Shaping preferences for cooperation in the context of primary education

How to cite

Hett, Florian; Wagner, Valentin; Schunk, Daniel; Mechtel, Mario. 2019. "Shaping preferences for cooperation in the context of primary education." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004741. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4741-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Florian Hett* , Valentin Wagner , Daniel Schunk , Mario Mechtel

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004741
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4741-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2019-09-23 – 2020-09-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4741

Abstract

Our research project focuses on individual preferences for cooperation. It addresses the questions where differences in cooperative behavior stem from and whether and how preferences for cooperation can be influenced. We analyze how the particular style and content of social interaction between teachers and children shape cooperative attitudes on a day-to-day basis within the context of primary education using a randomized controlled trial. In our treatment, coaches providing afternoon childcare at our partner schools engage children in a broad variety of group games and activities explicitly featuring the experience of well-functioning cooperation for a period of eight to nine weeks. The project aims at measuring short- and long-run effects of the treatment and investigating underlying mechanisms.

Experimental design

Our project consists of a randomized controlled trial (RCT) investigating how the particular style and content of social interaction between teachers and children shapes cooperative attitudes on a day-to-day basis. In our treatment, tutors providing afternoon childcare at our partner schools engage children in a broad variety of group games and activities, which explicitly afford the experience of well-functioning cooperation for a period of eight to nine weeks.

Design details

Randomization method
We first contact schools that have an established afternoon-care system for first graders and ask the schools and subsequently the parents for consent. Then, from the pool of all children taking part in afternoon childcare, we randomly assign children for which we have consent into groups of four or five. Subsequently, we assign the peer groups, stratified on gender composition and the children’s language skills either to the cooperative afternoon childcare program (treatment condition) or to the regular afternoon childcare program (control condition). Stratification algorithm: 1- Determining the number of treatment groups (4/5 children per group) in a school: a. Divide total number of children with parental consent in a school by 2. b. Test whether it is possible to split the halved population into groups of 4 or 5 children. If yes: this determines the number of treatment groups within the school; approximately 50% of the children are part of the treatment condition, while 50% are part of the control condition. If no: formation of a reasonable number of treatment groups within the school; slightly more than 50% of the children are part of the treatment condition; while slightly less than 50% are part of the control condition. [Example 1: 20 children in a school, 10 in the treatment condition, 10 in the control condition, 2 treatment groups with 5 children each. Example 2: 23 children in a school; 12 in the treatment condition, 11 in the control condition; 3 treatment groups with 4 children each.] 2- Determining the number of children per stratification cell: Determine the number of children within each of the four cells: “Girl, German-speaking household”, “Boy, German-speaking household”, “Girl, Foreign first language household”, “Boy, Foreign first language household”. 3- Assignment of children to the treatment/control condition: a. The relation between the number of treatment and control condition children (1b) determines the assignment of children to T/C for each of the 4 stratification cells. In the balanced case, 50% of the children in each cell are assigned to the treatment/control condition. In the unbalanced case, a lot determines which of the 4 stratification cells comprises a higher share of treatment/control children in order to reach the number of observations per experimental condition as determined in 1b. b. Once we know the number of children per stratification cell who should be assigned to either the treatment or control condition, each child is randomly assigned to one of the two conditions by drawing lots. 4- Assignment of children to the treatment groups: depending on the number of treatment groups in a school, all children who were randomly assigned to the treatment condition in 3b are now randomly assigned to the specific treatment groups by drawing lots.
Randomization unit
See above and below
Clusters
About 20 schools and we would expect to have about 9 clusters (groups of five) per school, i.e. 180 clusters in total.
Observations
Our targeted number of observations is 900 children, ideally 450 in the treatment and 450 in the control group. This would correspond to about 20 schools and we would expect to have about 9 clusters (groups of five) per school, i.e. 180 clusters in total.
Arms
Our targeted number of observations is 900 children, ideally 450 in the treatment and 450 in the control group.
Primary outcomes
Our central outcome variable is a child’s preference for cooperation. To measure this, we employ the experimental protocol described and applied in Hermes et al. (forthcoming) (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jebo.2018.12.032). As an intermediate outcome variable, we measure perceived norms of cooperation as well as altruism. To do so, we add another stage to the protocol described in that paper, which features a third-party punishment game and a dictator game.
Secondary outcomes
As additional control variables, we elicit experimental measures for competitiveness, risk preferences, and time preferences. We aim at measuring these outcomes at several points in time: directly before and after the treatment phase, one year after the treatment phase, and also long term. All our measurement protocols are available on GitHub: https://github.com/jo3rn/oTree-apps and https://github.com/jo3rn/KidsCOOP. We also elicit a broad set of additional measures by using questionnaires with parents and teachers. The questionnaire files can be found here https://seafile.rlp.net/f/dc460bd0a677493088d7/ (PW: CoopKids) and are also uploaded as a supplement to this document.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords