Unintended Consequences of Health Awareness Campaigns: A Field Experiment in Cairo

How to cite

Ibanez, Marcela; Karbala, Ghida. 2019. "Unintended Consequences of Health Awareness Campaigns: A Field Experiment in Cairo." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004614. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4614-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Marcela Ibanez* , Ghida Karbala

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004614
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4614-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2016-03-01 – 2016-04-30
Countries
Egypt (Cairo)
JEL codes
I19, I31, J18
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4614

Abstract

We study the effect of health awareness campaigns on cognitive load and behavioral preferences implementing a field experiment with a representative sample of adult individuals residing in Cairo, Egypt. Participants in a door-to-door survey were assigned to watch videos about a commonly spread and highly contagious disease affecting children or a placebo video. Consistent with dual process theories, we find that the health awareness video impaired cognition of the targeted population in terms of lower scores on cognitive ability and fluid intelligence tests compared with the control group. The results show that participants who experienced financial and health stress in their daily life were mostly affected by the treatment. The findings emphasize the need to account for cognitive taxation when designing interventions and determining target beneficiaries.

Intervention

We investigate whether exposure to information has unintended negative consequences on the targeted population. Particularly we ask whether access to health- awareness information can generate cognitive tax among the targeted beneficiaries hence influencing their decision making process. To generate awareness on the causes, consequences, and recommended precautions related to Accute Respiratory Infection, we launched an independent door to door campaign. Adults with and without children were exogenously selected to be exposed to one of two health awareness videos or to a control placebo video. The videos replicated commonly used formats in awareness campaigns and lasted on average 12 minutes.

Experimental design

We used a between-subject experimental design in which participants were exposed to one of three different videos.
The health awareness video discussed the causes, symptoms and consequences of acute respiratory Infections (ARIs). This video was presented in one of two formats. The first version of the video focused in the long term consequences of ARIs on children’s health. In this version, the information presented emphasized the contagious characteristic of the disease, the problems of late diagnosis and the health complications that could arise on the long run. The second version of the video focused on the financial burden associated with
treating the direct and indirect health consequences of ARIs. In this version, we offered precise figures on the estimated costs of medication and treatment. Both versions comprehensively explained the required precautions in order to reduce vulnerability to the infection.

The placebo treatment discussed the consequences of wildlife poaching and ways to facilitate conservation. To ensure comparability, the videos were designed to be homogeneous in terms of duration, narration, language, and complexity of footage and information presented. Throughout this paper, we will refer to the above manipulations as the health, finance and control (placebo) treatments.

The videos were composed of six segments each lasting approximately two minutes. Following each of the six segments, we interrupted the video to obtain measures on cognitive functioning and individual preferences (e.g. risk, time, competition).

Design details

Randomization method
The sample used was drawn in a two step-procedure using household lists generated in 2014. The selection and treatment allocation was done using Schneider and Schlather (2017) approach for multiple treatment assignment. The main idea of this procedure is to minimize the differences in a covariance matrix resembling the observable characteristics of participants allocated to the different treatments. The minimization is performed by replacing selected individuals from the comparison groups with new individuals from the sample until the process converges to a low difference in the statistic. We applied this procedure separately for married couples and for a comparable sample of never married men and women.
Randomization unit
Individual. We consider single men and women and compared them with married participants.
Clusters
5 localities.
Observations
640 individuals
Arms
215 individuals in control, 205 health treatment and 220 in finance treatment.
Primary outcomes
We consider the impacts on mental clarity and fluid intelligence. In addition we study the impacts on risk preferences in gains and losses, competition preferences, time preferences in the short and long run and inconsistency in time preferences.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords