Decision Making for Others and the Preference for Competition

How to cite

Ifcher, John; Zarghamee, Homa. 2019. "Decision Making for Others and the Preference for Competition." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004731. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4731-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

John Ifcher* , Homa Zarghamee

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004731
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4731-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2019-10-05 – 2019-12-15
Countries
United States of America (California), United States of America (New York)
JEL codes
J16, C91, D90, J24
Secondary IDs
Russel Sage Foundation Grant # 98_16_07
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4731

Abstract

We examine whether the gender-variant preferences for competition identified in the literature apply in decision-making for others (DMfO). Specifically, we will conduct a laboratory experiment in which subjects make decisions regarding willingness to compete on behalf of themselves and on behalf of others. Our willingness to compete measure follows closely the measure used in Neiderle and Vesterlund (2007).
Subjects will be assigned (by session) to either make decisions on behalf of themselves first (control) or on behalf of a randomly-assigned subject in the same session first (treatment). It warrants mention that when making decisions on behalf of another subject, the decision maker will know the gender of the person on whose behalf they are making the decision. All subjects will make decisions both on behalf of themselves and others; the only difference between treatment and control groups is the order in which they make those decisions. The study includes a second experimental intervention. Specifically, half of the subjects will be randomly-assigned to the "skin in the game" condition. These subjects will receive 10 percent of the earnings of subject on whose behalf they make the decision if the payment task is a DMfO task. The other half of the subjects will make un-incentivized DMfO decisions. Thus, the study is a 2 X 2 designed: DMfO first or DMfO second versus skin-in-the-game condition or no skin-in-the-game condition.

This investigation of willingness to compete in DMfO is motivated by two policy-relevant factors. First, a popular explanation for gender differences in various academic and labor-market settings is a lack of mentorship for women. DMfO research can help understand the nature of mentor’s decisions. Second, sponsorship (giving mentors a stake in mentee’s outcomes) has been proposed as a policy to help close gender gaps. In an experiment similar to Niederle and Vesterlund, Baldiga & Coffman (2018) find that sponsorship only serves to increase the
competitiveness of the worst performing men, thereby increasing the gender gap in willingness to compete. In the Baldiga & Coffman experiment, though, sponsors did not make decisions on behalf of subjects, nor did they indicate in any way what they thought subjects should do; as such, the effect of DMfO, an important dimension of real-world mentorship/sponsorship relationships, has not been studied in this context.

Intervention

Subjects' willingness to compete (and preference for competition) will be measured following the methods used in Neiderle and Vesterlund (2007). The intervention is to randomly assign subjects (by session) to either make decisions on behalf of themselves first (control) or on behalf of a randomly-assigned subject in the same session first (treatment). It warrants mention that when making decisions on behalf of another subject, the decision maker will know the gender of the person on whose behalf they are making the decision. All subjects will make decisions both on behalf of themselves and others; the only difference between treatment and control groups is the order in which they make those decisions. The study includes a second experimental intervention. Specifically, half of the subjects will be randomly-assigned to the "skin in the game" condition. These subjects will receive 10 percent of the earnings of subject on whose behalf they make the decision if the payment task is a DMfO task. The other half of the subjects will make un-incentivized DMfO decisions. Thus, the study is a 2 X 2 designed: DMfO first or DMfO second versus skin-in-the-game condition or no skin-in-the-game condition.

Experimental design

We examine whether the gender-variant preferences for competition identified in the literature apply in decision-making for others (DMfO). Specifically, we will conduct a laboratory experiment in which subjects make decisions regarding willingness to compete on behalf of themselves and on behalf of others. Our willingness to compete measure follows closely the measure used in Neiderle and Vesterlund (2007).
Subjects will be assigned (by session) to either make decisions on behalf of themselves first (control) or on behalf of a randomly-assigned subject in the same session first (treatment). All subjects will make decisions both on behalf of themselves and others; the only difference between treatment and control groups is the order in which they make those decisions. The study includes a second experimental intervention. Specifically, half of the subjects will be randomly-assigned to the "skin in the game" condition. These subjects will receive 10 percent of the earnings of subject on whose behalf they make the decision if the payment task is a DMfO task. The other half of the subjects will make un-incentivized DMfO decisions. Thus, the study is a 2 X 2 designed: DMfO first or DMfO second versus skin-in-the-game condition or no skin-in-the-game condition.

Design details

Randomization method
Subjects will be randomized by session. Sessions will be run at Columbia and Santa Clara University. At each university, the first scheduled session will be randomly assigned, by coin toss, to either a decision making on behalf of oneself first or on behalf of another first. Thereafter, the sessions will alternate between decisions on behalf of oneself first and decisions on behalf of others first. We will endeavor to balance the day of the week and start time of the sessions for the two types of sessions.
Randomization unit
Session. There will be approximately 20 sessions. Each session will have approximately 25 subjects. Approximately 10 sessions will be run at Columbia University and approximately 10 sessions will be run at Santa Clara University.
Clusters
Approximately 500 subjects randomized into approximately 20 sessions.
Observations
Approximately 500 subjects.
Arms
Approximately 500 subjects. Approximately 250 subjects will make decisions on behalf of oneself first and approximately 250 subjects will make decisions on behalf of others first. Approximately half of the treatment and control groups will be in the skin-in-the-game condition. The other half of the treatment and control groups will be in the no skin-in-the-game condition.
Primary outcomes
Willingness to compete for self and willingness to compete for others (these outcome measures are used to measure the preference for competition).
Secondary outcomes
Ranking of own performance, ranking of other's performance, and risk-preference elicitation.

Materials

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords