Information Barriers to Public Service Delivery: Innovations in Strengthening Local Political Accountability in Uganda

How to cite

Garcia, Ana; Michelitch, Kristin; Grossman, Guy. 2014. "Information Barriers to Public Service Delivery: Innovations in Strengthening Local Political Accountability in Uganda." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000450. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.450-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ana Garcia* , Kristin Michelitch , Guy Grossman

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0000450
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.450-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2012-05-23 – 2015-08-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/450

Abstract

There is a wide agreement among scholars of African politics that politicians feel little electoral pressure to improve vital public goods and social services. The prevalence of clientelism, ethnic voting and faulty elections are commonly held as the main culprits. Our research project focuses instead on two alternative barriers that weaken democratic accountability across Africa: (1) acute lack of politician performance information in the hands of citizens, which renders citizens ethnic or clientelistic voters; and (2) lack of information in the hands of politicians about service deficiencies in their constituency, which reduces their ability to monitor and sanction service providers. In collaboration with a leading Ugandan NGO – Advocates Coalition for Democracy and the Environment (ACODE) – IPA associated Principal Investigators Guy Grossman and Kristin Michelitch have designed two interventions to directly address these informational barriers: (1) a widespread dissemination of information regarding the performance of local government councilors' to citizens, and (2) opening a new channel of communication from citizens to local government councilors to report public service deficiencies via an innovative text message technology.

Through a randomized controlled trial (RCT) method, the research team is studying the extent to which those two interventions impact the behavior of voters and politicians, and ultimately the provision of public services, such as health and education. Our research design involves a panel survey of citizens, local councilors, and public service providers, pre and post-intervention implementation. This study has clear theoretical and policy implications. Theoretically, it will contribute to the growing micro-foundational body of work on political accountability in low-income countries with weak democratic institutions. Specifically it brings together and improves upon the largely disjointed literatures on political accountability and public service provision. From a policy perspective, the project will generate useful knowledge about the effectiveness of new innovations to improve the provision of education and health services to marginalized populations. More so, this study breaks new ground in the utilization of recent information technology innovations to affect politicians-constituents relations.

Intervention

There are two interventions that are part of this project; disseminating politician performance information to citizens, and allowing citizens to communicate complaints to politicians via innovative text messaging software.

The intensive dissemination consist in community meetings held by ACODE, our partner organization, at parish level. They invite the community leaders of the community and explain them the roles of the councilors and their scores. In addition, the information on councilors' responsibilities and scores is shared with meeting attendees throughout the year via periodic text-messages.

The text message platform allows citizens to send messages to their councilors regarding problems or issues in their subcounties. The service is introduced through a series of community meetings. Reminders of the system are sent to meeting attendees throughout the year via text messages.

The RCT is implemented using a 2x2 factorial design.

Experimental design

We assigning constituencies to the different treatment conditions in a crosscutting research design. Operating in a total of 208 local councilor constituencies (“sub-counties”) in which ACODE issues scorecards, will yield four treatment groups. One quarter of the sub-counties will have the Intense LGCSC Dissemination with SMS communication service (Group A), one quarter will have the SMS communication service and Weak LGCSC Dissemination (Group C), one group will have solely the Intense LGCSC Dissemination (Group B), and one group will receive solely the Weak LGCSC Dissemination (Group D). We will compare change in key outcomes across these four treatment groups to establish the interventions' singular and joint effects.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was conducted using computer based software (Stata)
Randomization unit
The units of randomization are the Special Women Councilor areas that are composed by two-three parishes.
Clusters
218 special women councilors
Observations
471 councilors
Arms
52 special women councilors in control, 55 in intensive dissemination, 52 in SMS platform and 52 in both treatments
Primary outcomes
The research team is focusing on the following outcomes: (i) local councilors’ efforts with respect to public services, (ii) utility and quality of two key social services: health and education at the unit-level, and (iii) citizen turnout and vote-choice basis on politician performance versus clientelism or co-ethnicity (a long-term outcome).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords