, Jenny; Aggarwal, Shilpa. 2019. "The Effect of Cash Transfers and Market Access on Households in Rural Liberia and Malawi." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004869. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4869-2.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jonathan Robinson* , Alan Spearot , David Sungho Park , Naresh Kumar , Dahyeon Jeong , Jenny Aker , Shilpa Aggarwal

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004869
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4869-2.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2018-11-26 – 2021-08-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4869

Abstract

We are evaluating the impact of two cross-cut interventions: (1) a cash transfer program implemented by the NGO GiveDirectly, and (2) a market access intervention which reduces travel costs for farmers to access agricultural inputs like fertilizer and improved seeds. The study will take place in 600 villages in Liberia and Malawi (300 in each country). In each country, 100 villages will receive cash transfers only, 100 will serve as control, 50 will receive both cash transfers and market access, and 50 will receive market access only. Surveys will be conducted with 10 households per village.

We plan to conduct two separate analyses from this experiment.

First, we plan to evaluate the direct effect of cash transfers (controlling for market access). To do this, we will conduct a baseline and endline survey, which will include a host of outcomes. In addition, we will conduct high frequency phone surveys to measure dynamic impacts of transfers, with a particular focus on food consumption and related outcomes.

Second, we plan to evaluate the effect of market access and cash (and their interaction). This analysis will focus primarily on agricultural outcomes.

Intervention

There are two interventions. First, the NGO GiveDirectly is providing cash transfers to households. The value of this transfer is experimentally selected (at the village level) to be $250, $500, or $750 per household. These sums are paid out in monthly $250 increments, so that villages receive 1, 2, or 3 payments. There are several additional sub-randomizations. In Liberia, respondents are randomly chosen to be paid out quarterly, while others are paid over consecutive months. In Malawi, monogamously married households were randomly selected for either the male or female head of households to receive the transfer. Transfers are made via mobile money; since pre-existing mobile money usage is low, beneficiaries are given the option to buy cell phones (with the cost deducted from later transfers) and are given help in signing up for mobile money.

Second, a market access intervention is cross-randomized. Respondents are given a voucher to defray transportation costs to access inputs. In Liberia, agricultural input dealers set up stalls at local market centers where inputs were made available. In Malawi, a major agricultural input dealer set up events at prominent locations (such as primary schools). Inputs were not subsidized.

Experimental design

The experiment includes 600 total villages (300 in each country). The experiment will be cross-cut so that in each country 100 villages receive cash transfers, 100 serve as control, 50 receive market access only, and 50 receive both market access and cash. We plan to enroll a sample of 10 households per village, so that our target sample is 6,000 total households.

There are several sub-treatments within the cash transfer treatment arm. First, the value of the transfers was randomly selected to be $250, $500, or $750 per household. These sums are paid out in monthly $250 increments, so that villages receive 1, 2, or 3 payments. In addition, in Liberia, respondents are randomized into being paid this amount quarterly (i.e. spread out every 3 months for a year), or in 3 consecutive months. Finally, in Malawi, GiveDirectly randomized whether the male or female head of the household received the cash transfer (conditional on both spouses being home at the time of enrollment).

The randomization is stratified by administrative units known as “clan” in Liberia and “group village” in Malawi. Treatment intensity is randomly varied across group villages in Malawi and across geographic clusters in Liberia.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization by a computer, in Stata.
Randomization unit
Village
Clusters
600 villages (300 in Liberia and 300 in Malawi)
Observations
6,000 households (3,000 in Liberia and 3,000 in Malawi).
Arms
(1) 200 villages receive cash transfers only (100 in each country) (2) 200 villages receive nothing (pure control - 100 in each country) (3) 100 villages receive market access only (50 in each country) (4) 100 villages receive cash and market access (50 in each country)
Primary outcomes
Food Security, Expenditures, Agriculture, Income, Labor Supply, Assets, Health Behavior, Child Anthropometrics, Household Resilience, Interpersonal Transfers, Intimate Partner Violence
Secondary outcomes
Prices of food items

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords