RAND and Innovations for Poverty Action (IPA) are conducting a rigorous evaluation of a credit-building loan offered at a credit union in the Midwest, financial counseling offered over the phone, and a product add-on that encourages automated payments into a savings account called “Pay Yourself Back.” The evaluation employs a cross-cutting encouragement design, with the loan product and counseling services randomly encouraged at the start of study participation. For participants who are encouraged to take up the loan product and open the loan, the “Pay Yourself Back” add-on will be randomized six months prior to the completion of loan repayment. The study will examine the impact of the loan product, counseling services, and the encouragement for automated savings payments on credit, savings, debt, and loan repayment rates in the short and long term. It will also examine whether self-selection into the loan product is indicative of credit worthiness.
Intervention
Hidden.
Experimental design
Hidden.
Design details
Randomization method
The cross-cutting randomization of the loan product and counseling services will be implemented by surveyors in credit union branches using a random number generator on a computer. Surveyors will input study participants’ information into a database, which will randomly generate their treatment assignment and display assignment to surveyors. Random assignment between 'easy on-ramp' and 'high angle on-ramp' to open the loan will be contingent on interest in the loan product. The encouragement to enroll in automated savings deposits will be implemented over the phone using a random number generator on a computer.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
2400 credit union members
Observations
2400 credit union members
Arms
T1) Not interested in the loan, not encouraged to call phone financial counseling: 360
T2) Not interested in the loan, encouraged to call phone financial counseling: 360
T3) Interested in the loan, easy on ramp, not encouraged to call phone financial counseling: 420
T4) Interested in the loan, easy on ramp, encouraged to call phone financial counseling: 420
T5) Interested in the loan, high-angle on ramp, not encouraged to call phone financial counseling: 420
T6) Interested in the loan, high-angle on ramp, encouraged to call phone financial counseling: 420
Total: 2400
Note: These estimates assume that 70% of study participants are interested in the loan product.
Additional randomization on credit-building loan borrowers:
T7) Encouraged to automate savings payments (“Pay Yourself Back”): 420
T8) Not encouraged to automate savings payment (“Pay Yourself Back”): 420
Note: These estimates assume that of the study participants who are interested in the loan and encouraged to open it, 840 open the loan.
Primary outcomes
➢ Credit Score
- FICO
- Vantage Score
➢ Credit Report Measures
- Balance on recent loans
- Number of accounts late
- Open revolving credit limit
➢ Debt/Credit Attitudes and Behavior
- Credit awareness
- Debt repayment
- Future credit usage
➢ Savings Levels
➢ Selection Bias of those who choose to take up credit-building loan
- Comparing credit and savings outcomes of those who are interested in the loan and not encouraged to take it up with those of the group who are not interested in the loan
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.