Complementarities in Behavioral Interventions: Evidence from a Field Experiment on Energy Conservation

How to cite

Fang, Ximeng; Goette, Lorenz; Tiefenbeck, Verena; Sutter, Matthias; Rockenbach, Bettina; Staake, Thorsten; Schoeb, Samuel. 2019. "Complementarities in Behavioral Interventions: Evidence from a Field Experiment on Energy Conservation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004865. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4865-1.2000000000000002

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ximeng Fang* , Lorenz Goette , Verena Tiefenbeck , Matthias Sutter , Bettina Rockenbach , Thorsten Staake , Samuel Schoeb

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004865
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4865-1.2000000000000002
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2016-12-01 – 2017-07-31
Countries
Germany (North Rhine-Westfalia)
JEL codes
D12, D83, Q41
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4865

Abstract

Behavioral policy often aims at overcoming barriers like imperfect information or limited attention that cause suboptimal consumer decisions. We argue that when multiple barriers are present, it may be important to overcome them all at the same time, as intervention strategies eliminating only a single barrier can be undermined by the remaining barriers. Thus, behavioral interventions that are tailored towards addressing different barriers each can be complements, in the sense that each intervention is more effective in conjunction with the other(s) than in isolation. We conduct a three-month randomized field experiment on energy conservation in a resource-intensive everyday activity, using two different interventions, home energy reports and real-time feedback, which target information and attention barriers to different degrees, respectively. Crucially, we evaluate both the combined intervention as well as each intervention in isolation.

Home energy reports in isolation fail to reduce energy use despite achieving significant knowledge gains, whereas real-time feedback in isolation induces considerable conservation effects. Strikingly, combining both interventions boosts these effects by over 50 percent, thus showcasing how barrier multiplicity can generate complementarities in behavioral interventions.

Intervention

We study the effect of two types of behavioral interventions on energy conservation in a specific everyday activity (showering). The first intervention are home energy reports, which are delivered via email and provide information on water and energy use as well as CO2 emissions due to showering. The second intervention is real-time feedback on water use, which is delivered through a smart meter directly in the shower. Crucially, we also evaluate the combined intervention with both home energy reports and real-time feedback.

Experimental design

Initially planned design:
- Real-time feedback (RTF): yes or no
- Home energy reports (HER): yes or no
- If HER yes: Social comparison feedback either exogenous or endogenous (Endo)
-> 6 treatment arms: 1) RTF no + HER no, 2) RTF no + HER yes, 3) RTF no + HER yes + Endo, 4) RTF yes + HER no, 5) RTF yes + HER yes, 6) RTF yes + HER yes + Endo

As we only managed to recruit 361 subjects instead of the planned 600 subjects, we forwent the planned treatment groups 3) and 6) with endogenous social comparison. Instead we implemented a 2x2 experimental design with RTF yes/no and HER yes/no.

Design details

Randomization method
Smart meters with and without real-time feedback are distributed alternatingly from apartment to apartment in each student dormitory. Home energy reports are assigned based on a random draw on the computer.
Randomization unit
Individual/apartment level (only single-person apartments)
Clusters
361 individuals (intially planned: 600 individuals)
Observations
21,000 shower observations (intially planned: 40,000 shower observations)
Arms
90 individuals in each of the 4 groups (initially planned: 100 individuals each, 6 groups)
Primary outcomes
Energy and water consumption in the shower
Secondary outcomes
Awareness about resource use in the shower (learning), environmental attitude, subjective shower comfort

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords