Childcare for Childhood and Business Development
How to cite
Gulesci, Selim; Somville, Vincent; Bjorvatn, Kjetil; Ferris, Denise; Nasgowitz, Arne; Vandewalle, Lore. 2019. "Childcare for Childhood and Business Development." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004490. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4490-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Can providing access to childcare services for three to five years old children (i) improve children’s educational (and health) outcomes, (ii) stimulate the development of female businesses and (iii) improve the effectiveness of mainstream business development interventions, such as business grants? These are the key research questions that we plan to address in this research.
Microenterprises are an important source of employment, and developing such enterprises is a key policy concern in most countries, and especially in low-income countries where they employ more than half of the labor force (Hipple, 2010; de Mel et al., 2008). But while there is a lot of optimism about the power of finance for small-scale business development, a growing literature shows that success cannot be taken for granted and may critically depend on the entrepreneur’s gender, educational background, and business skills.
The links between familial obligations and business development are highlighted by a number of recent studies. Using capital grants to measure returns to capital in Sri Lankan microenterprises, De Mel et al (2009) show that male-owned microenterprises had high returns to capital, while female-owned enterprises did not benefit from the grants. Fafchamps et al (2014) find that in Ghana, grants to microenterprises have differential effect by gender of the entrepreneur and by kind of transfer (in cash or in kind). Berge, Bjorvatn and Tungodden (2015) show that combining human and financial capital interventions caused a substantial improvement for male entrepreneurs, but not for female entrepreneurs. The authors suggest that social constraints - and in particular domestic obligations - could be an important explanation for the lack of impact for female entrepreneurs.
In this project, we propose an innovative way to study microenterprise development, by fully integrating domestic constraints in the study of business development and by combining a direct business support intervention with a family support intervention. We will collaborate with BRAC in Uganda to conduct a randomized experiment that will provide randomly selected women with: (i) subsidized access to childcare (the family support intervention) (ii) a business grant (the business support intervention) (iii) childcare and a business grant together (to understand complementarities). A fourth group will be kept as control.
References:
Berge, L. I., K. Bjorvatn and B. Tungodden (2015). Human and Financial Capital for Microenterprise Development: Evidence from a Field and Lab Experiment, Management Science, 61(4): 707–722.
de Mel, Suresh, D. McKenzie and C. Woodruff (2008). Returns to Capital in Microenterprises: Evidence from a Field Experiment, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 123 (4): 1329-1371.
de Mel, Suresh, D. McKenzie and C. Woodruff (2009). Are Women more Credit Constrained? Experimental Evidence on Gender and Microenterprise Returns, American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 1(3): 1-32.
Fafchamps, M., D. McKenzie, S. Quinn and C. Woodruff (2014). Microenterprise Growth and the Flypaper Effect: Evidence from a Randomized Experiment in Ghana, Journal of Development Economics, 106: 211-226.
Hipple, S. F. (2010). Self-employment in the United States, Monthly Labor Review, September 2010: 17-32.
Intervention
The first intervention is offering a subsidy to cover the tuition and lunch fees for the target child to attend nursery school for a full year (three terms). The second intervention is providing a cash grant, equivalent to the average value of the subsidy received by individuals in the first intervention (average at the community level). The cash transfers will be paid in three installments, corresponding to the start of school terms so that the timing of the cash payments is identical to the payment for child care.
As discussed above, other studies have found rather modest impacts of providing grants to women, but our hypothesis is that this may be due to binding household constraints. Therefore, we will explore whether there are complementarities between child care and cash grants: the combination of a cash grant and childcare is the third treatment arm. In addition, there will be a control group that receives neither family nor business support. As a result, there are four different treatment arms:
- C – Control - Women who will not receive child care support, nor cash grant.
- T1 – Treatment 1 – Women who will receive child care only.
- T2 – Treatment 2 – Women who will receive cash grant only.
- T3 – Complementarities – Women who will receive both child care and cash grant.
Experimental design
The sample:
First, we selected three districts in Western Uganda (Kasese, Kyenjojo and Kabarole), three districts in central Uganda (Mukono, Masaka and Mityana) and three districts in Eastern Uganda (Mbale, Iganga and Jinja).
In these districts we identified 454 communities containing at least one nursery school. To identify eligible households, we conducted a census in September 2018 in each of the 454 communities.
To be eligible, a household has to satisfy three criteria: (i) the female caregiver should be present within the household (e.g. mother or grandmother), (ii) the household should have one (and only one) child in the age range 3-5 and (iii) the children shouldn’t already be attending full time childcare (but we allowed for children attending part-time child-care).
We also wanted to have a sufficiently large group of households both with and without younger siblings (below 3 years old). To that end we restricted the study samples to villages that have at least three households that satisfy the three criteria and do not have younger siblings, and at least one household that satisfies the three criteria and has younger siblings.
Finally, from the list of eligible households, we randomly selected 1496 in 400 communities to participate in the baseline survey.
Data collection:
The baseline was conducted in November and December 2018 and consisted of two surveys: a “household” survey and a “childhood development” survey. The two surveys were conducted by separate teams. The respondent for the household survey was the main female caregiver of the target child.
The household survey collected four main categories of information: (i) The socio-economic status of the household, including detailed information on business ownership (where applicable), assets, financial loans and savings; (ii) labor supply of the respondent and other household members; (iii) time use of the mother, father, and/or other main caregivers of the target child; and (iv) data on attitudes towards risk, happiness, stress, social attitudes and financial literacy.
The childhood development survey collected information on the target child using the International Development and Early Learning Assessment (IDELA) instrument developed by Save the Children. The tool consists of a battery of questions and tests that aim to measure the level of competency or mastery that children possess across four domains - motor skills, early literacy, early numeracy and socio-emotional skills.
We will conduct three follow-up surveys:
July-August 2019: Short-run follow-up survey – We will collect information on a limited set of outcomes from the household survey, but will not collect data on childhood development outcomes. From the households, we will collect the following information: questions related to the socio-economic status (excluding information related to loans and savings), time use of the mother, father, and/or other main caregivers of the target child and information on happiness and stress.
November-December 2019: Midline survey – We will collect data on the same set of indicators as at baseline, including the childhood development survey.
November-December 2020: Midline survey – We will collect data on the same set of indicators as at baseline and midline, including the childhood development survey.
Randomization:
Following the baseline survey, we randomized the 1496 households that were surveyed into the four different groups: C, T1, T2 and T3.
The randomization was conducted at the individual level. The following variables were used as randomization strata: district indicators, an indicator for whether the target child has younger siblings, whether the target child was already attending daycare at baseline, respondent’s occupation at baseline, and whether the mother of the target child resided in the same household at baseline.
As a result, out of the 1496 households that were part of the baseline survey, 363 were randomly allocated to T1, 364 to T2, 357 to T3 and 412 to C. These are not symmetric, because the number of observations differed across strata and it was not always divisible by four.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.