Perception of body mass as signal of wealth: a survey experiment in Uganda.

How to cite

Macchi, Elisa. 2019. "Perception of body mass as signal of wealth: a survey experiment in Uganda.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004806. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4806-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Elisa Macchi*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004806
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4806-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2019-11-13 – 2020-02-29
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4806

Abstract

Worldwide, 2.8 million people die each year as a result of being overweight and contrary to popular opinion, nearly 80% of deaths by noncommunicable diseases (NCDs) occur in LMICs (WHO, 2010). To date, research on obesity mostly focuses on high income countries. Yet, there are reasons to believe that perceptions and characteristics of obesity might differ substantially in high and low income countries.
Among the differences, it has been observed that in LMICs - in contrast to high income countries - body mass correlates positively with socioeconomic status (WHO, 2010; Subramanian et al., 2011).

I hypothesise that, in line with a representativeness model of stereotypes, high body mass might be perceived as signal of wealth in LMICs.
I investigate this hypothesis with a survey experiment in a low-income country context, the urban area of Kampala in Uganda. In the experiment, to get at the causal effect of body mass, I randomly assign body mass exploiting photo-morphed portraits.

In the first part of the survey, respondents are shown a set of portraits and rate them in terms of wealth and other relevant characteristic. This setting allows to test if in the absence of reliable information on wealth - high body mass increases the likelihood of being perceived wealthy. To investigate the mechanism, the design varies the amount of information provided on wealth of the hypothetical individuals. In a second step, I investigate perceived returns to high body mass. I focus on access to credit and elicit respondents' implicit and explicit beliefs on returns to high body mass. I compare individuals' expectations of returns to high body mass with the actual rates of body mass discrimination. In a third part, I elicit expected beliefs on healthy behaviours. In a third part, I elicit nutritional knowledge and explicit beliefs on returns to high body mass.

Experimental design

This is a survey experiment.

In the first part, respondents see a portrait randomly chosen among a set of photo-morphed and original pictures. Each photo-morphed picture is obtained by photo-morphing a portrait of an individual from Kampala, either increasing or decreasing body mass.

Respondents provide their best guess, and expectations on others’ beliefs, on wealth, attractiveness, health, longevity, self-control and productivity of the individual as portrayed in the picture (see Survey tool Appendix). First order beliefs are not incentivised. Beliefs' on others beliefs are incentivised using pilot data. The experiment has two treatment arms: in 1) participants see a portrait and learn the age of the person. In 2) participants additionally learn that the person owns a car or a land title. The aim of the second treatment arm is to reduce asymmetric information in wealth, allowing to test for the signaling channel. Information treatment is randomly assigned at the individual level, to avoid lack of information to be interpreted as not-owning.

In the second part, individuals are shown a set of hypothetical loan applications and are asked to guess how the applications have been evaluated by a set of real loan officers currently employed in the greater Kampala area. The applications are created in the following way. In each application, the applicants' age, nationality and place of residence are defined statically, while the applicants' loan profile, collateral, reason for loan, occupation, income (profits and revenues), gender, portrait, body mass are cross-randomised. Body mass is randomized by assigning the high body mass or low body mass photomorphed version of the randomly selected portrait. To avoid suspicions, portraits are randomized without replacement across the full set of applications each respondents receives so that no picture is seen twice by the same respondent. Using the procedure detailed in the appendix, I first build 30 loan applications with all the cross randomized information, except body mass. Then I create the final set of 60 applications by creating two versions (a high body mass or low body mass) of each application. The 4 applications are randomly selected from the set of 60 applications, conditional on the picture in the application not being randomly selected in the first part. Answers are incentivised using the answers of real loan officers currently employed in Kampala (Ref. AEARCTR-0004528).

In the third part, respondents answer a set of questions including demographics, returns to healthy behaviours, nutritional knowledge, willingness to borrow and explicit beliefs on returns from body mass.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer
Randomization unit
Within subject for the body mass randomisation; Individual level randomization for the information treatment.
Clusters
500 individuals. Participants to the survey are individuals aged 20+ living in the greater Kampala area (Kampala, Mukono, Wakiso districts). The sample is stratified by gender, age and by wealth. Stratification by age is implemented by targeting three age groups: 20-30; 30-45; 45+. Stratification by wealth is obtained by ranking wards according to a poverty index based on dwelling's characteristics, share of households living on less than 2 meals per day, share of households which do not have a bank account.
Observations
Part 1: 2000 pictures (4 pictures per respondent) Part 2: 2000 applications (4 applications per respondent)
Arms
This is not an RCT. In the first part (section Beliefs and Perception), for each picture shown, either the higher body mass or the lower body mass version is randomly selected. For the income information treatment, 250 participants per treatment arm. In the second part (Section Ratings), for each picture shown, either the higher body mass or the lower body mass version is randomly selected. In the third part (Section Returns), 250 respondents are assigned to the nutrition treatment and 250 are assigned to the exercise treatment. Concerning Explicit beliefs, 1/3 of the sample is assigned a S3 to S5 weight change, 1/3 is assigned to a S5 to S7 weight change, 1/3 is assigned to a S7 to S9 weight change.
Primary outcomes
First order beliefs on wealth; Beliefs on other beliefs on wealth; Expectations of returns to body mass in access to credit.
Secondary outcomes
First order beliefs on Beauty, Health, Self-control, Life expectancy and productivity. Beliefs on others' beliefs on Attractiveness, Health, Self-control, Life expectancy, productivity. Explicit beliefs on returns to high body mass. Beliefs on returns to healthy and unhealthy behaviours. Other collected outcomes in the post experimental survey are: 1) nutritional knowledge information; 2) anthropometric information; 3) willingness to borrow

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords