Strength in numbers? Understanding the role of gender group composition on knowledge contribution.
How to cite
Baldassari, Daphne. 2019. "Strength in numbers? Understanding the role of gender group composition on knowledge contribution.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004679. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4679-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In 2018, women remain underrepresented in senior management positions in key sectors such as the technology and financial investment sectors [Catalyst, 2018]. Although research has identified the impact of stereotypes on women’s and men’s decisions [Gorman, 2005; Coffman, 2014], it remains unclear how firms from these industries can develop an organizational design that helps reduce the strong and persistent impact of stereotypes on individual decisions such as knowledge contribution and persistence in the industry.
This project examines through which mechanism gender group composition—the number of women in a group relative to the number of men—impacts the decision to contribute ideas to a group in the male-typed domain of financial and investment services. Building on insights from the literature on belonging uncertainty and stereotype inoculation [Walton, 2007; Cohen, 2008; Brands and Fernandez-Mateo, 2017; Dasgupta, 2015], I theorize that being in a female-majority group will reduce women’s belonging uncertainty and help foster women’s decision to contribute knowledge in the group.
Recent findings by Chen and Houser [2017] highlight that gender group composition influences the impact of stereotypes on individuals’ knowledge contribution. Using the place-in-line game proposed by Coffman [2014] to measure the willingness to contribute, I will test whether the impact of gender group composition on the decision to contribute knowledge is mediated by a decrease in women's belonging uncertainty.
Intervention
The intervention - random assignment of individuals to a three-people group - will occur at each odd round of the group phase. The gender group composition is randomly determined.
Experimental design
1. Participants will be recruited from various undergraduate pools at the University of Toronto.
2. Participants will be asked three questions to determine their belonging uncertainty to the finance industry. These questions are adapted from the belonging uncertainty scale by Walton and Cohen (2007).
3. Participants will answer multiple choice questions on finance individually and will be asked to assess their confidence in their answers.
4. Participants will start the group phase, which consist of 10 rounds. At each odd round, they are randomly assigned to a group. They are asked to answer a new set of multiple choice questions on finance and to decide their place in line, which determines their willingness to have their answer be picked as the group’s answer. A random round will be selected where participants are asked again three questions to determine their belonging uncertainty to the finance industry.
Before starting the group phase, they will have an explanation of the place-in-line game and will be asked to answer two comprehension questions. Every decision is incentivized. Within each group, the only information communicated about the group is the gender of the group members.
5. At the end of the experiment, participants will be asked for a final time to answer the three questions related to the belonging uncertainty scale and to fill a post-experiment survey.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.