Financial reward schemes in microfinance

How to cite

Stryjan, Miri; Deserranno, Erika. 2019. "Financial reward schemes in microfinance." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004529. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4529-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Miri Stryjan* , Erika Deserranno

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004529
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4529-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2018-09-01 – 2020-07-31
Countries
Uganda ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4529

Abstract

We evaluate the effect of incentive schemes (bonuses) on the performance of credit officers working for a large microfinance institution. Specifically, we compare between a bonus scheme based on individual performance and a bonus scheme based on team performance.

Individual behavior is largely driven by incentives, yet those faced by employers and employees are often misaligned - the classic principal-agent problem. A large theoretical literature is concerned with the design of contracts that provide solutions to the agency problem. One commonly proposed tool for addressing agency problems is the provision of financial reward schemes, or bonuses. In organizations with a social mission, or where agents are expected to perform on both measurable and non-measurable tasks, such schemes may perform worse because only certain tasks can be rewarded in this way, and these tend to be the non-social tasks (Holmström and Milgrom, 1991, Holmström and Milgrom, 1994). Earlier research findings also suggest that financial rewards risk to crowd out employees’ intrinsic motivation to “do good”. Such motivation is of particular relevance to the public sector and in organizations with a social mission, including those in the microfinance sector. Despite these potential risks, financial reward schemes are pervasive in organizations, and only a number of recent experiments from developing countries have evaluated such schemes.

This study adds to the literature on financial reward schemes in organizations. The microfinance setting is an interesting one in which to evaluate bonus schemes as credit officers are in frequent contact with the borrowers and social factors can affect their decisions regarding loan granting and the repayment collection. When individual reward schemes are introduced, a credit officer may need to trade off monetary rewards against social expectations and rewards. Bonuses based on individual effort, as compared to team based bonuses, reduces free riding and may thus incentivize certain credit officers to work harder. At the same time, key aspects of the job require teamwork between credit officers, and a monetary incentive based on the individual level performance might negatively affect effort on these components.

The study is carried out in collaboration with BRAC Uganda, currently one of the largest development organizations and micro finance institutions in the country with more than 200,000 active borrowers (see www.brac.net/uganda). We collaborate with BRAC to evaluate the effects of a move from a reward scheme for credit officers based on team performance to a scheme based on individual performance. We use a randomized control methodology with randomization at the branch level, and ask how individual level as compared to team level bonus contracts affect outcomes such as credit officer effort, measures of team work, staff well-being and borrower pool characteristics.

Intervention

We collaborate with BRAC Uganda Microfinance to evaluate the effects of a move from a reward scheme for credit officers based on team performance to a scheme based on individual performance. We randomize branch offices to either
(a) treatment (individual performance based bonus) or
(b) control (team performance based bonus)
and ask how individual level as compared to team level bonus contracts affect outcomes such as: credit officer effort, loan quantity and quality, measures of team work, staff and borrower well-being and borrower pool characteristics.

Experimental design

In October 2018, BRAC Uganda Microfinance transitioned from a system with staff bonuses based on team performance to a system in which staff bonuses were based on performance of the individual credit officer. The researchers collaborated with BRAC in this process and randomly assigned 2/3 (106) of the branches to the individual incentive scheme (treatment), while the remaining 1/3 (53) of branches remained with the old, team incentive setup (control group), with small changes made to make the two incentive schemes as comparable as possible.

The randomization was stratified on area (branches are grouped in areas with 4-5 branches in each), and on the following branch level variables: repayment performance in the past year, number of staff and rural/urban status of the branch.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization was conducted by the researchers on a computer. The randomization was stratified (Bruhn and McKenzie, 2009) by Area (Branch offices are grouped into Areas with 4-5 Branches in each), and on the following Branch level variables: repayment performance in the past year, number of staff and rural/urban status of the branch.
Randomization unit
Branch office (Local office). 159 branches are included in the experiment.
Clusters
159 branches.
Observations
159 branches, and data on 700 Credit officers and between 200,000 - 300,000 borrowers with active loans during the experiment period.
Arms
The 159 branches are divided as follows between treatment and control: Individual incentive (treatment): 106 branches Team incentive (control): 53 branches
Primary outcomes
Loan quantity, size and quality (repayment performance), staff turnover, borrower satisfaction with credit officer.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords