Targeting Incentive Contracts in Heterogeneous Populations

How to cite

Zucker, Ariel; Dizon-Ross, Rebecca. 2019. "Targeting Incentive Contracts in Heterogeneous Populations." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004735. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4735-1.6

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ariel Zucker* , Rebecca Dizon-Ross

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004735
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4735-1.6
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2019-05-01 – 2021-12-31
Countries
India (Tamil Nadu)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4735

Abstract

Providing financial incentives to encourage behavioral change is increasingly common: policymakers pay people to exercise, to study more, and maintain tree cover. In designing incentives for behavior change, there is frequently a tradeoff between motivating those with high and low costs of engaging in the behavior: whereas the optimal contract for high-cost individuals will have a large incentive or a low behavior target, the optimal contract for low-cost individuals will have a small incentive or a large behavior target. This project will investigate methods for targeting incentive contracts for behavioral change to individuals with heterogeneous behavior cost. In a randomized controlled trial among individuals with diabetes and prediabetes, we will experimentally evaluate two methods for targeting incentive contracts for walking: individual contract choice, and targeting on observable characteristics. We will first show that in our setting, contracts with a higher step target are more effective for individuals with low walking costs at baseline. Second, we will assess the relative performance of our two targeting methods in terms of targeting precision and walking encouragement. Finally, we will explore the role of key challenges to implementing each method, including the endogeneity and limited information content of observable characteristics, and the principal and agent’s imperfect knowledge of preferences.

Experimental design

We randomly assign individuals to one of three targeting regimes: choice, targeting on observables, and random assignment. In addition, a small monitoring group is included for benchmarking purposes; this group will not receive any incentive contract, but we will monitor their steps. We will cross-randomize information on which step target we believe is most likely to be most effective at encouraging walking.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is stratified based on our forecasted median age (49) and gender. Ordered treatment assignment lists for each stratum cell are randomly generated in the office by a computer using Stata 15, and treatments are assigned to participants on rolling basis.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
1
Observations
We aim to enroll approximately 4,000 diabetics, pre-diabetics, hypertensives, and prehypertensives in Experiment 1. We aim to enroll approximately 750 diabetics, pre-diabetics, hypertensives, and prehypertensives in the "Baseline Choice" group added in Experiment 2 and continuing into Experiment 3. We aim to enroll approximately 3-4,000 diabetics, pre-diabetics, hypertensives, and prehypertensives in Experiment 3. We will continue enrollment in Experiment 3 as our funding allows.
Arms
The following treatment group distribution is approximate, since enrollees will be assigned to treatments according to baseline strata in a pre-determined order, and some may withdraw following randomization but prior to the intervention. Experiment 1: Incentive Groups: T1 – Random, 10,000 step target: 15% T2 – Random, 12,000 step target: 25% T3 – Random, 14,000 step target: 15% T4 – Choice 1: 25% T5 – Choice 2: 0.5% T6 – Targeting: 17.5% Non-incentive Group: Monitoring Only: 2% Information Treatment: 60% of the experimental sample excluding the Targeting group will be cross-randomized into the Information treatment prior to deciding which contract they prefer in Choice Menu 1. Experiment 2: 20% Baseline Choice 80% Allocated to Experiment 1 (no change to those within Experiment 1) Experiment 3: Incentive Groups: T1 – Random, 10,000 step target: 9.3% T2 – Random, 12,000 step target: 9.3% T3 – Random, 14,000 step target: 9.3% T4 – Choice 1: 19% T5 – Choice 2: 0.5% T8 – Choice 3: 19% T6 – Targeting: 10% T7 – Baseline Choice: 19% Non-incentive Group: Monitoring Only: 4.25% Phase-in period duration cross-randomization: 60% of the experimental sample will be cross-randomized into a 13-day (rather than 6-day) phase-in period.
Primary outcomes
Daily steps taken during intervention.
Secondary outcomes
Indicators for daily steps above 10,000, 12,000, and 14,000; Distance from assigned step target to “optimal” step target; step target assigned; steps taken during “phase-in period”.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords