On the Impact of Social Comparison on Physician Behavior
How to cite
Mueller, Tobias; Gerfin, Michael; Gestel, Raf Van; Doorslaer, Eddy Van. 2019. "On the Impact of Social Comparison on Physician Behavior." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004747. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4747-1.2
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Primed by the ongoing political and academic debate about rising health costs and the over-provision of medical care in the developed world, this research project strives at gaining an in-depth understanding about how the provision of social comparison information influences physician behavior, adherence to clinical guidelines and quality of care. To this end, we are planning to run a pragmatic randomized trial in which general practitioners (GPs) from the universe of all GPs active in the outpatient sector in Switzerland are randomly assigned to either an intervention group receiving social comparison letters or the control group (no letter). The information in the social comparison letters is extracted from routinely collected insurance claims data and contains information about the health care costs or practice style behavior (e.g. vaccination rate, generic drug use) of a GP in comparison to peers with a comparable risk pool of patients. Previous studies have shown that peer comparison information has the potential to significantly influence individual decision-making in various contexts thereby motivating the extension to the proposed physician population (e.g. Meeker et al., 2016; Allcott & Rogers, 2014).
Intervention
We randomly assigned general practitioners (GPs) from the universe of all primary care providers active in the outpatient sector in Switzerland to receive peer comparison letters containing information on low-value care (i.e., vitamin D testing and generic substitution) or medical spending in comparison to GPs with a comparable risk pool of patients. Primary care providers in the control group receive no social comparison letter.
The letter will be sent out once at the beginning of the intervention period and the short-term reaction is tracked after half a year. To capture the long-term response, information on the main outcomes will be gathered again after one year.
Experimental design
Nation-wide pragmatic randomized trial using a full factorial design allocating physicians to either the control or one of the intervention arms receiving peer comparison information.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.