Volunteer Now or Later: The Effects of Effort Time Allocation on Donations
How to cite
Su, Yuxin; Capra, C. Monica; Jiang, Bing. 2019. "Volunteer Now or Later: The Effects of Effort Time Allocation on Donations." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004472. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4472-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
If you were asked to volunteer now or later, what would you choose? We present a model of volunteering that allows for the allocation of effort donations across time. We derive hypotheses regarding the effect of time flexibility on overall effort donations and on the tendency to renege on a promise to donate. We test the predictions of our model using an online experiment with a large sample of Amazon Mechanical Turk workers. We find that flexibility in choosing when to allocate effort donations increases overall donations despite of the added incentive
to renege on a promise to donate. Furthermore, compared to those who donate money, those who donate effort are more generous. The results provide support to the idea that donating effort (i.e., volunteering) differs, in fundamental ways, from monetary charitable donations
Intervention
On Day 1, participants assigned to Group 1 (G1) were given the option to volunteer for charity now or not volunteer at all (i.e., directly refuse). Those assigned to Group 2 (G2) could choose to volunteer in three days or not volunteer at all (i.e., directly refuse). Individuals assigned to Group 3 (G3) were given the options to volunteer now, volunteer in three days, or not volunteer at all. To compare effort donations to money donations, we added an additional treatment, G2M, which was similar to G2, but allowed participants to donate money instead of effort to benefit the charity. On Day 4, subjects in G2, G2M, and G3 who planned to volunteer were given the option to confirm or renege on their planned donations.
Experimental design
On Day 1, subjects answered demographic questions and a set of "filler" quizzes and surveys. These included questions about exercise and eating, IQ-type questions, a quantitative time preference survey, and self-efficacy questions. At the end of the survey, all the subjects were directed to the donation decision and were asked whether they would be willing to answer additional questions to benefit a GiveWell charity of their choice. We call this additional survey the volunteer survey. All subjects in all groups were asked to affirm their initial donation decisions. Those in G2, G2M, and G3 who chose to answer the volunteer survey in three days were also given the option, on Day 4, to confirm or renege on their choice. If on Day 4, those who planned to volunteer chose to confirm, they were directed to the volunteer survey. In contrast, if they reneged on their planned donation, they skipped the volunteer survey and proceed to the follow-up survey. At the end of the entire survey, participants were asked to explain why they chose to volunteer or to renege on a plan to volunteer.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.