Drip Irrigation in the Tropics: Evidence from Southern India

How to cite

Gine, Xavier; Jacoby, Hanan; Fishman, Ram. 2019. "Drip Irrigation in the Tropics: Evidence from Southern India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004504. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4504-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Xavier Gine* , Hanan Jacoby , Ram Fishman

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004504
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4504-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2016-01-01 – 2020-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4504

Abstract

Water scarcity is one of the fundamental challenges facing developing country agriculture. In South Asia, millions of privately-owned borewells have sprung up in the last two decades, to the point where groundwater has become the largest irrigation source in India, especially vital for dry season cultivation. While groundwater exploitation has contributed significantly to poverty reduction in rural India, unregulated drilling has also raised concerns about the sustainability of this crucial resource. Widespread adoption of drip irrigation has been proposed as a promising water-saving solution to the problem of groundwater over-exploitation. However, there is little, if any, rigorous evidence on the benefits, both in terms of agricultural production and potential water savings, of drip irrigation.

We implement a randomized control trial, in which a treatment group of borewell owners was encouraged to participate in a government subsidy program to adopt drip irrigation against a control group that kept the status quo. The study will track agricultural production, farm income, and water use in both groups before and after drip adoption.

Intervention

Subsidies on drip irrigation are distributed through a partnership of India’s central and state governments. The Centrally Sponsored Scheme, released in 2005-06, provides 40% of drip costs, contingent on an additional 10% or more being offered by state governments. There is considerable variation in both the level of subsidy and the delivery of drip subsidies across states. Andhra Pradesh, the state in which this IE will be carried out, has recently increased is subsidy share to 50%, making for a total subsidy of 90%. The overall amount a farmer can receive is capped at levels that depend on land holdings. For the smallest total land holding category (< 10 acres), the cap is 100,000 Rs. per farmer, which allows for a 2 acre drip system, depending on the crop in question and other technical parameters. Farmers who have availed themselves of the subsidy in the past are ineligible to receive additional subsidies for a period of 10 years.

Government certified commercial suppliers can sell drip equipment to farmers at regulated prices and be eligible for the subsidy. In particular, the farmer applies for the subsidy at a local government agency, a process that is often facilitated by the supplier, and involves the submission of documents establishing land ownership and a legal electricity connection for the pump. Once the farmer pays his share (10%) and the application is approved, the drip supplier installs the equipment. Finally, once the government verifies the installation, the remaining 90% of the costs are transferred directly to the supplier.

The intervention was implemented as follows. We offered to pay the farmer’s share of the cost of the drip system (i.e., the 10%, limited to 10,000 Rs. per farmer) and to connect them with a drip company. Jain Irrigation Inc., one of the world’s largest suppliers of drip systems and the one with the largest market share in India, agreed to handle the subsidy application process and the installation of all drip systems and to provide close technical support to participating farmers.

Experimental design

Sampling must account for the localized nature of groundwater markets; the vast majority of these transactions occur between adjacent plots. Thus, the highest level unit of analysis for the study is the adjacency of plots around a reference borewell. Our sampling frame will be drawn from the 2012 Groundwater Markets Survey (henceforth GMS; see Giné and Jacoby, 2019). As in that survey, the owner of the reference borewell will be surveyed with regards to his plot (reference plot), but he will also report on water transfers to any of the adjacent plots. Based on GMS data, inclusive of the reference borewell, there are typically 2-3 wells within an adjacency (mean = 2.5).

The experiment will consist of a treatment arms and a control group. The treatment will entail subsidized drip adoption on the reference borewell plot. As noted, this involves a total investment of around 100,000 Rs. (10% of which will be subsidized through the experimental intervention) that covers a drip system for around 2 acres.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
Adjacency of all plots around a reference borewell belonging to a farmer
Clusters
N/A
Observations
861 adjacencies
Arms
471 control adjacencies and 390 treated adjacencies
Primary outcomes
utcome Name Definition Measurement Level Total profit Total revenue – cost (Rs.) Borewell-plot Cultivated area Acres Borewell-plot Crop choice High water intensity (Wet) vs. low water intensity (Irrigated dry) Borewell-plot Water Sales revenue Rs. Borewell Irrigated area Acres Borewell Well Use Frequency and duration Borewell
Secondary outcomes
Outcome Name Definition Measurement Level Profit per acre for crop under drip Net revenue/Acre Borewell-plot Yield for crop under drip Tons / Acre Borewell-plot Labor Use Quantity (man-hours per acre) Borewell-plot Water Use Frequency and duration Borewell-plot Fertilizer Use Quantity (kg per acre) Borewell-plot Water Transactions Any water transferred to Adjacency neighboring parcels? Amount (area under), price, and nature of contract

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords