Mindsets: The Influence of Intelligence Theories on Educational Outcomes
How to cite
Cruz, Tassia. 2019. "Mindsets: The Influence of Intelligence Theories on Educational Outcomes." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004479. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4479-2.3
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This project seeks to assess how an intervention - growth mindset workshops for 5th grade teachers - impacts teachers’ ways of thinking about their own attitudes, and how these changes impact their attitudes toward students in the classroom, and, consequently, students’ results. Specifically, we would like to understand the impact of issues related to teachers’ mindsets that are particular to the context of students in vulnerable situations (such as in public schools of Rio de Janeiro municipality, Brazil). For this purpose, we ran a two-level clustered randomized experiment with treatment at the second (school) level. We randomly selected 50% of 178 candidate schools from the municipality into a treatment group and the other 50% into a control group. The randomization was done by pairing, using the predicted value of the students' results inferred from the characteristics of the schools in previous years. Next, we will assess how much teachers’ and their students’ mindsets changed as a result of the intervention. We will also measure, through classroom observations, how teachers’ practices, performance and dynamics within their classes are being impacted by the intervention. Finally, we will look at how this process ultimately affects student scores in standardized tests. This experiment allows us to address the following set of questions: do teachers working with students in vulnerable social contexts change their pedagogical practices after the proposed intervention? Do such changes influence the outcomes of their students? Do these changes ameliorate students’, classes’ and schools’ achievement gaps? Ultimately, we believe that investigating the entire causal chain linking the teacher's shift in mindset to eventual reductions in academic performance inequalities within the classroom is critical to maximizing the impacts of such interventions.
Intervention
The intervention was a structured workshop of 5 weeks to elementary education teachers with the objective of promoting pedagogical practices with "growth mindset". Our hypothesis is that, in promoting changes in the beliefs about the intelligence, the implementation of mindset workshops helps teachers in their pedagogical practices to improve student learning. The workshops included discussions about brain functioning and their relation to the concept of mindset, the re-signification of error as fundamental to the learning process, and the elaboration of strategies to deal with error and frustration in the learning process. Finally, the workshops dealt with the role of effort and the concept of “stereotype threat” (Steele and Aronson 1995) in vulnerable contexts.
Experimental design
We ran a two-level clustered randomized experiment with treatment at the second (school) level. We randomly selected 50% of 178 candidate schools from the municipality to the treatment group and the other 50% to the control group. The randomization was done by pairing, using the predicted value of the students’ results inferred from the characteristics of the schools in previous years. It is estimated that schools have the harmonic average of 60 students in the 5th grade, divided on average in two classes, according to data from 2018.
Design details
Materials
Papers from this trial
- Cruz, Tassia, Teacher Mindsets and Student Learning: A Randomized Intervention in Rio de Janeiro. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=7124184 http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.7124184
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.