Watching the State: Can New Technologies Promote (a Sense of) Democracy?

How to cite

Faikina, Anastasiia. 2019. "Watching the State: Can New Technologies Promote (a Sense of) Democracy?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004635. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4635-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Anastasiia Faikina*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004635
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4635-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2019-08-22 – 2019-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D72, D73, K42, P16
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4635

Abstract

Why do autocrats implement new technologies aimed at increasing transparency - to curb corruption or to create a veneer of democracy? This project studies the effects of technology of video monitoring of election on its outcomes, the behavior of local authorities and citizens' beliefs in one prominent authoritarian regime, Russia. Using administrative data on results of the 2018 Presidential election, I show that video monitoring suppressed voter turnout by 5% and reduced the number of votes cast for the incumbent by 8.5%, consistent with an improvement in electoral accountability. However, these effects were partially mitigated by displacement of votes to nearby unmonitored polling stations. To test the mechanisms and evaluate the effects of video monitoring on citizens’ beliefs and behavior, I conduct online and in-person survey experiments ahead of the 2019 Single Voting Day. In particular, I remind respondents in the treatment group that many polling stations in the upcoming election will have video monitoring that anyone can freely stream on the government-run website. Afterward, I elicit respondents' voting behavior and beliefs, perceptions about elections, and general views on democracy.

Intervention

The intervention consists of two survey experiments conducted online and in-person. The treatment group receives a reminder that many polling stations in the upcoming election will be equipped with video monitoring. It also provides information that the government-run website <name> will freely stream the election day online. The control group does not receive any information about video monitoring. After the treatment is introduced, I elicit respondents’ voting behavior and beliefs, trust in elections, and general views on democracy. To elicit voter intimidation, I cross-randomize a listing experiment over the main treatment.

Experimental design

In-person survey. About two weeks before Single Voting Day, I will conduct a survey experiment on a subsample of respondents of a nationally representative survey who indicate that there will be elections in their locality. Half of this subsample will be assigned to a treatment group which will be reminded about the presence of video monitoring at many polling stations. They will also be given information that the government-led website <name> will stream the election day online and asked whether they will watch it. Respondents in the control group will not receive any information about video monitoring.

Online survey. Wave 1. Two weeks before Single Voting Day, I will use the online survey platform Anketolog to recruit 1,600 respondents who reside in the regions that will have Gubernatorial elections. Half of them (800 respondents) will be assigned to a treatment group that will get a reminder about video monitoring in the upcoming elections. Another half (800 respondents) will not get any information about video monitoring. Afterward, I will elicit respondents’ intended voting behavior, beliefs about the voting behavior of others, and perceptions of electoral integrity.

Wave 2. After Single Voting Day, I will attempt to recontact the same sample of 1,600 respondents. I will elicit their real voting behavior, perceptions of electoral integrity, and general views on democracy. I will also cross-randomize half of them into a listing experiment to elicit voter intimidation. Moreover, I will elicit their knowledge and engagement in video monitoring, as well as their beliefs on its effectiveness.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is conducted by survey firms.
Randomization unit
Randomization is done at individual level.
Clusters
Treatment is not clustered. Information on the number of observations is presented below.
Observations
(1) In-person survey: A subsample of a nationally representative sample of 1,600 respondents who will indicate that there will be elections in their locality on the 2019 Single Voting Day (approximately 60% of the full sample according to the electoral calendar). (2) Online survey: 1600 respondents who reside in the regions that will have gubernatorial elections on the 2019 Single Voting Day.
Arms
In-person survey: 1/4 of the subsample that has elections control-no listing, 1/4 of the subsample control-listing, 1/4 of the subsample treatment-no listing, 1/4 of the subsample treatment-listing. Online survey: 1/4 of the sample (~400 respondents) control-no listing, 1/4 of the sample (~400 respondents) control-listing, 1/4 of the sample (~400 respondents) treatment-no listing, 1/4 of the sample (~400 respondents) treatment-listing. Note: There is a probability of attrition from the 2nd wave of the online survey.
Primary outcomes
Voting behavior, Voter intimidation, Trust in elections, Views on democracy
Secondary outcomes
Knowledge about video monitoring, Engagement in video monitoring, Effectiveness of video monitoring

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords