Counseling the Unemployed in France (OPP/CVE)

How to cite

Crepon, Bruno; Gurgand, Marc; Behaghel, Luc. 2015. "Counseling the Unemployed in France (OPP/CVE)." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000472. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.472-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Bruno Crepon* , Marc Gurgand , Luc Behaghel

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0000472
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.472-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2005-01-01 – 2009-05-11
Countries
France (Europe)
JEL codes
J22, J64, J68
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/472

Abstract

This project reports the results of a large-scaled randomized controlled experiment comparing the public and private provision of counseling to job seekers. The intention-to-treat estimates of both programs are not statistically different, but more workers were enrolled in the private program, implying an effect per beneficiary that is twice as large under the public as under the private program. We find suggestive evidence that the private firms may have insufficiently mastered the counseling technology, and exercised less effort on those who had the best chance to find a job. This highlights the incentive problems in designing contracts for these services.

Intervention

All jobseekers involved in the experiment initially passed through the main public unemployment agency ANPE. People in the experiment are jobseekers identified by caseworkers as "at risk of long-term unemployment" and were classified into three different categories:

Population 1: Newly unemployed at risk of long-term unemployment - people who have just entered unemployment and are eligible for more than 120 days of unemployment benefits;
Population 2: Stock Unemployed at risk of long-term unemployment - those who were already unemployed at the beginning of the experiment;
Population 3: Ineligible Newly Unemployed at risk of long-term unemployment - people that have just become unemployed, but are eligible for less than 120 days of unemployment

Two separate programs were designed to support job seekers who have been, or are at risk of long-term unemployment:
(1) Cap Vers l'Entreprise (CVE), provided directly by ANPE;
(2) Opérateurs Privés de Placement (OPP), supplied by private firms mandated by UNEDIC.

Each program offered similar forms of assistance and support which consisted of weekly personal counseling and monitoring by a counselor who worked with a limited number of jobseekers. The counseling lasted for at most six months and aimed to assist jobseekers in finding stable employment. This included an intensive follow-up, with at least a weekly contact (email, phone) and a monthly face-to-face meeting between the job seeker and his personal counselor. Compared to the usual track, where a contact is supposed to take place every month, this is a significant increase in human resources dedicated to follow the job seeker. The support also included continued monitoring of the individuals in their new employment.

The OPP program only accepted ineligible newly unemployed people (population 1). The CVE program accepted all three populations (population 1-2-3)

Experimental design

Registered jobseekers of population 1 were randomly assigned into each of the three groups: CVE, OPP, or the normal ANPE track (control group), which included much less intensive support.
Jobseekers from the "stock unemployed" (population 2) and "ineligible newly unemployed" (population 3) were not eligible for the OPP program, and so they were randomly assigned to either the CVE program or the normal ANPE track.

Design details

Randomization method
Used Extranet program to randomly assign.
Randomization unit
individual (job seeker)
Clusters
Number of observation was not planned. Up to 40,000 slots were available for OPP and up to 40,00 for CVE. Entry in the program was maintained over a year. All eligible job seekers were registered in the experiment and allocated to treatment groups based on probabilities regularly up dated so as to meet capacity constraints and requirements.
Observations
same as clusters
Arms
Population 1: OPP 45460; CVE 9875; Regular 13055 Population 2: CVE 29257; Regular 34684 Population 3: CVE 33315; Regular 53387
Primary outcomes
Data on employment status was collected for three, six and nine month intervals from administrative records and telephone surveys on a sub sample of jobseekers. In ongoing analysis, researchers are interested in estimating not only the average duration of unemployment, whether the counseling affects long term unemployment levels through a better matching of individuals to jobs. The main outcome variables are employment outcomes (especially at six months) but also at 9 and 12 month

Materials

Papers from this trial

  1. The paper reports the results of the experiment for jobseekers of population 1 (job-seeker newly unemployed with at least 120 days of unemployment benefits) in areas were private and public services …
  2. Behaghel, Luc, Bruno Crépon, and Marc Gurgand. 2014. "Private and Public Provision of Counseling to Job Seekers: Evidence from a Large Controlled Experiment." American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 6(4): 142-74. http://www.povertyactionlab.org/publication/private-and-public-provision-counseling-job-seekers-evidence-large-controlled-experiment

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords