Community Cellular Networks: An Experimental Evaluation in the Philippines

How to cite

Keleher, Niall; Troland, Erin; Rezaee, Arman; Blumenstock, Joshua. 2019. "Community Cellular Networks: An Experimental Evaluation in the Philippines." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004469. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4469-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Niall Keleher* , Erin Troland , Arman Rezaee , Joshua Blumenstock

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004469
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4469-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2016-07-01 – 2020-06-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D83, L86, O18, O31
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4469

Abstract

Despite the rapid expansion of mobile coverage in the developing world, roughly 10% of the world's population still lives beyond the reach of a cell tower and all of the platforms, products, and services that cell towers make possible. This study investigates the impact of a new type of cellular connectivity designed specifically to address the "last mile" problem: the Community Cellular Network. Built on open-source technology, the Community Cellular Network provides community-owned cellular infrastructure at one-tenth of the cost of traditional mobile towers.
Our goal is to develop a deeper understanding of the social and economic impacts of first-time access to a cellular network in isolated communities in the Philippines. We use a two-stage randomized control trial in which we (i) randomly assign villages to receive or not receive a new cell tower; and (ii) within treated villages, randomize the price that households paid to access these networks. This pre-analysis plan describes how we plan to study the impacts of cellular access on social network structure, and several social and economic outcomes.

Intervention

1. Community Cellular Networks
The primary intervention is the installation of cellphone towers in selected sites. Researchers from the University of California, Berkeley developed a new mobile phone technology --- the Community Cellular Network (CCN) --- that provides local coverage at one-tenth of the cost of traditional mobile towers. The CCN is designed specifically for rural settings with intermittent power and is designed to be owned and maintained by local community members with modest technical training (Heimerl and Brewer, 2010). Over the past several years, we have been collaborating with those who developed the CCN and researchers at the University of the Philippines, Diliman, to deploy CCNs in several remote and isolated villages in the Philippines.

2. Price Promotions
We offered promotions to customers through a second randomized experiment. The first dimension is a free credit of 100 Pesos loaded directly to the customer's balance. The second dimension is a type of tariff discount provided to customers. 50% tariff discounts were applied to either local on-network calls or long-distance calls. All customers, including those in the promo control group, received five free long-distance text messages. To account for potential sharing of phones within the household, treatment assignment was done at the household level.

Experimental design

By leveraging a new low-cost technology, and by cultivating strong local relationships, we created a truly unique opportunity to conduct a randomized control trial of Community Cellular Networks in a set of 14 geographically isolated villages in the Aurora province of the Philippines. The randomized control trial had two stages. The first was a village-level treatment, where a "staggered roll-out" design randomly determined which seven of the 14 villages received a CCN between September 2017 and September 2019, as well as the timing of each installation. The second stage was a household-level treatment, through which we reduced the cost of making phone calls and sending text messages to specific households. This second stage will allow us to precisely estimate the demand for cellular connectivity (and all that comes with it), and will create random household-level variation in communication costs, which we can in turn use to identify the impact of connectivity on other outcomes.

Design details

Randomization method
Community Cellular Networks - Matched-pairs randomization done on a computer using the R package, nbpMatching, from Beck, Lu, and Greevy (2016) Price Promotions - Random assignment to price promotions done in Stata.
Randomization unit
Community Cellular Networks - randomized at the village/site level Price Promotions - Randomized at the household level
Clusters
Community Cellular Networks - 14 sites Price Promotions - 1131 eligible households
Observations
Community Cellular Networks - 2,370 households Price Promotions - 6,613 adults
Arms
Community Cellular Networks - 1. Treatment (7 sites) 2. Control (7) Price Promotions - 1. No promotions (187 households) 2. Free phone credit (191) 3. Local discount (183) 4. Local discount plus free credit (186) 5. Long distance discount (191) 6. Long distance discount plus free credit (193)
Primary outcomes
We will test four families of hypotheses: (i) access to communications, (ii) social networks, (iii) informedness, and (iv) economic outcomes. Each family contains one or more specific outcomes that we hypothesize are likely to be impacted by treatment. Within the family access to communications, we have one hypothesis: 1. Increased access to communications Within the family social networks, we have two hypotheses: 2. Increased social connectedness - local 3. Increased social connectedness - long-distance Within the family informedness, we have two hypotheses: 4. Increased informedness 5. Increased disaster preparedness Finally, within the family economic outcomes, we have ?ve hypotheses: 6. Increased market access 7. Changed migration 8. Changed remittances and risk-sharing 9. Changed income and expenditures 10. Changed subjective well-being
Secondary outcomes
We have two secondary families of outcomes The first is political economy, which has hypotheses: 1. Increased political participation 2. Increased political manipulation 3. Increased political-economic knowledge The second is intra-household decision-making, which has hypotheses: 4. Increased role of women in income decisions 5. Increased role of women in fishing/agriculture decisions 6. Increased role of women in control of resources 7. Decreased spousal difference in reported fish/crop prices

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords