Can improving labor market opportunities for marginalized youth alter their social and economic trajectories? We examine this question in the context of Northern Nigeria, a region with a long history of religious tension and violence along Christian-Muslim lines. Using a RCT, we study whether providing skills training to impoverished youth, who largely lack access to formal education and attend Islamic religious schools, can improve their engagement in income generating activities and reduce their participation in religious and political violence. We also examine whether training can promote gender empowerment, both among trained girls as well as their caretakers. The skills training is delivered through “Mafita”, a DfiD-funded initiative implemented by Adam Smith International (ASI). The training we examine in the impact evaluation described here takes the form of an apprenticeship, which provides on the job training in which youth train directly with skilled master craftsmen. The study involves 5,165 subjects and spans a two-year period, with endline data collected over the November 2018-May 2019 period. This document specifies the analysis plan for examining the effects of this training initiative, delineating the econometric specifications and outcomes we plan to examine, which, among others include: employment, income, female empowerment, female confidence, participation in religious and political violence, religious extremism, social networks, and subjective wellbeing.
Intervention
This study evaluate the impact of an apprenticeship intervention delivered by the Mafita program to over 3,000 young men and women. The program is unique in targeting highly marginalized individuals, including many Almajirai. The intervention first delivered 6 months of foundational training in basic literacy, numeracy, project funding, working in teams, and managing relationships. It then linked participants to Master Craft Persons (MCPs) with whom they completed 6-9 months of apprenticeship.
Experimental design
The study is a randomized control trial that targets a pool of 5,165 individuals, 3,066 of whom were randomly assigned into the treatment group while the remaining 2,099 were assigned to the control group.
Design details
Randomization method
Randomization was done electronically in office by a computer using Stata.
Applicants were randomly assigned into a treatment group that received training starting in April 2017 and a control group that was excluded from training. The pool of applicants comprised 5,165 individuals, 3,066 of whom were randomly assigned into the treatment group while the remaining 2,099 were assigned to the control group.
The Mafita program asked to make sure that at least 40% of the treated individuals would be women, at least 20% would be Almajirai (Quranic school boys), and at least 20% would be Islamic Quranic Education (IQE) girls. To ensure this, as well as geographic balance across treatment and control, the intersection of geographical location, applicant type, and gender was used to define randomization strata. The geographical location variable used for this purpose was the local government area (LGA) of the applicant’s residence. Applicant type was one of the following three categories; i) Almajirai boys, ii) IQE girls, and iii) other (PWD, OVC, ESL).
Primary outcomes
1. Income generating activities (in past 30 days)
a. Worked in wage employment (t3>0)
b. Worked self-employed (u3>0)
c. Hours worked in wage employment (t4)
d. Hours worked in self-employment (u4)
e. Total income from wage employment (t12)
f. Total profits from self-employment (u9a)
2. Participation in political and religious violence. For our main analysis of this outcome, we will use responses from a self-completed audio module. We will also do a confirmatory analysis using responses to the same questions elicited in a list experiment (see Section 4.5 for details).
a. Used force or violence for a political cause (r13)
b. Participated in a group that sought to administer justice to someone for behaving badly/immorally (r12)
c. Used force or violence for reasons related to your religion (r9)
d. Participated in any riot, protest or demonstration that turned violent (r10)
3. Attitudes toward religious adherence and religious enforcement
a. Believes it’s important that government ensures people follow religious laws (e6)
b. Vignettes on enforcing violations of religious rules. (For calculation of the index, the outcome will be defined as choosing either “report to authorities” or “beat up” as the answer. In additional analysis, we will also report effects of treatment on the probability of choosing each individual answer.)
i. Willing to punish alcohol consumption (e91)
ii. Willing to punish miniskirt wearing (e101)
iii. Willing to punish blasphemy (e111)
4. Female empowerment
a. Desired/actual age of marriage / fertility (bc2, b2c, b2d, y32)
b. Experienced domestic violence (o21-o215)
c. In a marriage, who do you think should have the greater say in each of the following decisions (outcome defined as probability that decision is taken by wife or both partners equally) (y1-y10)
d. Who decides how income will be used in household (y11)
e. Would like daughters to work outside the home (y12)
f. Various questions on women’s role in society (y14-y21)
g. OK for a husband to beat his wife under various circumstances (y22-y28)
h. OK for a wife to have her own opinion, even if it is different from her husband’s (y29)
i. Would like to be working in 5 years’ time (ha1)
j. Confidence in ability to solve Raven’s matrices (B11)
5. Caregiver female empowerment. In the primary hypothesis we will examine the sample of caregivers who have female wards. Treatment will be defined based on whether the caregiver has any female ward enrolled in Mafita. We will also conduct heterogeneity analysis with boys, to determine if the response of caregivers is significantly different for caregivers who have male wards enrolled in Mafita (as compared to those who have female wards enrolled in the program).
a. Ok for unmarried and married women of ages 14, 18 and 22 to be earning an income inside home and outside home (b2a-e)
b. Age at which women should get married (b3_1); Age at which women should have their first child (b3_3)
c. Various questions on what women should be allowed to do in society and what boys and girls should have to do and have prioritized toward them (b5_1 – b5_8)
d. Various questions on equality in household decision making (b6_1-b6_10)
6. Anti-social behavior. For our main analysis of this outcome, we will use responses from a self-completed audio module. We will also do a confirmatory analysis using responses to the same questions elicited in a list experiment (see Section 4.5 for details).
a. Used tramadol in past 3 months (r2)
b. Used kayan maye in past 3 months (r1)
c. Stolen objects or money from someone, when that person was not present (r5)
d. Stolen objects or money from someone, when that person was present (r6)
e. Gotten into a fight where I tried to physically hurt someone (r3)
f. Did some work for a criminal group (d’an ta’adda) in the past 6 months (r14)
7. Generosity toward other religions: donation experiment. See section 4.4 for details.
Secondary outcomes
8. Attitudes towards political violence
a. Use of violence is justified in protesting an injustice (I3)
b. It is good to use violence to resolve problems (I5)
c. It is ok to use force or violence for political cause (I6)
9. Religious social network (for the purpose of this outcome, a respondent’s social network is defined as the five people he/she spends the most time with)
a. Number of people from other religion in social network (e22)
b. Trusts people from other religions (e45)
c. Trusts leaders from other religions (e57)
10. Religiosity
a. Time spent on religious activities (c22c)
b. Importance of religion in respondent’s life (e35)
c. Other things are more important than religion (r16)
d. Often has a strong sense of God’s presence (h211)
11. Subjective well-being
a. Cantril’s Ladder (h11)
b. MHI-5 (mhi1-mhi5)
12. Self-esteem
a. 7 item index (h212, h31-h39)
13. Skills
a. Literacy assessment (Ia1-Ia5)
b. Numeracy assessment (na1-na7)
14. Assets and consumption
a. 12-item module (Q1-Q7, Q11-Q12)
b. Money spent on various categories (d22a-d22c, d22f-d22k)
15. Job search behavior
a. In the past 6 months, did you actively look for a job? (v1)
b. How many months out of the past 6 months did you actively look for a job (v2)
c. In the past 30 days, did you actively look for a job? (v3)
d. How many days out of the past 30 days did you actively look for a job? (v4)
e. In the past 7 days, did you actively look for a job? (v5)
f. How many days of the past 7 days did you spend actively looking for a job? (v6)
g. In the past 6 months, did you try to start your own business (v7)?
h. In the past 30 days, did you try to start your own business (v8)?
16. Range of social networks (for the purpose of this outcome, a respondent’s social network is defined as the five people he/she spends the most time with)
a. Number of people in social network who are currently employed (e24)
b. Number of people in social network who live in same neighborhood as respondent (e26)
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.